Plasma Arc Surfacing of Fe90 Alloy: Process Optimisation and Wear Performance
Literature Overview and Context
This paper by Lu Hailong and Kang Jiandong from Jilin Vocational College of Industry and Technology and Liaohe Oilfield Exploration Bureau Machinery Factory investigates plasma arc surfacing (PTA) of Fe90 alloy onto low-carbon steel. The Fe90 alloy is a high-chromium, high-carbon iron-based alloy designed for wear resistance. The authors used plasma arc surfacing with varying welding currents, then measured hardness with a Rockwell hardness tester and wear resistance with a wet sand rubber wheel abrasive wear tester. They used optical microscopy and SEM to analyse the microstructure of the deposited layers.
The key findings are that the surface of the deposited layer has better performance than the side, and that at a welding current of 180 A, the deposited layer achieves optimum performance with a surface hardness of 67.7 HRC and the best wear resistance.
Technical Interpretation and Metallurgical Reasoning
Plasma Arc Surfacing Process Characteristics
Plasma arc surfacing uses a constricted arc between a tungsten electrode and the workpiece. The arc is highly concentrated, with energy densities significantly higher than conventional TIG or GMAW. This allows high deposition rates with low dilution, which is critical for hardfacing alloys. The dilution rate in PTA is typically 5 to 15 percent, compared to 20 to 30 percent for GMAW and 30 to 50 percent for SAW.
Low dilution is important for Fe90 alloy because the alloy relies on its high carbon and chromium content to form hard carbides. If the substrate dilutes the deposit, the carbon and chromium levels drop, and the hardness and wear resistance decrease. The paper's finding that the surface has better performance than the side is consistent with this. The surface is the last to solidify and has the highest alloy content, while the side is closer to the substrate and has higher dilution.
Effect of Welding Current on Microstructure
The welding current controls the heat input and, therefore, the cooling rate and the dilution. At low current, the heat input is low, the cooling rate is high, and the deposit may have a fine microstructure but poor fusion with the substrate. At high current, the heat input is high, the cooling rate is low, and the deposit may have a coarse microstructure with high dilution.
The paper found that 180 A is the optimum. At this current, the heat input is sufficient to ensure good fusion and moderate dilution, while the cooling rate is high enough to produce a fine microstructure with uniformly distributed hard carbides. The hardness of 67.7 HRC is typical for Fe90 alloy, which contains about 4 to 5 percent carbon and 25 to 30 percent chromium. The carbides are primarily M₇C₃ and M₂₃C₆, which are very hard and provide excellent abrasive wear resistance.
Wear Mechanism and the Role of Carbides
In abrasive wear, the hard carbides in the deposit resist cutting and ploughing by abrasive particles. The matrix, which is typically martensitic or austenitic, holds the carbides in place. If the matrix is too soft, the carbides are pulled out and the wear rate increases. If the matrix is too hard, it may be brittle and crack under impact.
The paper's finding that the surface has better wear resistance than the side is explained by the microstructure. The surface has a higher carbide volume fraction and a more uniform distribution. The side, being closer to the substrate, has higher dilution and a lower carbide volume fraction. This is a common issue in hardfacing and is why multi-layer deposits are often used to achieve the desired properties.
Integration with Engineering Practice
Shop Floor Experience with Plasma Arc Surfacing
Plasma arc surfacing is a precision process. It is used in applications where low dilution and high deposit quality are critical, such as valve seats, pump components, and moulds. It is also used for hardfacing of drill bits and other oilfield equipment. The process requires careful control of the arc current, voltage, travel speed, powder feed rate, and plasma gas flow.
In my experience, the most common issue with PTA is inconsistency in the deposit thickness and composition. This is often caused by variations in powder feed rate or by fluctuations in the arc current. The paper's finding that 180 A is the optimum current for Fe90 alloy is useful, but it is specific to the equipment and powder used. Each PTA system has its own characteristics, and the optimum parameters must be determined by trial.
The Importance of Dilution Control
Dilution is the key parameter in hardfacing. If dilution is too high, the deposit loses its alloy content and hardness. If dilution is too low, the deposit may have poor fusion and may spall. The paper's finding that the surface has better properties than the side is a direct consequence of dilution. In multi-layer deposits, the first layer has high dilution, but subsequent layers have lower dilution as the substrate is further away.
For applications where the deposit is used as-is, such as a single-layer hardfacing, the dilution must be carefully controlled. For applications where multiple layers are applied, the first layer can be considered a transition layer, and the final layer is the one that matters. In practice, I would recommend applying at least two layers for Fe90 alloy to ensure that the final surface has the desired hardness and wear resistance.
Standards and Quality Control
There is no specific standard for plasma arc surfacing of Fe90 alloy. The relevant standards are general hardfacing standards, such as AWS A5.21 for surfacing electrodes and wires, and ISO 14175 for filler gases. For quality control, the key tests are hardness, wear resistance, and microstructure.
For a hardfacing application, I would specify the following:
| Parameter | Requirement | Test Method |
|---|---|---|
| Surface hardness | Minimum 60 HRC | Rockwell C |
| Dilution | Maximum 15 percent | Metallographic section |
| Wear rate | As per specification | Wet sand rubber wheel |
| Porosity | No visible porosity | Radiographic or section |
| Cracks | No cracks in deposit | Dye penetrant |
Key Questions and Reflections
Why Is 180 A the Optimum?
The paper reports that 180 A gives the best combination of hardness and wear resistance. This is likely because at lower currents, the heat input is insufficient to melt the powder completely, leading to unmelted particles and poor fusion. At higher currents, the heat input is excessive, leading to high dilution and a coarse microstructure.
In my experience, the optimum current depends on the powder feed rate and the travel speed. A higher powder feed rate requires a higher current to melt the powder. A higher travel speed requires a higher current to maintain the same heat input per unit length. The paper's finding is a starting point, but each application must be optimised.
What About the Substrate?
The paper uses low-carbon steel as the substrate. In practice, Fe90 alloy is often applied to medium-carbon steel, cast iron, or tool steel. The substrate composition affects the dilution and the formation of the heat-affected zone. For high-carbon substrates, the HAZ may be martensitic and susceptible to cracking. Preheating is often required.
For cast iron substrates, the carbon in the substrate can migrate into the deposit, increasing the carbon content and making the deposit harder but more brittle. This is a common issue in hardfacing of cast iron components. The paper does not address this, but it is an important practical consideration.
What Is the Right Hardness?
A hardness of 67.7 HRC is very high. This is suitable for applications where abrasive wear is the primary failure mode, such as agricultural implements, earthmoving equipment, and mining tools. However, it is not suitable for applications where impact is also a factor, as the deposit may be too brittle.
For applications with combined abrasion and impact, a lower hardness with higher toughness may be preferable. This can be achieved by modifying the alloy composition or by using a different hardfacing material. The paper's Fe90 alloy is a good choice for pure abrasion, but for impact applications, a more ductile alloy such as a martensitic stainless steel may be better.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper provides useful data on the plasma arc surfacing of Fe90 alloy. The finding that 180 A is the optimum current is valuable, but it is specific to the equipment and powder used. The key lesson is that PTA is a precision process that requires careful parameter control and that the optimum parameters must be determined for each application.
For the shop floor, the key takeaways are:
- Always determine the optimum current for each powder and substrate combination. Do not assume that the parameters from one application will work for another.
- Control the powder feed rate and travel speed carefully. Variations in these parameters will affect the deposit thickness and composition.
- Apply at least two layers for Fe90 alloy to ensure that the final surface has the desired properties.
- Monitor dilution by sectioning the deposit and measuring the alloy content in the first and subsequent layers.
For the delivery site, the key lesson is that hardfacing is not a one-size-fits-all solution. The deposit must be matched to the wear mechanism and the operating conditions. A deposit that is too hard may crack under impact, while a deposit that is too soft may wear rapidly. The paper provides a good starting point for Fe90 alloy, but the final decision must be based on the specific application.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper is a useful reference for anyone involved in hardfacing with Fe90 alloy. It provides data on the optimum current and the resulting hardness and wear resistance. It also highlights the importance of dilution control and the difference between the surface and side properties of the deposit.
Looking forward, I would like to see more research on the effect of post-weld heat treatment on the properties of Fe90 deposits. In some applications, a stress-relief treatment may be beneficial to reduce residual stresses and improve toughness. I would also like to see more work on the effect of the substrate composition on the deposit properties, particularly for high-carbon and cast iron substrates.
In my own practice, I would use this paper as a reference for setting PTA parameters for Fe90 alloy and for establishing acceptance criteria for hardness and wear resistance. I would also use it to train operators on the importance of parameter control and dilution management. The paper is a reminder that in hardfacing, the process parameters are just as important as the alloy composition.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd