Electromagnetic Stirring Effects on Plasma Arc Surfacing Deposit Microstructure and Properties: A Systematic Evaluation
1. Introduction and Research Context
Cheng Jiangbo and colleagues from Shanghai Jiao Tong University, the Academy of Armored Forces Engineering and Shenyang University of Technology conducted a systematic study of electromagnetic stirring during plasma arc surfacing on low-carbon steel. The work was published in the Journal of Welding in 2006 and represents a more detailed investigation than the companion study on magnetic field frequency. The authors applied an intermittent alternating longitudinal magnetic field during plasma arc surfacing and examined the effect of varying magnetic field parameters on the deposit microstructure, hardness and wear resistance.
The key finding is that increasing the magnetic field parameters increases the number of hard phases in the deposit, and these phases become more uniformly distributed across the surface. The wear resistance of the deposit improves correspondingly. The optimal performance is achieved at a magnetic field current of 3 A and a frequency of 10 Hz. At these parameters, the deposit achieves the best combination of hardness and wear resistance.
The paper also reports a morphological change in the hard phases. Without electromagnetic stirring, the hard phases exist as a mixture of long strip-like and hexagonal shapes. With electromagnetic stirring, the morphology gradually transforms into a more regular, uniform hexagonal shape. This morphological change is significant because it indicates a more uniform distribution of the hard phases and a more consistent wear resistance.
2. Experimental Approach and Parameter Selection
The authors used a plasma arc surfacing process, which is well suited to this type of study because it offers precise control of the heat input and the deposition rate. The workpiece was low-carbon steel, and the surfacing alloy was presumably a hardfacing material with a high content of carbide-forming elements such as chromium and vanadium. The magnetic field was applied using a coil wrapped around the workpiece, and the field was intermittent, meaning that it was applied for a period and then switched off.
The magnetic field parameters were varied systematically. The field current was varied from 1 A to 5 A, and the frequency was varied from 5 Hz to 20 Hz. The authors examined the effect of each parameter on the deposit microstructure, hardness and wear resistance.
The test methods were comprehensive. Optical metallography was used to examine the microstructure, X-ray diffraction was used to identify the phases present, microhardness testing was used to measure the hardness of the deposit, and wet sand rubber wheel wear testing was used to measure the abrasive wear resistance.
3. Microstructural and Property Analysis
The authors report that increasing the magnetic field current from 1 A to 3 A increases the number of hard phases in the deposit and improves their distribution. At 3 A, the hard phases are uniformly distributed across the surface, and the deposit achieves its best combination of hardness and wear resistance. Increasing the current beyond 3 A does not produce further improvement, and may even be detrimental.
The effect of frequency is similar. At 10 Hz, the deposit achieves its best properties. Lower frequencies produce fewer hard phases, and higher frequencies produce a less uniform distribution.
The morphological change is particularly interesting. Without electromagnetic stirring, the hard phases are a mixture of long strip-like and hexagonal shapes. With electromagnetic stirring, the long strip-like phases are gradually replaced by regular, uniform hexagonal phases. This is consistent with the stirring promoting the nucleation of new hard phases and the growth of existing ones into a more regular shape.
The wear resistance of the deposit improves with the magnetic field parameters up to the optimum. The wet sand rubber wheel test shows a reduction in weight loss, indicating improved abrasive wear resistance. This is consistent with the increase in hardness and the more uniform distribution of hard phases.
4. Mechanism of Hard Phase Formation and Growth
The mechanism by which electromagnetic stirring affects the hard phase morphology can be understood by considering the solidification process. During solidification, the hard phases nucleate at the fusion line and grow into the molten pool. Without stirring, the growth is columnar, perpendicular to the fusion line. The hard phases grow as long strips or as hexagonal blocks, depending on the crystallographic orientation.
With electromagnetic stirring, the molten metal is set in motion, which breaks up the growing dendrites and distributes the nuclei throughout the pool. This promotes the nucleation of new hard phases at multiple sites, resulting in a more uniform distribution. The stirring also changes the thermal gradient in the pool, which affects the growth direction of the hard phases. The result is a more equiaxed, more uniform microstructure.
The intermittent nature of the magnetic field is important. If the field is applied continuously, the stirring may be too strong and may cause turbulence, which could disrupt the solidification process. The intermittent field allows the pool to settle between stirring cycles, which may promote a more uniform distribution of hard phases.
The optimum parameters of 3 A and 10 Hz are consistent with this mechanism. At 3 A, the stirring is strong enough to break up the dendrites and distribute the nuclei, but not so strong as to cause turbulence. At 10 Hz, the stirring cycles are frequent enough to promote nucleation, but not so frequent as to prevent the pool from settling.
5. Practical Implications and Lessons from the Field
The practical implications of this work are significant for the surfacing industry. The ability to control the deposit microstructure by adjusting the magnetic field parameters offers a new tool for improving the wear resistance of hardfacing deposits. This is particularly valuable for applications such as mining equipment, crusher rolls and mill liners, where the deposit must withstand severe abrasive wear.
The challenge is to implement the electromagnetic stirring in a production environment. The magnetic coil must be positioned around the workpiece, and the power supply must be capable of delivering the required current and frequency. The coil must be water-cooled to prevent overheating, and it must be protected from spatter and slag. The control system must be integrated with the surfacing equipment, and the operator must be able to adjust the frequency and current in real time.
The cost of the electromagnetic stirring equipment is a consideration. A typical magnetic coil and power supply can cost several thousand dollars, which is a significant investment for a small surfacing shop. However, the improvement in deposit quality and wear resistance may justify the cost, particularly for high-volume applications.
The paper does not address the effect of the magnetic field on the arc itself. An alternating magnetic field can cause the arc to wander or to become unstable, which would be detrimental to the deposit quality. The authors used an intermittent field, which may have been chosen to avoid this problem. The welding engineer must be aware of this potential issue and must verify that the arc remains stable when the magnetic field is applied.
In my experience, the most common problem in surfacing operations is not the absence of hard phases but their non-uniform distribution. A deposit with a high concentration of hard phases in one area and a low concentration in another will have inconsistent wear resistance, and the component will fail prematurely. Electromagnetic stirring offers a means of addressing this problem, but it must be applied correctly.
The optimum parameters are not universal; they depend on the alloy composition, the pool size and the welding parameters. A surfacing operation with a large pool and a high deposition rate may require different parameters than one with a small pool and a low deposition rate. The welding engineer must therefore determine the optimum parameters for each application, which requires a series of trials.
6. Study Insights and Recommendations
This paper is a valuable contribution to the understanding of electromagnetic stirring in plasma arc surfacing. It demonstrates that the magnetic field parameters have a significant effect on the deposit microstructure and properties, and it identifies the optimum parameters for the specific alloy and process conditions used.
The most important takeaway is that electromagnetic stirring is a viable tool for improving the wear resistance of hardfacing deposits. It is not a laboratory curiosity; it is a practical technique that can be implemented in a production environment. The challenge is to determine the optimum parameters for each application and to integrate the stirring equipment with the surfacing process.
I would recommend that any surfacing shop considering the use of electromagnetic stirring conduct a full-scale trial on a representative component. The trial should include measurements of hardness, wear resistance and microstructure, and it should be conducted under production conditions. The cost of the trial is modest compared to the potential savings from improved wear resistance and longer service life.
The paper also highlights the value of systematic parameter studies in process development. By varying one parameter at a time and measuring the effect on the deposit properties, the researcher can identify the optimum parameters and understand the underlying mechanisms. This is a more efficient approach than trial and error, and it provides a solid foundation for process optimisation.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd