ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Anti-Sulfur High-Pressure Separator UNS N06625 Hardfacing: Welding Procedure Qualification and Corrosion Testing

Literature Overview and Practical Context

This paper by Han Bing, Feng Wei, and Wei Tao addresses a critical issue in oil and gas processing: the manufacture of high-pressure separators for sour service. The authors analysed the characteristics of produced fluids containing high H₂S and CO₂, determined that a low-alloy steel vessel with UNS N06625 (Inconel 625) hardfacing was the appropriate construction, and then conducted a comprehensive welding procedure qualification and corrosion testing programme. The three welding methods evaluated were single-layer electroslag hardfacing, shielded metal arc welding (SMAW) hardfacing, and automatic GTAW hardfacing of small-bore internal surfaces.

I have been involved in similar projects for sour service separators and scrubbers, and I can tell you that the corrosion testing regime described in this paper is exactly what the client should be asking for. The key challenge is not just to deposit the nickel alloy, but to ensure that the deposit has the corrosion resistance required for the service environment. The paper reports that all three welding methods produced acceptable results, and the corrosion tests, including intergranular corrosion, magnesium chloride stress corrosion cracking, hydrogen sulfide stress corrosion cracking, and dynamic corrosion evaluation under simulated separator conditions, all passed.

Welding Procedure Qualification: Three Methods Compared

The authors evaluated three welding methods for depositing UNS N06625 on low-alloy steel. Each method has its own characteristics, and the choice depends on the geometry of the component and the accessibility of the surface.

Welding Method Application Advantages Limitations
Single-layer electroslag hardfacing Large flat or cylindrical surfaces High deposition rate, low dilution Requires specialised equipment, limited to certain geometries
SMAW hardfacing General surfaces, field repairs Flexible, widely available Lower deposition rate, higher dilution, operator skill dependent
Automatic GTAW hardfacing Small-bore internal surfaces Precise control, low dilution, consistent quality Slow, requires orbital equipment

The critical parameter in all three methods is dilution. When depositing UNS N06625 on low-alloy steel, the iron from the base metal dilutes the nickel alloy, reducing its corrosion resistance. The authors' approach was to use a single-layer electroslag process, which has inherently low dilution because the slag layer protects the molten pool and the heat input is distributed over a large area. For SMAW, the dilution is higher, but the authors were able to achieve acceptable results by using low heat input and stringer beads. For the small-bore internal surfaces, automatic GTAW was the only viable option, and the authors developed a procedure that maintained dilution below the acceptable limit.

The welding procedure qualification (WPQ) is the foundation of any sour service fabrication. The paper reports that the authors performed a full range of tests, including intergranular corrosion (ASTM A262 Practice E), magnesium chloride stress corrosion cracking (ASTM G36), hydrogen sulfide stress corrosion cracking (NACE TM0177 Method A), and dynamic corrosion evaluation under simulated separator conditions. This is a comprehensive test matrix, and the fact that all tests passed is a strong indication that the welding procedures are sound.

Corrosion Testing: What the Results Really Mean

The corrosion tests described in this paper are not routine quality control tests. They are performance tests designed to simulate the actual service environment. The intergranular corrosion test (ASTM A262 Practice E) evaluates the susceptibility of the nickel alloy to sensitisation, which occurs when chromium carbides precipitate at grain boundaries. The magnesium chloride stress corrosion cracking test (ASTM G36) evaluates the resistance to chloride-induced stress corrosion cracking, which is a common failure mode in sour service. The hydrogen sulfide stress corrosion cracking test (NACE TM0177 Method A) evaluates the resistance to sulfide stress cracking, which is the most critical failure mode in sour service.

The dynamic corrosion evaluation is particularly interesting. The authors simulated the actual separator conditions, including the partial pressures of H₂S and CO₂, the temperature, and the flow rate. This is a more realistic test than the static tests, because it accounts for the effect of flow on corrosion rate and on the stability of the protective oxide film. The fact that the dynamic corrosion test passed is a strong indication that the hardfaced separator will perform in service.

For the pipe and fitting industry, this testing regime is directly applicable to the manufacture of sour service pipeline components such as valve bodies, fittings, and flanges. The same corrosion tests should be performed on any component that will be in contact with sour fluids. The cost of the testing is significant, but it is a fraction of the cost of a failure in service.

Engineering Practice: Lessons from the Shop Floor

The paper describes the successful manufacture of the separator, which is the ultimate proof that the welding procedures and corrosion testing are adequate. However, I would like to draw attention to a few practical points that the paper does not fully address.

First, the inspection of the hardfaced surface is critical. The authors do not mention NDT, but in practice, the hardfaced surface should be inspected with PT or MT to detect surface cracks, and UT should be used to verify the bond integrity between the deposit and the base metal. Lack of fusion or porosity in the hardfaced layer can create corrosion cells that lead to pitting and stress corrosion cracking.

Second, the hardness of the hardfaced layer should be controlled. UNS N06625 deposits typically have a hardness of 180-220 HV, but if the dilution is too high, the hardness can increase due to the formation of martensite in the dilution zone. A hardness survey across the hardfaced layer should be performed to ensure that there is no hard zone that could be susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking.

Third, the welding parameters must be carefully controlled to avoid hot cracking. UNS N06625 is susceptible to solidification cracking, which occurs when the deposit contains high levels of niobium and molybdenum. The authors do not mention this, but in practice, the welding parameters must be set to ensure a low heat input and a controlled cooling rate. The use of a stringer bead technique and a low interpass temperature is essential.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that the paper raises is the choice between single-layer and multi-layer hardfacing. The authors used a single-layer electroslag process, which is unusual. In most applications, multi-layer hardfacing is used to achieve the required thickness and to ensure that the corrosion-resistant alloy is not diluted by the base metal. However, the authors were able to achieve acceptable results with a single layer, which suggests that the electroslag process has very low dilution. This is an important finding, because single-layer hardfacing reduces the manufacturing time and cost.

Another question is the long-term performance of the hardfaced layer. The corrosion tests provide a snapshot of the material's performance, but they do not account for the effect of long-term exposure. In practice, the hardfaced layer should be inspected periodically during service, and the corrosion rate should be monitored. The dynamic corrosion test provides a baseline, but the actual service conditions may be more severe.

The paper also raises the question of the welding consumable. UNS N06625 is available as a filler wire, a covered electrode, and a flux-cored wire. The choice of consumable affects the deposit chemistry and the corrosion resistance. The authors do not specify the consumable, but in practice, the consumable should be certified to the relevant standard, such as ASME SFA-5.14 for filler wire or ASME SFA-5.11 for covered electrodes.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is an excellent example of the systematic approach required for sour service fabrication. The authors started with a thorough analysis of the service environment, selected the appropriate material and welding method, performed a comprehensive welding procedure qualification, and validated the results with a full range of corrosion tests. The successful manufacture of the separator is the ultimate proof of the soundness of the approach.

For the pipe and fitting industry, the key lesson is that sour service fabrication requires a complete understanding of the service environment and a comprehensive testing programme. The cost of the testing is significant, but it is a fraction of the cost of a failure in service. The engineer should not compromise on the testing regime, and should ensure that the welding procedures are qualified to the most demanding standards.

The paper also highlights the importance of selecting the right welding method for each application. The electroslag process is ideal for large surfaces, SMAW is flexible and widely available, and automatic GTAW is the only option for small-bore internal surfaces. The engineer should evaluate each method on its merits and choose the one that provides the best combination of quality, productivity, and cost.

In conclusion, this paper provides a comprehensive and well-executed study of UNS N06625 hardfacing for sour service separators, demonstrating that the welding procedures and corrosion testing are adequate for the service environment. The systematic approach described in the paper should be adopted as a model for any sour service fabrication, and the corrosion testing regime should be used as a benchmark for quality assurance.