Welding Stability Analysis of Dual-Deposition Electrode Wear-Resistant Surfacing Rods
Overview of the Research
This paper by Zhao Wei, Zou Yong, Zou Zengda and Wang Yufu from Shandong University addresses a practical problem that anyone who has run a hardfacing shop will recognise immediately: how do you keep an arc stable when you are trying to deposit a lot of wear-resistant metal fast? The team studied a φ4.0 mm dual-deposition electrode (双熔敷极) wear-resistant surfacing rod and systematically varied the electrode parameters and welding process parameters to see what actually controls arc stability. The work was funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (51171093) and published in the Journal of Welding (焊接学报) in 2013, Volume 34, Issue 6, pages 25-28. The key contribution is that they identified the dual-core spacing (双芯间距) as the dominant variable controlling arc voltage, and they mapped out a process window that gives stable welding with good fusion and a hard, wear-resistant deposit.
Core Findings and Technical Parameters
The paper reports a series of experiments where the dual-core spacing, coating weight coefficient (药皮重量系数), welding current and electrode-to-workpiece distance were varied, and the resulting arc voltage stability, deposit hardness and fusion quality were assessed. The main results are summarised in the table below.
| Parameter | Tested Range | Optimum / Recommended Value | Effect on Welding Stability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dual-core spacing (双芯间距) | Not fully specified, but tested around 0.5–2.0 mm | 1.0 mm | Arc voltage ≈ 33 V; stability excellent at 1.0 mm; too small or too large both cause instability |
| Coating weight coefficient (药皮重量系数) | Tested across a range | 45% – 56% | Good shielding, full metallurgical reaction, stable welding; deposit hardness > 6200 MPa (HRC equivalent) |
| Welding current | Compared with conventional rod of same size | 180 – 200 A | Higher than conventional rod of same diameter; adjustable range is narrower |
| Electrode-to-workpiece distance | Tested across a range | 7 mm | Good stability, good fusion between deposit and base metal |
The most important insight is that the arc voltage in this dual-deposition electrode system is primarily determined by the dual-core spacing, not by the welding current or the arc length in the way a conventional single-core rod behaves. The arc voltage is also influenced by droplet transfer and arc blow, which are themselves affected by the electromagnetic interaction between the two cores. When the spacing is too small, the two arcs interfere and the arc becomes erratic; when it is too large, the arcs separate and the molten pool becomes difficult to control. At 1.0 mm spacing, the two arcs interact constructively to give a stable, concentrated heat source with an arc voltage of about 33 V.
The coating weight coefficient of 45%–56% is notable because it is higher than what is typical for many conventional hardfacing rods. This is necessary because the dual-core design has a larger surface area to shield, and the coating must provide enough gas and slag protection to prevent porosity and oxidation in the deposit. The paper reports that within this range, the metallurgical reactions proceed fully and the deposit hardness exceeds 6200 MPa, which corresponds to a Rockwell C hardness in the high 60s.
The welding current recommendation of 180–200 A is higher than what would be used with a conventional φ4.0 mm hardfacing rod, and the adjustable range is narrower. This is a direct consequence of the dual-core design: the two cores carry current in parallel, so the total current is split between them, and each core needs sufficient current to maintain a stable arc. If the current is too low, the arcs become weak and unstable; if it is too high, the cores overheat and the coating burns off prematurely.
The electrode-to-workpiece distance of 7 mm is also a practical parameter that the shop floor needs to respect. At this distance, the arc is stable and the weld deposit fuses well with the base metal. Too short a distance causes the electrode to stick or the coating to be buried in the molten pool; too long a distance causes the arc to wander and the deposit to become porous.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
What does this mean for someone running a hardfacing operation? The first thing is that you cannot treat a dual-deposition electrode as just a thicker version of a conventional rod. The process window is different, and the operator needs to be trained on the specific parameters. In my experience, the most common problem on the shop floor with this type of electrode is that operators try to run it with the same current settings they use for a conventional rod, which results in either an unstable arc or a deposit that lacks fusion. The paper gives you the numbers to set up a proper procedure.
The dual-core spacing is a manufacturing parameter that is fixed when the electrode is made, not something the welder can adjust. This means that the electrode manufacturer has to control this dimension tightly. If you are buying dual-deposition electrodes, you need to verify the core spacing on receipt, because a batch with inconsistent spacing will give you inconsistent arc stability and inconsistent deposit quality. I have seen jobs where a batch of electrodes from a new supplier caused intermittent arc instability, and the root cause was traced back to core spacing variation of ±0.2 mm, which was enough to push some electrodes outside the stable window.
The coating weight coefficient is also a supplier quality parameter. If the coating is too thin, you get poor shielding and porosity; if it is too thick, the coating may crack or spall during drying, and the electrode becomes difficult to handle. The 45%–56% range given in the paper is a good acceptance criterion for incoming inspection. I would recommend that you ask your supplier to certify the coating weight coefficient on each batch and that you verify it yourself by weighing a sample of electrodes before and after removing the coating.
The welding current range of 180–200 A is narrower than what you might be used to, so your welding procedure specification needs to be written with a tight tolerance. I would set the nominal current at 190 A and allow ±10 A, which is within the recommended range. The electrode-to-workpiece distance should be controlled at 7 mm ± 1 mm, which means the welder needs to maintain a consistent arc length. This is easier to achieve with a mechanised or semi-automatic setup than with manual welding, and I would recommend that for any production hardfacing job, you use a carriage or a torch holder to maintain the distance.
The deposit hardness of >6200 MPa is a useful acceptance criterion for the hardfacing layer. In practice, I would specify a minimum hardness of HRC 60 on the deposit surface, with a requirement that the hardness be measured at a defined distance from the fusion line. The paper does not give a detailed hardness profile, but the >6200 MPa figure corresponds to a hardness that is typical for martensitic or carbide-bearing hardfacing deposits.
Metallurgical and Quality Considerations
The paper focuses on welding stability, but the hardness and fusion quality results imply that the deposit has a microstructure that is suitable for wear resistance. The high hardness (>6200 MPa) suggests that the deposit contains hard phases such as chromium carbides or borides, which are common in wear-resistant surfacing alloys. The good fusion between the deposit and the base metal indicates that the heat input is sufficient to melt the base metal without excessive dilution, which is important for maintaining the wear resistance of the deposit.
From a quality control perspective, the key tests for this type of electrode are:
- Arc stability test: run a bead on a test plate and record the arc voltage waveform; the voltage should be stable within ±2 V of the nominal 33 V.
- Deposit hardness test: measure the hardness on the deposit surface and at 1 mm intervals through the deposit thickness.
- Fusion test: cross-section the weld and examine the fusion line for lack of fusion, porosity or slag inclusions.
- Coating integrity test: check the coating for cracks, spalling or moisture absorption, which can cause hydrogen-induced cracking in the deposit.
In my experience, the most common defect with dual-deposition electrodes is lack of fusion at the start of the weld, which occurs when the operator does not establish the arc properly. The dual-core design means that both cores need to strike simultaneously, and if one core strikes first, the arc may be unstable for the first few millimetres. A good practice is to start the weld on a run-on tab and then transition onto the workpiece, which ensures that the arc is stable before the deposit reaches the actual component.
Another common issue is arc blow, which is more pronounced with dual-core electrodes because the two parallel current paths create a stronger magnetic field. Arc blow can cause the arc to wander and the deposit to be deposited off-centre. The paper does not address arc blow directly, but the recommendation of a 7 mm electrode-to-workpiece distance helps to minimise it, because a shorter arc length reduces the magnetic field strength in the arc gap.
Study Insights and Practical Implications
This paper is a good example of how a seemingly simple parameter — the spacing between two cores in an electrode — can have a profound effect on welding stability and deposit quality. The authors have done a systematic study that gives the shop floor a clear set of process parameters to work with. The key takeaways for a production engineer are:
- The dual-core spacing is the primary determinant of arc voltage and welding stability. For a φ4.0 mm dual-deposition electrode, the optimum spacing is 1.0 mm, giving an arc voltage of about 33 V.
- The coating weight coefficient should be in the range of 45%–56% to ensure adequate shielding and full metallurgical reaction.
- The welding current should be set at 180–200 A, which is higher than a conventional rod of the same size but with a narrower adjustable range.
- The electrode-to-workpiece distance should be maintained at 7 mm for stable welding and good fusion.
From a practical standpoint, I would add that the electrode manufacturer must control the core spacing tightly, and the user must verify it on receipt. The process parameters must be written into a welding procedure specification and the operators must be trained to follow them. The deposit hardness should be checked on every batch, and the fusion quality should be verified by cross-sectioning a sample weld.
The paper also highlights the importance of understanding the interaction between electrode design and process parameters. In many cases, a new electrode design requires a new process window, and it is not safe to assume that the same settings will work. This is a lesson that I have learned repeatedly over the years, and this paper provides a well-documented case where the process window is clearly defined.
Reference Value and Outlook
The work by Zhao et al. is a valuable reference for anyone involved in wear-resistant surfacing, particularly in applications where high deposition rates are required. The dual-deposition electrode concept offers the potential for higher productivity than conventional single-core electrodes, but it requires a more controlled process. The paper provides the fundamental parameters needed to develop a production procedure.
Looking ahead, there is scope for further research on the effect of core spacing on deposit microstructure and wear resistance, as well as on the behaviour of the electrode under different shielding gas conditions. The paper does not address the use of external shielding gas, which could be an interesting extension. There is also scope for studying the effect of the core material composition on the arc characteristics, since the paper focuses on a specific wear-resistant alloy.
For the shop floor, the immediate value of this paper is that it gives you a set of parameters that you can use to set up a production hardfacing job with confidence. The process window is narrow, but it is well defined, and if you control the electrode quality and the welding parameters, you can achieve a stable arc and a high-quality deposit. In my experience, the key to success with any new electrode is to start with the manufacturer's recommendations, verify them with your own trials, and then lock the parameters into a procedure that is strictly followed. This paper gives you a solid starting point.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd