Hardness Is Not the Whole Story in Overlay Weld Metal
What the 2002 paper really says
Many shops still treat overlay weld metal acceptance as a hardness test, but the 2002 paper from Shenyang University of Technology warns that hardness and wear resistance are not a straight line. I have seen too many spool tests pass at 58 HRC and then a pump casing or mill liner fail in three months because the carbide network was wrong, the dilution was too high, or the service was low stress abrasion rather than gouging. The practical message is that overlay quality must be judged by the whole weld metal system: chemistry, microstructure, heat input, dilution, and the type of wear expected at the delivery site.
Technical points that matter on the shop floor
| Factor | What it does | Shop floor control |
|---|---|---|
| Hardness | Resists indentation and some abrasion but does not guarantee toughness | Verify with portable hardness after cooling and record interpass temperature |
| Carbide type and size | Primary carbides can improve sliding wear but large brittle carbides crack under impact | Control filler selection and dilution so carbides are fine and distributed |
| Heat input | High heat can refine some structures but can coarsen carbides and soften the HAZ | Use balanced current, voltage, and weave width and monitor interpass temperature |
| Dilution | Base metal changes overlay chemistry and can create soft zones or brittle phases | Keep dilution within procedure range and use a buffer layer when needed |
| Cooling rate | Influences martensite, bainite, ferrite, and retained austenite | Use preheat and post heat per WPS and avoid quenching by wet plates |
In a real plant, FMEA helps rank these variables. For high impact mining chutes, I put toughness and crack arrest above peak hardness. For slurry pumps, I care about carbide volume fraction and matrix support. If the customer only specifies hardness, I negotiate a microstructure requirement in the technical bid because otherwise delivery becomes a blame game.
Delivery and quality practice
Overlay jobs often travel with the component, so documentation must survive the site. I require macrographs of witness plates, hardness traverses, and when abrasive service is severe, a small impeller test or pin abrasion test. For CRA overlay, dilution control is even more critical because iron pickup can ruin corrosion resistance before wear even starts. Standards such as ASME B16.34 or JB/T for valve trim do not replace the need for a wear-specific qualification. A good overlay procedure is a controlled process, not a hard welding trick.
In short, the 2002 paper is a reminder that wear is a property of a microstructure in a stress state, not a number on a hardness block. The factory must design the overlay around the machine and the site, then prove it with the right tests.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd