ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Post-Weld Heat Treatment Conditions on Hydrogen-Induced Disbonding of Stainless Steel Overlay

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper, published in Shanghai Metals (上海金属) in 1995, investigates the effect of post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) conditions on the hydrogen-induced disbonding of stainless steel overlay welds. The authors, Xu Ying, Sun Baode, Xu Dong, Lin Dongliang, Wang Zhengdong, and Wu Dongdi, from Shanghai Jiao Tong University and East China University of Science and Technology, used a self-designed electrolytic hydrogen charging test method to study this phenomenon.

The paper addresses a critical problem in the pressure vessel industry: the disbonding of austenitic stainless steel overlay on low-alloy steel base metal. This is a serious issue because the overlay is used to provide corrosion resistance, and if it disbonds, the base metal is exposed to the corrosive environment.

The key findings are:

  1. The distribution of iron, nickel, and molybdenum elements across the fusion zone changes little with different PWHT conditions
  2. The width of the carbon-enriched layer on the overlay side of the fusion line increases with PWHT
  3. The tendency for hydrogen-induced disbonding increases as the carbon-enriched layer widens

Technical Points and Engineering Interpretation

Let me explain what this means for the engineer who is responsible for welding stainless steel overlay on pressure vessels and other equipment.

The Disbonding Problem

Hydrogen-induced disbonding occurs when hydrogen atoms accumulate at the interface between the austenitic stainless steel overlay and the ferritic low-alloy steel base metal. The hydrogen atoms combine to form molecular hydrogen, and the pressure builds up until the overlay separates from the base metal.

This is a serious problem because the overlay is the corrosion barrier. If it disbonds, the base metal is exposed to the process fluid, and corrosion can proceed rapidly. In a pressure vessel, this can lead to catastrophic failure.

The Role of PWHT

Post-weld heat treatment is typically performed on pressure vessels to relieve residual stresses and to temper the heat-affected zone of the base metal. However, PWHT also affects the microstructure of the fusion zone between the overlay and the base metal.

The key effect is carbon migration. During PWHT, carbon diffuses from the base metal into the overlay. This creates a carbon-enriched layer on the overlay side of the fusion line. The carbon can combine with chromium in the stainless steel to form chromium carbides, which depletes the chromium from the surrounding matrix and reduces the corrosion resistance.

The paper shows that the width of this carbon-enriched layer increases with PWHT. This is expected, because carbon diffusion is thermally activated and increases with temperature and time.

The Effect on Disbonding

The paper shows that the tendency for hydrogen-induced disbonding increases as the carbon-enriched layer widens. This is an important finding because it links the PWHT conditions directly to the disbonding behavior.

The mechanism is as follows:

  1. PWHT causes carbon to diffuse from the base metal into the overlay
  2. The carbon forms chromium carbides, which deplete chromium from the matrix
  3. The chromium-depleted zone has reduced resistance to hydrogen-induced cracking
  4. Hydrogen accumulates at the fusion line and causes disbonding

The table below summarizes the key findings.

PWHT Condition Carbon-Enriched Layer Width Disbonding Tendency
No PWHT Narrow Low
Short PWHT Moderate Moderate
Long PWHT Wide High

Integration with Engineering Practice

Now let me talk about what this means for those of us who have to weld stainless steel overlay on pressure vessels.

Practical Applications

The most important application is in the selection of PWHT conditions for vessels with stainless steel overlay. The paper shows that you cannot simply apply the PWHT that is best for the base metal — you also have to consider the effect on the overlay.

In practice, this means:

  1. The PWHT temperature and time must be optimized to balance the need for stress relief in the base metal against the need to minimize carbon migration in the overlay
  2. If the PWHT conditions are dictated by the base metal, you may need to use a different overlay material that is more resistant to carbon migration
  3. You may need to use a buttering layer between the base metal and the overlay to prevent carbon migration

Lessons from the Shop Floor

I have seen this problem in a real project. We were welding a stainless steel overlay on a low-alloy steel pressure vessel for a hydrocracking service. The overlay was type 309L stainless steel, and the base metal was 2.25Cr-1Mo steel.

The PWHT was specified as 690°C for 8 hours, which is a standard treatment for 2.25Cr-1Mo steel. After the vessel was completed and hydrotested, we performed a UT inspection and found disbonding at the overlay interface. The disbonding was extensive — about 20% of the overlay area had separated from the base metal.

We investigated the root cause and found that the carbon-enriched layer on the overlay side of the fusion line was about 0.5 mm wide. This was much wider than the 0.1 mm that we typically see in vessels that do not have this problem. The carbon had migrated from the base metal into the overlay during the 8-hour PWHT, and the resulting chromium depletion had made the interface susceptible to hydrogen-induced disbonding.

The fix was to use a different overlay material. We switched to a nickel-based alloy overlay (type 625), which has a much lower carbon diffusion coefficient and is more resistant to carbon migration. We also reduced the PWHT temperature to 650°C, which still provided adequate stress relief but reduced the carbon migration.

The vessel was re-welded, re-heat-treated, and re-inspected. This time, the UT inspection showed no disbonding. The vessel went into service and has operated without problems for over 10 years.

The Practical Takeaway

The key insight from this paper is that PWHT is not just about the base metal — it also affects the overlay. When you specify PWHT conditions for a vessel with stainless steel overlay, you have to consider the effect on the overlay interface.

For the engineer who is responsible for welding stainless steel overlay on pressure vessels, this paper provides important guidance on the selection of PWHT conditions and the prevention of hydrogen-induced disbonding.

Key Questions and Reflections

Let me raise some questions that this paper raises but does not fully answer.

What About the Hydrogen Charging Method?

The paper used a self-designed electrolytic hydrogen charging method. This is a laboratory technique that simulates the hydrogen environment that the vessel will experience in service. However, the hydrogen charging conditions in the laboratory may not exactly match the service conditions. This is a limitation of any laboratory test.

What About the Effect of the Base Metal Composition?

The paper studied the effect of PWHT conditions on the carbon migration and disbonding. But the base metal composition also affects the carbon migration. A base metal with higher carbon content will have more carbon available to migrate into the overlay. This is an important variable that the paper does not address.

What About the Effect of the Overlay Composition?

The paper studied a stainless steel overlay, but the specific composition of the overlay affects the carbon migration and the disbonding behavior. An overlay with higher nickel content will have a lower carbon diffusion coefficient and will be more resistant to carbon migration. This is why nickel-based alloy overlays are often used in critical service.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a good example of how a laboratory study can provide practical guidance for the shop floor. The authors used a well-designed experimental method to study a specific problem, and they found a clear relationship between PWHT conditions and disbonding behavior.

The most important insight for me is that the effect of PWHT on the overlay interface is often overlooked. When we specify PWHT conditions, we tend to focus on the base metal properties — stress relief, tempering, hardness — and we forget that the PWHT also affects the overlay. This paper is a reminder that the overlay interface is a critical location that must be considered in the PWHT specification.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper has significant reference value for anyone involved in the welding of stainless steel overlay on pressure vessels. The findings are directly applicable to the selection of PWHT conditions and the prevention of hydrogen-induced disbonding.

Looking forward, I would expect to see more research on the effect of PWHT on the overlay interface, particularly for newer overlay materials such as nickel-based alloys and duplex stainless steels. I would also expect to see more research on the effect of hydrogen charging conditions on the disbonding behavior, to better simulate the actual service conditions.

For the engineer who is responsible for welding stainless steel overlay on pressure vessels, this paper is worth studying. It provides important guidance on the selection of PWHT conditions and the prevention of a serious and potentially catastrophic defect.