Repair of Disc Shear Blades by Surfacing Welding
Overview of the Literature
This paper, published in China Surface Engineering (2006, Vol. 19, No. 3), addresses a subject that is directly relevant to any steel pipe production line: the repair of disc shear blades by surfacing welding. The authors, from the Welding Research Institute of MCC Group, describe the selection of a flux-cored wire (YJ259-S) and the use of automatic submerged-arc surfacing to restore worn blades. The paper reports that the repaired blades have strength and toughness equivalent to the original, and wear resistance 20% higher than the base metal. The blades were subsequently run in actual production and met all requirements. This is a classic example of extending the service life of expensive tooling through a well-executed repair programme.
Why Disc Shear Blades Wear Out
Disc shear blades are used to cut steel strip and plate in pipe mills, slitting lines, and shearing lines. The cutting edge experiences high contact stresses, abrasive wear, and occasional impact loading. The typical failure modes are:
| Failure Mode | Description | Contributing Factors |
|---|---|---|
| Abrasive wear | Gradual loss of cutting edge material due to sliding contact with the strip | Hardness of the strip, surface scale, cutting speed |
| Chipping | Localised fracture of the cutting edge | Impact loading, insufficient toughness, hard inclusions in the strip |
| Plastic deformation | Rounded or flattened cutting edge | Excessive cutting force, insufficient hardness of the blade |
| Fatigue cracking | Cracks initiating at the cutting edge and propagating | Cyclic loading, stress concentration at the edge |
In a pipe mill, the shear blades are often used to cut the strip before forming, or to trim the edges. The wear rate depends on the material being cut, the thickness, and the operating conditions. When the blade becomes worn, the cutting quality deteriorates, leading to burrs, edge damage, and potential problems in the forming process.
Surfacing Material and Process Selection
The paper selected YJ259-S, a flux-cored wire designed for submerged-arc surfacing. This wire produces a deposit with a chemical composition that provides a good balance of hardness and toughness. The key parameters of the surfacing process are summarised below:
| Parameter | Typical Value | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Wire diameter | 3.2 mm or 4.0 mm | Selected based on the blade size and required deposition rate |
| Welding current | 300–450 A | Adjusted to achieve the desired penetration and dilution |
| Arc voltage | 28–34 V | Maintained to ensure stable arc and proper bead shape |
| Travel speed | 30–50 cm/min | Controlled to achieve the required build-up thickness |
| Preheat temperature | 200–300 °C | Required for high-carbon or alloyed blade materials |
| Interpass temperature | ≤ 350 °C | To prevent excessive heat input and distortion |
| Post-weld heat treatment | Stress relief at 550–600 °C | Optional, depending on the blade material and service conditions |
The paper emphasises that the dilution rate must be controlled. If the dilution is too high, the deposit will be contaminated with base metal, reducing the hardness and wear resistance. If it is too low, the bond between the deposit and the base metal may be inadequate. A dilution rate of 20–30% is typically acceptable for this application.
Repair Procedure and Quality Control
The repair procedure described in the paper follows a logical sequence:
- Preparation: The worn blade is cleaned to remove oil, grease, and scale. The worn area is machined or ground to remove any cracked or damaged material, ensuring a sound base for the surfacing.
- Preheating: The blade is preheated to the specified temperature to reduce the risk of cracking due to thermal stress.
- Surfacing: The automatic submerged-arc surfacing is performed in multiple passes, with each pass overlapping the previous one by 30–50%. The welding parameters are monitored and recorded.
- Post-weld treatment: After surfacing, the blade is allowed to cool slowly, and a stress-relief treatment is applied if required.
- Machining: The surfaced area is machined back to the original dimensions, with a final grinding operation to achieve the required surface finish and cutting edge geometry.
- Inspection: The repaired blade is inspected for surface defects (PT or MT), hardness (on the cutting edge), and dimensional accuracy.
The paper reports that the repaired blades achieved a hardness of 55–60 HRC on the cutting edge, which is comparable to the original blade. The wear resistance was 20% higher, which the authors attribute to the fine-grained microstructure of the deposit and the presence of hard carbides.
Practical Experience and Lessons Learned
I have seen similar repair programmes on shear blades in pipe mills, and the results are generally positive if the procedure is followed correctly. However, there are some pitfalls that I would like to highlight:
- Insufficient preheating: If the blade is not preheated adequately, the first pass of surfacing can cause cracking, especially on high-carbon or alloyed blades. The crack may not be visible until after machining, leading to a rejected blade.
- Incorrect dilution control: If the welding current is too high, the dilution increases, and the deposit becomes softer and less wear-resistant. This is a common mistake when the operator tries to increase the deposition rate.
- Distortion: Thin blades can distort during surfacing due to the thermal input. The distortion can be controlled by using a lower heat input, applying the surfacing in a balanced sequence, and using clamping fixtures.
- Post-weld inspection: It is essential to perform NDE after machining, not just before. A defect that is hidden in the as-welded condition may become visible after the surface is machined.
In one project I was involved in, the repair programme extended the life of the shear blades by a factor of three, resulting in significant cost savings. The key was to establish a clear procedure, train the operators, and monitor the results over time.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a practical guide for anyone involved in the repair of shear blades or similar cutting tools. The main takeaways are:
- The selection of the surfacing material is critical. The wire must be compatible with the base metal and the service conditions.
- Automatic submerged-arc surfacing is a reliable and cost-effective method for repairing large blades, provided that the process parameters are controlled.
- The quality of the repair depends on proper preparation, preheating, and post-weld treatment.
- The repaired blade can have performance equal to or better than the original, but only if the repair is performed correctly.
In summary, this paper demonstrates that a well-designed repair programme can significantly extend the service life of expensive tooling, reducing downtime and cost. It is a valuable reference for plant engineers and maintenance personnel.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd