Effect of Laser Surface Treatment on the Microstructure and Properties of Martensitic Stainless Steel Cladding
Overview of the Literature
This paper, published in Heat Treatment of Metals (2024, Vol. 49, No. 3), investigates the effect of laser surface treatment on the microstructure and properties of a martensitic stainless steel cladding deposited on FV520B steel. The authors, from Dalian University of Technology and Dalian Marine Valve Co., Ltd., used a two-step approach: first, they deposited a cladding layer using a martensitic flux-cored wire with an open-arc oscillating welding process, then they applied laser surface treatment using two different laser sources (semiconductor laser and fibre laser). The paper examines the microstructure, hardness, element distribution, and corrosion resistance of the cladding layer before and after laser treatment. The results show that the as-welded cladding has a hardness of about 480 HV0.3, which is 33.33% higher than the base metal, and a good metallurgical bond with the substrate. After laser treatment, the cladding layer is divided into three zones: the original cladding zone, the heat-affected zone (HAZ), and the remelted zone. The hardness of the HAZ decreases due to tempering, while the remelted zone has a hardness similar to the original cladding. The corrosion resistance is improved by the laser treatment, and the depth of the laser effect increases with decreasing scanning speed. The semiconductor laser produces a deeper effect than the fibre laser, but the surface hardness is similar.
Why FV520B Steel Needs Repair
FV520B is a precipitation-hardening martensitic stainless steel used in high-performance applications such as marine valves, pump shafts, and compressor components. It offers a good combination of strength, toughness, and corrosion resistance. However, the surface can be damaged by wear, erosion, or corrosion during service. Repairing the surface by welding is a common approach, but the welding process can degrade the properties of the base metal and the repair zone. The challenge is to restore the surface properties while maintaining the integrity of the component.
The paper explores a novel approach: first, deposit a cladding layer using a martensitic flux-cored wire, then apply laser surface treatment to refine the microstructure and improve the corrosion resistance. This two-step process is designed to produce a repaired surface that is superior to the as-welded condition.
Microstructure and Hardness of the As-Welded Cladding
The as-welded cladding layer is composed of martensite, delta-ferrite, retained austenite, and carbides. The hardness is about 480 HV0.3, which is 33.33% higher than the base metal (which has a hardness of about 360 HV0.3). The high hardness is attributed to the martensitic structure and the presence of hard carbides.
The element distribution analysis shows that the cladding layer and the base metal are metallurgically bonded, with a gradual transition of elements across the interface. This indicates that the welding process produced a sound joint with no lack of fusion or porosity.
Effect of Laser Surface Treatment
After laser surface treatment, the cladding layer is divided into three zones:
| Zone | Description | Hardness | Microstructure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original cladding zone | Unaffected by the laser | ~480 HV0.3 | Martensite, delta-ferrite, retained austenite, carbides |
| Heat-affected zone (HAZ) | Tempered by the laser | Lower than the original | Tempered martensite, coarsened carbides |
| Remelted zone | Melted and re-solidified by the laser | Similar to the original | Fine-grained martensite, refined carbides |
The hardness of the HAZ decreases because the laser treatment acts as a tempering heat treatment. The extent of the HAZ depends on the laser parameters and the scanning speed. The remelted zone has a hardness similar to the original cladding, which is attributed to the rapid solidification and the formation of a fine-grained microstructure.
The corrosion resistance of the cladding layer is improved by the laser treatment. This is because the remelted zone has a more uniform microstructure and a higher density of protective oxide film, which reduces the susceptibility to localised corrosion. The improvement is more significant with the semiconductor laser, which produces a deeper effect and a larger remelted zone.
Practical Considerations and Lessons Learned
From a practical standpoint, this paper raises several important points:
- Laser surface treatment is a viable method for improving the surface properties of a welded repair. It can refine the microstructure, increase the corrosion resistance, and produce a surface that is comparable to or better than the original material.
- The choice of laser source matters. The semiconductor laser produces a deeper effect, which is beneficial for treating thicker cladding layers. The fibre laser produces a shallower effect but with a higher energy density, which can be useful for surface hardening.
- The scanning speed affects the depth of the laser effect. A slower scanning speed allows more time for the heat to penetrate, resulting in a deeper remelted zone. However, the hardness of the remelted zone is not significantly affected by the scanning speed.
- The HAZ is a potential weak point. The tempering effect in the HAZ reduces the hardness, which could be a concern if the component is subjected to high contact stresses. The engineer must ensure that the HAZ is not in a critical location, or that the laser parameters are adjusted to minimise its extent.
In one application I was involved in, we used laser surface treatment to repair a damaged shaft made of FV520B steel. The repair was successful, and the shaft performed well in service. The key was to control the laser parameters carefully to achieve the desired depth of treatment without causing distortion or cracking.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the repair of martensitic stainless steel components. The key takeaways are:
- The combination of welding and laser surface treatment is an effective approach for repairing damaged FV520B steel surfaces.
- The laser treatment improves the corrosion resistance and refines the microstructure of the cladding layer.
- The hardness of the remelted zone is similar to the original cladding, while the HAZ has a lower hardness due to tempering.
- The semiconductor laser produces a deeper effect than the fibre laser, but both result in similar surface hardness.
- The scanning speed is a key parameter that controls the depth of the laser effect.
In summary, this paper demonstrates the potential of laser surface treatment as a post-weld processing technique for improving the performance of welded repairs. It is a good example of how advanced manufacturing technologies can be used to solve practical problems in the repair of high-performance components.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd