ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Hardfacing of E-Grade Steel by MAG Welding: Microstructure, Properties, and Carbon Migration

Introduction

This study by Ding Yongfeng, Xu Wujiao, and Lei Fan from Chongqing University addresses the microstructure and properties of a MAG hardfacing layer deposited on E-grade steel using flux-cored wire and electrode 635E. The work is directly relevant to my experience in the repair and refurbishment of heavy machinery components, where hardfacing is routinely used to restore dimensions and improve surface performance. The paper's focus on carbon migration at the fusion boundary is a critical metallurgical phenomenon that I have seen cause premature failures in service if not properly understood and controlled.

Microstructure and Metallurgical Analysis

The authors report that the hardfacing layer exhibits good fusion bonding with the substrate, which is the fundamental requirement for any successful hardfacing operation. The heat-affected zone (HAZ) consists primarily of tempered martensite, indicating that the welding thermal cycle and any subsequent post-weld heat treatment have produced a stable, tough microstructure. This is consistent with my experience on the shop floor, where E-grade steels, typically used in structural and machinery applications, require careful control of cooling rates to avoid untempered martensite formation, which would be brittle and prone to cracking.

The hardfacing layer itself shows good strength and toughness, which the authors attribute to the alloying system of the 635E electrode. In my practice, I always insist on checking the chemical composition of the deposited metal, not just the filler wire, because dilution from the base metal can significantly alter the final alloy content. The paper's chemical analysis of the hardfacing layer is therefore a valuable contribution, as it allows engineers to predict the in-service performance based on the actual composition rather than the nominal wire composition.

Carbon Migration and Its Effects

The most significant finding of this study is the observation of carbon migration during hardfacing and subsequent tempering. The authors clearly identify a decarburized layer on the base metal side of the fusion boundary and a carburized layer on the weld metal side. The decarburized layer exhibits a microhardness significantly lower than that of the base material, while the carburized layer shows precipitated carbides and high hardness. This is a classic example of the carbon activity gradient that exists when a high-carbon steel is joined to a low-carbon or alloyed weld metal.

I have encountered this phenomenon many times in the repair of rolls, shafts, and dies. The practical consequence is a soft zone just below the hardfacing, which can become a preferential site for wear, corrosion, or fatigue crack initiation. In one memorable case, a large forging press column that had been hardfaced and then machined failed after only six months of service due to a soft decarburized zone that had been worn away, allowing the hardfacing to spall off. The solution was to redesign the hardfacing procedure to include a buffer layer of nickel-based alloy, which reduces the carbon activity gradient and suppresses the migration.

Practical Implications and Lessons Learned

From a manufacturing and delivery perspective, this paper reinforces several critical process control points. First, the tempering temperature and time must be carefully selected to minimize carbon migration while still achieving the desired hardness and stress relief. Second, the hardfacing process parameters, particularly heat input and interpass temperature, must be controlled to limit the width of the HAZ and the extent of the decarburized layer. Third, the chemical composition of the filler wire must be matched to the base material to minimize the carbon activity difference.

In my experience, the best way to manage this issue is to use a two-layer hardfacing technique. The first layer is deposited with a lower heat input and a filler material that has a carbon content close to that of the base metal, creating a transition zone. The second layer, which provides the final wear-resistant surface, is then deposited with the desired hardfacing alloy. This approach has consistently produced sound, crack-free hardfacing with minimal carbon migration and excellent service performance.

Conclusion

This study provides a thorough metallurgical explanation of carbon migration in MAG hardfacing of E-grade steel and its effect on the hardness distribution across the fusion boundary. The findings are directly applicable to the repair and fabrication of steel components in the heavy machinery and steel pipe industries. For any engineer involved in hardfacing operations, the key takeaway is that the fusion boundary is not a simple interface but a complex metallurgical zone where carbon diffusion can create both soft and hard regions, each with its own failure modes. By understanding and controlling this phenomenon through proper material selection, process parameters, and post-weld heat treatment, we can ensure that hardfaced components deliver reliable, long-lasting service. This paper is a valuable reference for anyone seeking to avoid the costly mistakes that arise from neglecting this fundamental metallurgical principle.