Additional Filler Wire Submerged Arc Surfacing of 12Cr2Mo1V Steel Bosses: Process Feasibility and Efficiency Gains
Literature Overview and Context
This paper by Wang Xuejiao, He Peng, Yan Junwen and Wu Chenglin from Erzhong (Deyang) Heavy Equipment Co., Ltd. investigates the use of additional filler wire submerged arc welding (SAW) for surfacing the boss body of 12Cr2Mo1V steel in hydrogenation reactor shells. The motivation is the low manufacturing efficiency of single-wire SAW for this application. The authors studied the process feasibility of additional filler wire SAW and evaluated the mechanical properties of the deposited metal.
The key findings are that additional filler wire SAW provides good weldability on 12Cr2Mo1V steel, that the mechanical properties fully meet the base material requirements, that Charpy V-notch impact tests at -30°C all exceed 54 J, and that the temper embrittlement resistance meets the requirement of vTr54 + 3ΔvTr54 ≤ 0°C. The two-gun six-wire additional filler wire SAW can improve production efficiency by 200 to 250 percent compared to single-wire SAW.
Technical Interpretation and Metallurgical Reasoning
The Challenge of Surfacing 12Cr2Mo1V Steel
12Cr2Mo1V is a Cr-Mo-V steel used for hydrogenation reactor shells. It is designed for high-temperature, high-pressure hydrogen service and has excellent resistance to hydrogen attack and temper embrittlement. The steel contains about 2.25 percent chromium, 1.0 percent molybdenum, and small additions of vanadium. The vanadium forms fine carbides that provide strength and creep resistance.
Surfacing the boss body of such a reactor is a critical operation. The boss is a nozzle or support attachment that is welded to the shell. The weld must have the same properties as the base material, including resistance to hydrogen attack and temper embrittlement. The conventional method is single-wire SAW, which is slow and requires many passes to build up the required thickness.
Additional Filler Wire SAW Process
Additional filler wire SAW is a variant of SAW where one or more additional filler wires are fed into the weld pool alongside the main electrode. The additional wires are not energised; they are melted by the heat of the arc and the weld pool. This increases the deposition rate without increasing the heat input per unit length, which is critical for maintaining the mechanical properties.
The two-gun six-wire configuration uses two welding guns, each with one main electrode and two additional filler wires, for a total of six wires. This allows a very high deposition rate while maintaining a low heat input per pass. The low heat input is important for controlling the cooling rate and the microstructure of the deposit.
Mechanical Properties and Temper Embrittlement
The paper reports that the impact toughness at -30°C exceeds 54 J, which is excellent for this steel. The temper embrittlement resistance is evaluated using the vTr54 + 3ΔvTr54 ≤ 0°C criterion. This criterion is based on the shift in the transition temperature caused by step cooling, which simulates the embrittlement that occurs during service.
The vTr54 is the temperature at which the impact energy is 54 J, and ΔvTr54 is the shift in this temperature after step cooling. The criterion requires that the sum of the vTr54 and three times the shift is less than or equal to 0°C. This ensures that the steel remains tough even after prolonged exposure to elevated temperatures.
The paper's finding that the deposit meets this criterion is significant. It means that the additional filler wire SAW process does not introduce any embrittlement that would compromise the service performance of the reactor.
Integration with Engineering Practice
Shop Floor Experience with Hydrogenation Reactor Fabrication
Hydrogenation reactors are among the most demanding pressure vessels. They operate at high pressure, high temperature, and in a hydrogen-rich environment. The materials must have excellent resistance to hydrogen attack, which requires a minimum chromium content and a fine, stable carbide structure. The welding process must be carefully controlled to avoid any defects that could lead to failure.
In my experience, the surfacing of bosses and nozzles on hydrogenation reactors is a critical path item. The conventional single-wire SAW process is slow, and the boss surfacing can take days or even weeks. This delays the overall fabrication schedule and increases the cost. The additional filler wire SAW process offers a significant improvement in efficiency, which is valuable for the manufacturer.
Efficiency Gains and Economic Impact
The paper reports a 200 to 250 percent improvement in production efficiency with the two-gun six-wire configuration. This is a substantial gain. For a large reactor with multiple bosses, the time savings can be significant. The reduction in welding time also reduces the labor cost and the energy consumption, which contributes to the "green manufacturing" goals mentioned in the paper.
However, the efficiency gain is not free. The additional filler wire SAW process requires more complex equipment, including wire feeders for the additional wires and a more sophisticated control system. The process also requires more careful setup and monitoring to ensure that the additional wires are fed correctly and that the weld pool is stable.
Quality Control and Process Qualification
The paper reports that the process qualification tests met all requirements. This is essential for the use of the process in pressure vessel fabrication. The qualification must include mechanical property testing, including tensile, impact, and bend tests, as well as the temper embrittlement evaluation.
For a hydrogenation reactor, the qualification must also include a hydrogen attack test, which is not mentioned in the paper but is required by some standards. The test involves exposing the material to hydrogen at high temperature and pressure and measuring the loss in strength and ductility.
Key Questions and Reflections
Why Is the Impact Toughness So High?
The paper reports impact toughness above 54 J at -30°C. This is excellent for a Cr-Mo-V steel. The high toughness is likely due to the fine microstructure produced by the low heat input of the additional filler wire SAW process. The low heat input results in a fine-grained deposit with a uniform distribution of carbides, which provides good toughness.
In conventional single-wire SAW, the heat input is higher, and the grain size is coarser. This can reduce the toughness. The additional filler wire process allows a higher deposition rate without increasing the heat input, which is the key to maintaining good toughness.
What About the Heat-Affected Zone?
The paper focuses on the deposited metal, but the HAZ is also important. The HAZ in 12Cr2Mo1V steel can be susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking and temper embrittlement. The low heat input of the additional filler wire process reduces the HAZ width and the time at high temperature, which can reduce the risk of these problems.
However, the HAZ is also affected by the preheat and interpass temperature. For thick sections, a high preheat is required to prevent cracking, but this can also increase the HAZ width. The paper does not provide details on the preheat and interpass temperature, but these are critical parameters that must be controlled.
What Is the Right Deposition Rate?
The paper reports a 200 to 250 percent improvement in efficiency. This is a significant gain, but it is not the maximum possible. The deposition rate can be increased further by using more wires or by increasing the wire diameter. However, there is a limit to how much additional wire can be melted without causing defects such as lack of fusion or slag entrapment.
In practice, the deposition rate must be balanced against the quality requirements. A higher deposition rate may be acceptable for the boss body, but it may not be acceptable for the final layers, which require a smooth surface and good fusion.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of pressure vessel fabrication. It demonstrates that additional filler wire SAW can be used for surfacing 12Cr2Mo1V steel bosses with excellent mechanical properties and a significant improvement in efficiency. The process is a viable alternative to conventional single-wire SAW for this application.
For the shop floor, the key takeaways are:
- Additional filler wire SAW can significantly improve the efficiency of boss surfacing without compromising the mechanical properties.
- The process requires careful control of the wire feed rates and the welding parameters to ensure a stable weld pool and consistent deposit quality.
- The qualification testing must include impact toughness at the design temperature and temper embrittlement evaluation.
- The process is best suited for large, repetitive surfacing operations where the efficiency gain can be fully realised.
For the delivery site, the key lesson is that the boss weld is a critical component of the hydrogenation reactor. Any defect in the weld could lead to failure in service, which would be catastrophic. The additional filler wire SAW process must be qualified and monitored to ensure that the deposit has the required properties.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper is a useful reference for anyone involved in the fabrication of hydrogenation reactors. It provides data on the process feasibility and the mechanical properties of the deposit. It also highlights the efficiency gains that can be achieved with additional filler wire SAW.
Looking forward, I would like to see more research on the application of additional filler wire SAW to other components of hydrogenation reactors, such as the shell-to-nozzle welds. I would also like to see more work on the effect of the process on the HAZ properties and the residual stress distribution.
In my own practice, I would use this paper as a reference for evaluating additional filler wire SAW as an alternative to conventional single-wire SAW for boss surfacing. I would also use it to establish qualification requirements and acceptance criteria for the process. The paper is a reminder that innovation in welding processes can lead to significant improvements in efficiency and quality, but it must be validated through rigorous testing.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd