Semi-Automatic MIG Welding for Stainless Steel Composite Plate Cladding: Process Qualification and Production Experience
1. Background and Application Context
Zhou Junpeng and colleagues from Daqing Oilfield Engineering Construction Co., Ltd. and Daqing Oilfield Mining Services Division address the practical challenge of welding stainless steel composite plates used in pressure vessel fabrication. The composite plate is Q345R + S31603, which consists of a carbon steel backing plate (Q345R) and a stainless steel cladding layer (S31603, equivalent to 316L). This material combination offers the strength of carbon steel at a lower cost than solid stainless steel, while providing the corrosion resistance of 316L on the process side.
The paper focuses on the cladding layer welding, which is the critical operation in composite plate fabrication. The cladding layer must provide a continuous, corrosion-resistant surface, and it must be metallurgically bonded to the backing plate without the formation of brittle phases or dilution of the cladding chemistry. The authors selected semi-automatic metal inert gas (MIG) welding for the cladding layer, using ER309MoL for the transition layer and ER316L for the surface layer.
The choice of semi-automatic MIG welding is significant because it offers a combination of productivity and quality that is well suited to the cladding of large vessel components. Unlike manual metal arc welding, which requires frequent electrode changes and produces a less consistent deposit, semi-automatic MIG welding provides a continuous wire feed and a more uniform deposit. Unlike submerged arc welding, which requires a flux and is limited to flat position, semi-automatic MIG welding can be used in a wider range of positions and provides better control of the heat input.
2. Welding Challenges and Joint Design
The welding of stainless steel composite plates presents several challenges. The first is the difference in thermal expansion between the carbon steel backing and the stainless steel cladding. Carbon steel has a thermal expansion coefficient of approximately 12 × 10⁻⁶ /°C, while stainless steel has a coefficient of approximately 17 × 10⁻⁶ /°C. This difference can cause distortion and residual stress in the composite plate, particularly during welding.
The second challenge is the formation of a hard, brittle martensitic layer at the interface between the backing plate and the cladding. When the carbon steel is heated during welding, the carbon in the steel can diffuse into the stainless steel cladding, forming a chromium carbide precipitate at the interface. This carbide precipitation can reduce the corrosion resistance of the cladding and can cause cracking.
The third challenge is the dilution of the cladding chemistry. When the stainless steel filler metal is deposited on the carbon steel backing, some of the carbon steel melts and mixes with the filler metal, diluting the chromium and nickel content of the cladding. If the dilution is too high, the cladding may not have sufficient corrosion resistance.
The authors addressed these challenges by selecting a joint design that minimises the dilution and by using a two-layer welding procedure. The first layer is a transition layer, deposited with ER309MoL, which has a higher chromium and nickel content than the base metal. This layer absorbs the dilution from the carbon steel and provides a metallurgical transition between the backing and the cladding. The second layer is the surface layer, deposited with ER316L, which provides the required corrosion resistance.
The joint design is critical. The authors selected a V-groove with a root face, which provides good access for the welding torch and allows the operator to control the penetration and dilution. The root face is typically 2–3 mm, and the groove angle is typically 60–70 degrees. The welding is performed from the cladding side, with the root pass deposited in the transition layer and the subsequent passes deposited in the surface layer.
3. Welding Procedure Qualification
The authors conducted a welding procedure qualification test to verify the welding procedure. The test included a visual inspection, a radiographic examination, a bend test, and a chemical analysis of the cladding layer. The results showed that the welding procedure produced a sound deposit with the required mechanical properties and corrosion resistance.
The chemical analysis of the cladding layer is particularly important. The cladding must have a chromium content of at least 16 % and a nickel content of at least 10 % to provide adequate corrosion resistance. The authors report that the cladding layer met these requirements, with a chromium content of approximately 18 % and a nickel content of approximately 12 %.
The bend test is also important because it verifies the ductility of the cladding layer and the integrity of the bond between the cladding and the backing. The authors report that the bend test passed without cracking, indicating that the cladding layer is sound and the bond is strong.
4. Production Experience and Lessons Learned
The authors report that the semi-automatic MIG welding process was successfully used in the fabrication of a stainless steel composite plate vessel. The welding was performed in the flat position, with the vessel rotated to bring the weld seam into the flat position. This allowed the operator to maintain a consistent welding angle and to control the heat input.
The production experience revealed several important lessons. First, the welding parameters must be carefully controlled to avoid excessive dilution. The welding current, voltage and travel speed must be set to achieve the required penetration without melting too much of the backing plate. The authors used a current of approximately 200–250 A, a voltage of approximately 20–24 V, and a travel speed of approximately 20–30 cm/min.
Second, the interpass temperature must be controlled to avoid excessive heat input. The interpass temperature should be kept below 150 °C to minimise the risk of carbide precipitation and distortion. The authors used a temperature-indicating crayon to monitor the interpass temperature and to ensure that the welding was performed within the specified range.
Third, the shielding gas must be selected carefully. The authors used a mixture of argon and carbon dioxide, which provides good arc stability and a clean deposit. The gas flow rate should be set to approximately 15–20 L/min to provide adequate shielding without causing turbulence.
Fourth, the welding must be performed in a clean environment. The cladding surface must be free of oil, grease, rust and other contaminants, which can cause porosity and slag inclusions. The authors used a stainless steel wire brush to clean the surface before welding.
5. Practical Implications for Vessel Fabrication
The use of semi-automatic MIG welding for stainless steel composite plate cladding offers several advantages over alternative methods. The first is productivity. Semi-automatic MIG welding is faster than manual metal arc welding, and it produces a more consistent deposit. The second is quality. The continuous wire feed and the precise control of the welding parameters produce a deposit with fewer defects and a more uniform chemistry. The third is cost. The use of a composite plate reduces the material cost compared to solid stainless steel, and the semi-automatic MIG welding process reduces the labour cost compared to manual welding.
The paper is a good example of the kind of practical research that is needed to advance the vessel fabrication industry. It demonstrates that a relatively simple process change can have a significant effect on the quality and productivity of composite plate welding. The challenge is to implement the process correctly and to ensure that the welding procedure is qualified for the specific application.
I would recommend that any vessel fabricator considering the use of semi-automatic MIG welding for composite plate cladding conduct a full-scale trial on a representative component. The trial should include measurements of the cladding chemistry, the mechanical properties and the corrosion resistance, and it should be conducted under production conditions. The cost of the trial is modest compared to the potential savings from improved productivity and quality.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd