ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Thermal Insulating Agents in Tungsten Carbide Surfacing Welding: A Practical Study Note

Literature Overview and Context

The paper by Diao Shusheng and colleagues from the Central Iron and Steel Research Institute and the University of Science and Technology Beijing addresses a critical problem in hardfacing technology: the loss of tungsten carbide (WC) particles during the surfacing welding process. When WC particles are exposed to the high temperatures of the welding arc, they can dissolve, oxidize, or sink to the bottom of the molten pool, reducing the effective hard phase content in the deposited layer. This directly compromises the wear resistance of the hardfacing.

The authors propose using a thermal insulating agent in tube-type cast WC welding electrodes to protect the carbide particles from excessive heat. The concept is elegant: if the WC particles are shielded from the full heat of the arc, they will retain their original size, shape, and hardness, resulting in a more effective wear-resistant layer.

This is a problem I have encountered many times in the pipe industry. Hardfacing is used extensively on drill pipe tool joints, mud motor components, and other wear-prone parts. The difference between a good hardfacing and a poor one often comes down to how many WC particles survive the welding process intact.

Technical Parameters and Experimental Results

The authors conducted TIG arc surfacing welding experiments using tube-type cast WC electrodes with and without thermal insulating agents. The key results are summarized below:

Parameter Without Insulating Agent With Insulating Agent (No. 2)
WC particle area fraction (Ac) 5-8% 21-29%
Hardness Not specified HRC 67+
WC particle melting/dissolution Significant Noticeably reduced
Linear wear amount (Δl) Higher Lower, following Δl = 0.0229 - 5.54×10⁻² Ac

The relationship between linear wear amount and WC particle area fraction is particularly interesting. The equation Δl = 0.0229 - 5.54×10⁻² Ac shows that as the WC content increases, the wear rate decreases linearly. This is a clear demonstration of the direct relationship between hard phase content and wear resistance.

The use of No. 2 thermal insulating agent increased the WC particle area fraction from 5-8% to 21-29%, a three to four-fold improvement. This is a dramatic increase that would have a significant impact on service life.

Process Mechanism and Metallurgical Analysis

The mechanism by which the thermal insulating agent works is straightforward: it creates a protective atmosphere or slag layer around the WC particles during the welding process, reducing their exposure to the high-temperature arc. This prevents:

  1. Dissolution of WC into the molten matrix: At high temperatures, WC can dissolve into the iron-based matrix, reducing the hard phase content and increasing matrix hardness (which can lead to brittleness).
  2. Oxidation of WC: WC can oxidize at high temperatures, forming WO3 which is volatile and can be lost from the deposit.
  3. Grain growth of WC: Even if the WC does not dissolve, it can undergo grain growth, which reduces its effectiveness as a wear-resistant phase.

The metallographic analysis confirmed that the WC particles in the deposits made with the thermal insulating agent were larger, more angular, and more uniformly distributed than those in the control samples. This is exactly what you want to see in a hardfacing deposit.

Engineering Practice Integration

In the pipe industry, hardfacing is used in several critical applications:

  1. Drill pipe tool joints: Hardfacing is applied to the tool joint surface to resist wear during drilling operations. A hardfacing with high WC content can significantly extend the life of the tool joint.
  2. Mud motor components: The rotor and stator of mud motors are subject to severe abrasive wear from drilling fluid. Hardfacing with WC particles is commonly used to extend their service life.
  3. Pipe handling equipment: Components such as pipe grippers, elevators, and slips are subject to wear from contact with pipe surfaces. Hardfacing can extend their service life.

The results of this research have direct implications for all these applications. Increasing the WC content from 5-8% to 21-29% would likely double or triple the service life of hardfaced components, depending on the specific wear mechanism.

However, I must raise a practical concern: the use of thermal insulating agents in tube-type electrodes adds complexity to the manufacturing process. The insulating agent must be uniformly distributed within the tube, and it must not interfere with the welding process or the quality of the deposit. The authors report that No. 2 thermal insulating agent performed well, but the selection of the appropriate agent and its concentration requires careful optimization.

Key Questions and Reflections

Several questions arise from this research:

  1. What is the optimal concentration of the thermal insulating agent in the electrode?
  2. Does the thermal insulating agent affect the weldability of the deposit, particularly in terms of porosity or slag inclusion?
  3. How does the thermal insulating agent affect the bond strength between the hardfacing and the substrate?
  4. What is the economic impact of using thermal insulating agents in production?

The authors have demonstrated that the thermal insulating agent can significantly increase WC retention, but they have not addressed the economic aspects or the long-term performance of the deposits.

Study Insights and Implications

This research highlights a fundamental principle in hardfacing technology: the effectiveness of a hardfacing deposit depends not only on the type and amount of hard phase material but also on how much of that material survives the welding process. The thermal insulating agent approach is a clever solution to a problem that has plagued the hardfacing industry for decades.

From a practical standpoint, the results suggest that tube-type WC electrodes with thermal insulating agents could be a viable alternative to conventional electrodes for applications requiring high wear resistance. The improvement in WC retention from 5-8% to 21-29% is substantial and would likely translate to a significant increase in service life.

However, I would caution against adopting this technology without thorough validation. The thermal insulating agent must be compatible with the specific welding process and the base material. It must not introduce defects such as porosity or slag inclusions, which would compromise the integrity of the hardfacing. I would recommend:

  1. Conducting welding procedure qualification tests to verify the weld quality and mechanical properties.
  2. Performing field trials on actual components to assess the wear resistance under real service conditions.
  3. Developing a quality control procedure for the tube-type electrodes to ensure consistent WC content and distribution.

Concluding Remarks

The research by Diao Shusheng and colleagues represents a significant advancement in hardfacing technology. The use of thermal insulating agents to protect WC particles during the welding process is a novel and effective approach that can dramatically increase the hard phase content in the deposit. The reported increase from 5-8% to 21-29% WC particle area fraction, combined with the corresponding improvement in wear resistance, is a compelling result.

For the pipe industry, where hardfacing is used extensively on drill pipe tool joints and other wear-prone components, this technology has the potential to extend service life and reduce maintenance costs. However, the transition from laboratory success to production reality requires careful validation and process optimization.

The key takeaway is that hardfacing technology is not just about the type and amount of hard phase material but also about how that material is protected and retained during the welding process. The thermal insulating agent approach addresses this critical aspect and opens the door to more effective and durable hardfacing deposits.