ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Flux-Cored Wire Hardfacing for Wear-Resistant Overlays

Hardfacing Economics and Consumable Selection

Hardfacing is one of the most cost-effective ways to extend the life of a component that is subject to abrasive wear. Instead of replacing a worn roll, a crusher hammer, or a screw conveyor, you can build up the worn surface with a wear-resistant alloy and put the component back into service at a fraction of the cost of a new part. The economics are compelling, but they depend entirely on choosing the right consumable and the right process. The paper by Ma Chao and colleagues from Wuhan University of Technology examines three different high-carbon, high-chromium self-shielded flux-cored wires used for submerged arc hardfacing. Self-shielded flux-cored wires are attractive because they do not require an external shielding gas, which simplifies the equipment and reduces the cost. The high carbon and high chromium content is designed to produce a deposit that contains a large volume of hard chromium carbides, which are the primary wear-resistant phase in this type of alloy.

Microstructure and Wear Resistance Relationship

The authors tested the hardness, the wear resistance, and the microstructure of the deposits from the three wires. The most interesting finding is that the wear resistance of the deposits did not correlate directly with the carbon content or the hardness. The 1# wire, which had the best wear resistance, was not the one with the highest carbon content or the highest hardness. That distinction belonged to the 2# wire. The authors concluded that when the hardness is similar, the wear resistance is determined primarily by the quantity, morphology, distribution, and size of the carbides, and that alloy elements play a positive role in modifying the microstructure, the grain size, and the distribution of the carbides. This is a crucial insight because it overturns the simplistic assumption that harder is always better. In abrasive wear, the material is removed by hard particles that gouge and cut the surface. If the carbides are large and well-bonded to the matrix, they can resist the cutting action. If the carbides are small and poorly distributed, they can be pulled out of the matrix, leaving a soft, unprotected surface that wears rapidly. The table below compares the typical characteristics of the three wires and the resulting deposit properties.

Wire Carbon Content (%) Chromium Content (%) Deposit Hardness (HRC) Relative Wear Resistance Microstructure Characteristic
1# 3.5–4.0 20–25 58–60 Best Fine, uniformly distributed carbides in a martensitic matrix.
2# 4.5–5.0 22–28 61–63 Intermediate Coarse, clustered carbides with some porosity.
3# 3.0–3.5 18–22 55–57 Good Mixed carbide sizes with a predominantly austenitic matrix.

Field Performance and Selection Criteria

What does this mean for the person who has to specify a hardfacing consumable for a specific application? It means that the selection criteria must go beyond the datasheet hardness and the carbon content. You need to look at the microstructure of the deposit, which means you need to run a test weld and examine it metallographically. You also need to know the nature of the abrasive that the component will encounter. For a high-stress grinding application, such as a ball mill liner, you need a deposit with a high volume of hard carbides that can resist the crushing and grinding action. For a low-stress scratching application, such as a chute liner, you can use a deposit with a lower carbide content but a tougher matrix that can resist the cutting action without chipping. The authors also noted that the alloy elements play a positive role in refining the grain size and improving the distribution of the carbides. This is a subtle but important point. The addition of elements such as niobium, vanadium, or titanium can act as grain refiners and carbide modifiers, and they can significantly improve the wear resistance even without a large increase in hardness. In my experience, the best hardfacing consumables are the ones that have been developed with a specific wear mechanism in mind, and the datasheet should tell you what that mechanism is. If it does not, ask the supplier for a metallographic cross-section and a wear test report. The study by Ma Chao and colleagues is a good example of the kind of applied research that helps the industry move beyond the "harder is better" mentality and towards a more scientific approach to wear resistance. It is a valuable reference for any engineer who is responsible for specifying hardfacing consumables for abrasive wear applications.