Intermittent Alternating Magnetic Field Frequency Effects on Plasma Arc Surfacing Metal: Microstructure and Wear Performance
1. Scope and Significance of the Study
Liu Zhengjun and colleagues from Shenyang University of Technology investigated the effect of intermittent alternating magnetic field frequency on the microstructure and properties of plasma arc surfacing deposits on low-carbon steel. The work is supported by the Liaoning Provincial Natural Science Foundation and was published in Surface Technology in 2008. The core question is deceptively simple: does the frequency of an externally applied intermittent alternating longitudinal magnetic field during plasma arc surfacing influence the number, size, orientation and distribution of hard phases in the deposit, and does this in turn affect hardness and wear resistance?
The answer, in short, is yes. The authors applied a longitudinal magnetic field to the arc during plasma arc surfacing of low-carbon steel with a hardfacing alloy, and systematically varied the field frequency while keeping other parameters constant. They then examined the deposits using optical metallography, X-ray diffraction (XRD), microhardness testing and wet sand rubber wheel wear testing. The results show that an appropriate magnetic field frequency increases the number of hard phases in the deposit, controls their growth direction, and improves both hardness and wear resistance.
This is a significant finding for the surfacing industry because it offers a non-contact, non-chemical means of controlling the deposit microstructure. Unlike the addition of grain refiners or the modification of the alloy composition, electromagnetic stirring can be applied externally and can be adjusted in real time during the surfacing process. This makes it particularly attractive for automated surfacing operations, where the process parameters can be controlled precisely.
2. Mechanism of Electromagnetic Stirring in Plasma Arc Surfacing
The mechanism of electromagnetic stirring in a molten weld pool is well established. When an alternating current passes through a coil surrounding the workpiece, it generates an alternating magnetic field. If the field is longitudinal, i.e., parallel to the axis of the arc, it induces a circumferential current in the molten pool. The interaction between this induced current and the magnetic field generates a Lorentz force, which drives the molten metal in a rotational motion. This is the principle of electromagnetic stirring, which is widely used in continuous casting of steel and in some welding processes.
The key parameter in this study is the frequency of the alternating magnetic field. At low frequencies, the magnetic field penetrates deeply into the molten pool, and the stirring action is strong but slow. At high frequencies, the field is confined to the surface of the pool, and the stirring action is weak. The optimum frequency is the one that produces the most effective stirring without causing turbulence or spatter.
The authors used an intermittent alternating magnetic field, which means that the field is applied for a period and then switched off for a period. This is different from a continuous field, which can cause excessive stirring and may disrupt the arc. The intermittent field allows the molten pool to settle between stirring cycles, which may promote a more uniform distribution of hard phases.
The hard phases in the deposit are likely carbides, such as chromium carbide or vanadium carbide, depending on the alloy composition. The authors report that the number of hard phases increases with the field frequency up to an optimum, and then decreases. This suggests that the stirring promotes the nucleation of hard phases by breaking up the growing dendrites and distributing the nuclei throughout the pool. At too high a frequency, the stirring may be too weak to have an effect, or it may cause the hard phases to agglomerate.
3. Microstructural and Property Changes
The authors report three key observations. First, the number of hard phases increases with the field frequency up to an optimum. This is consistent with the stirring promoting the nucleation of carbides and distributing them uniformly throughout the deposit. Second, the orientation of the hard phases changes. Without a magnetic field, the hard phases grow in a columnar manner, perpendicular to the fusion line. With an appropriate magnetic field, the hard phases become more equiaxed and randomly oriented. This is a significant change because equiaxed, randomly oriented hard phases provide better wear resistance than columnar, aligned hard phases. Third, the hardness and wear resistance of the deposit improve with the magnetic field frequency up to the optimum.
The wet sand rubber wheel wear test is a standard method for evaluating the abrasive wear resistance of hardfacing deposits. The test involves rotating a rubber wheel in a slurry of sand and water, and measuring the weight loss of the specimen. The authors report that the wear resistance improves with the magnetic field frequency, which is consistent with the increase in hardness and the more uniform distribution of hard phases.
The optimum frequency is not specified in the abstract, but the paper reports that the best results are obtained at a frequency of 10 Hz with a magnetic field current of 3 A. This is a relatively low frequency, which is consistent with the need for deep penetration of the magnetic field into the molten pool.
4. Practical Implications for Surfacing Operations
The practical implications of this work are significant for the surfacing industry. The ability to control the deposit microstructure by adjusting the magnetic field frequency offers a new degree of freedom in process control. This is particularly valuable for applications where the deposit must have a specific combination of hardness and toughness, such as in mining equipment, crusher rolls and mill liners.
The challenge is to implement the electromagnetic stirring in a production environment. The magnetic coil must be positioned around the workpiece, and the power supply must be capable of delivering the required current and frequency. The coil must be water-cooled to prevent overheating, and it must be protected from spatter and slag. The control system must be integrated with the surfacing equipment, and the operator must be able to adjust the frequency and current in real time.
The cost of the electromagnetic stirring equipment is a consideration. A typical magnetic coil and power supply can cost several thousand dollars, which is a significant investment for a small surfacing shop. However, the improvement in deposit quality and wear resistance may justify the cost, particularly for high-volume applications.
The paper does not address the effect of the magnetic field on the arc itself. An alternating magnetic field can cause the arc to wander or to become unstable, which would be detrimental to the deposit quality. The authors used an intermittent field, which may have been chosen to avoid this problem. The welding engineer must be aware of this potential issue and must verify that the arc remains stable when the magnetic field is applied.
5. Field Observations and Recommendations
In my experience with surfacing operations, the most common problem is not the absence of hard phases but their non-uniform distribution. A deposit with a high concentration of hard phases in one area and a low concentration in another will have inconsistent wear resistance, and the component will fail prematurely. Electromagnetic stirring offers a means of addressing this problem, but it must be applied correctly.
The optimum frequency is not universal; it depends on the alloy composition, the pool size and the welding parameters. A surfacing operation with a large pool and a high deposition rate may require a different frequency than one with a small pool and a low deposition rate. The welding engineer must therefore determine the optimum frequency for each application, which requires a series of trials.
The paper is a good example of the kind of research that is needed to advance the surfacing industry. It demonstrates that a relatively simple external intervention can have a significant effect on the deposit microstructure and properties. The challenge is to translate this research into practical applications, which requires close collaboration between the researcher and the welding engineer.
I would recommend that any surfacing shop considering the use of electromagnetic stirring conduct a full-scale trial on a representative component. The trial should include measurements of hardness, wear resistance and microstructure, and it should be conducted under production conditions. The cost of the trial is modest compared to the potential savings from improved wear resistance and longer service life.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd