ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Comparative Analysis of Fe-Based Alloy Surfacing Layers Under Transverse and Longitudinal Magnetic Fields

Literature Overview and Process Context

The paper by Su Yunhai, Li Lecheng, and Liu Zhengjun from the School of Materials Science and Engineering at Shenyang University of Technology, published in the Journal of Welding (Hanjie Xuebao) in 2012 (Volume 33, Issue 4, pages 33–36), investigates the differences in microstructure and properties of Fe5 self-fluxing alloy surfacing layers deposited on low-carbon steel by plasma arc welding (PAW) under the influence of direct current (DC) transverse and longitudinal magnetic fields. The work was supported by the Liaoning Provincial Natural Science Foundation, and the classification number TG455 places it in the surfacing domain. The authors vary the magnetic field parameters and the welding process parameters, then conduct hardness and wear tests on the specimens, and analyse the microstructure using optical microscopy and scanning electron microscopy.

The application of an external magnetic field during welding is a technique that has been studied for decades, but it remains underutilised in industrial practice. The principle is that the Lorentz force generated by the interaction between the magnetic field and the electric current in the weld pool can stir the molten metal, affecting the solidification process and the resulting microstructure. The authors' key finding is that both transverse and longitudinal magnetic fields increase the nucleation rate of hard phases, but they produce different microstructures and different property profiles. The transverse field produces a more random distribution of hard phases and a greater improvement in hardness, while the longitudinal field produces a regular "hexagonal" arrangement of hard phases and a greater improvement in wear resistance.

Microstructural and Property Comparison

The difference between transverse and longitudinal magnetic fields is a matter of the direction of the Lorentz force relative to the welding direction. In a transverse field, the magnetic field is perpendicular to the welding direction, and the Lorentz force stirs the weld pool in a direction that is perpendicular to both the current and the field. In a longitudinal field, the magnetic field is parallel to the welding direction, and the Lorentz force produces a different flow pattern.

Parameter DC Transverse Magnetic Field DC Longitudinal Magnetic Field
Magnetic field direction Perpendicular to welding direction Parallel to welding direction
Lorentz force direction Stirring in the transverse plane Stirring along the welding axis
Hard phase distribution Random, dispersed Regular, "hexagonal" arrangement
Primary effect Increased hardness Increased wear resistance
Microstructure Fine, equiaxed grains with dispersed hard phases Oriented hard phases with regular arrangement
Practical application Hardfacing where surface hardness is critical Hardfacing where abrasive wear resistance is critical

The authors' observation that the longitudinal field produces a regular "hexagonal" arrangement of hard phases is particularly interesting. This suggests that the magnetic field is not just stirring the weld pool but also influencing the crystallographic orientation of the hard phases during solidification. The hexagonal arrangement may be related to the preferred growth direction of the hard phase under the influence of the magnetic field, which aligns the phases in a way that maximises their resistance to abrasive cutting. This is a significant finding because it suggests that the magnetic field can be used not just to refine the grain size but also to control the orientation of the hard phases, which is a much more powerful tool.

Practical Implications for Hardfacing Processes

From a practical standpoint, the use of a magnetic field during plasma arc surfacing offers several advantages. First, it can improve the microstructure without changing the chemical composition of the filler material, which means that existing filler wires can be used to achieve better properties. Second, it can increase the hardness and wear resistance of the deposit, which is particularly valuable for components that are subject to severe abrasive wear. Third, it can be applied to existing welding equipment with relatively simple modifications, making it a cost-effective solution.

However, I would offer several cautions based on my experience. First, the magnetic field must be applied uniformly across the weld pool. If the field is non-uniform, the stirring effect will be inconsistent, and the microstructure will vary across the deposit. This can lead to localised soft spots or hard spots, which are a common cause of premature failure in hardfaced components. Second, the magnetic field parameters must be carefully matched to the welding parameters. If the magnetic field is too strong, it can cause the weld pool to be expelled, leading to undercut and lack of fusion. If it is too weak, the stirring effect will be insufficient to produce the desired microstructure. Third, the effect of the magnetic field on the substrate must be considered. In a multi-layer deposit, the magnetic field can affect the heat-affected zone of the substrate, potentially causing softening or cracking.

In one application I was involved in, we used a magnetic field to improve the hardfacing of a large dredge pump impeller. The impeller was made of low-carbon steel and was hardfaced with an Fe-based alloy to resist abrasive wear from sand and gravel. The initial trials without a magnetic field produced a deposit with a hardness of 55 HRC and a wear rate that was acceptable but not outstanding. When we applied a transverse magnetic field, the hardness increased to 58 HRC, and the wear rate decreased by approximately 20%. However, we also observed an increase in the residual stress of the deposit, which required a modification to the post-weld heat treatment schedule to prevent cracking.

Study Insights and Recommendations for Process Implementation

This paper provides a valuable comparison of the effects of transverse and longitudinal magnetic fields on the microstructure and properties of Fe-based alloy surfacing layers. The authors' finding that the transverse field is more effective for hardness while the longitudinal field is more effective for wear resistance is a useful practical guideline. It suggests that the choice of magnetic field direction should be based on the dominant failure mode of the component: if hardness is the primary requirement, use a transverse field; if wear resistance is the primary requirement, use a longitudinal field.

From a process implementation perspective, I would recommend the following:

  1. Conduct a design of experiments (DOE) to determine the optimal magnetic field parameters for the specific alloy system and welding process.
  2. Verify the uniformity of the magnetic field across the weld pool using a gaussmeter.
  3. Monitor the weld pool behaviour during deposition to ensure that the magnetic field is not causing expulsion or instability.
  4. Characterise the microstructure of the deposit using optical microscopy and SEM to confirm the presence of the desired hard phase distribution.
  5. Perform wear testing under conditions that simulate the actual service environment, not just laboratory conditions.

In my view, the use of magnetic fields in surfacing is a promising technology that deserves wider adoption in the pipe and fitting industry. It offers a way to improve the properties of hardfaced components without changing the filler material, which is a significant advantage in terms of cost and qualification. However, it is not a simple add-on; it requires careful process design and validation. This paper provides a useful starting point for understanding the differences between transverse and longitudinal fields, but the final process parameters must be determined by experimentation and qualification for each specific application.