ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Plasma Surfacing Speed Effects on Ni60 Coating Microstructure and Hardness

Overview and Practical Significance

This study by Luo Shengyang and Yuan Zhentao addresses a question I have wrestled with on the shop floor more times than I care to count: what happens when you push the travel speed on a plasma transferred arc (PTA) surfacing torch too fast or too slow? The authors systematically varied surfacing speed from 100 to 300 mm/min on 304 stainless steel substrates with Ni60 powder and characterised the resulting coatings through optical microscopy, SEM, XRD, EDS and microhardness testing. The findings are straightforward but the implications run deep for anyone responsible for hardfacing valve seats, pump components, or extruder screws. The optimum speed of 200 mm/min produced the best combination of wetting angle (55°) and dilution rate (4.5%), with the finest grain structure and the highest average hardness. What the paper does not say explicitly, but what I know from experience, is that this kind of optimisation is not a laboratory curiosity—it is the difference between a component that lasts one campaign and one that lasts five.

Technical Parameter Analysis

Parameter Value at 200 mm/min Engineering Significance
Wetting angle 55° Indicates good spreading and fusion with substrate
Dilution rate 4.5% Low dilution preserves Ni60's hard-phase content
Primary phase Columnar dendrites + faceted precipitates Favourable for wear resistance
FeNix phase crystallinity Peak at 200 mm/min Optimal hard-phase formation
Boride crystallinity Peak at 200 mm/min Optimal hard-phase formation
Average microhardness Maximum at 200 mm/min Direct correlation with service life

The relationship between surfacing speed and dilution is the crux of the matter. At lower speeds, the arc dwells longer, melting more substrate and increasing dilution—which pulls iron into the coating and dilutes the nickel-based hard phases. At higher speeds, the coating becomes thinner and less uniform, with poor wetting and potential lack of fusion. The 200 mm/min sweet spot balances these competing effects. I have seen this pattern repeated across dozens of alloy systems, and the lesson is always the same: you cannot optimise surfacing parameters in isolation; you must optimise them against the dilution rate you can tolerate for the specific service condition.

Microstructural Evolution and Phase Analysis

The paper reports that the coating's central region consists of columnar dendrites with precipitates growing in a faceted, lateral manner. This is typical of Ni60 solidification, where the primary γ-Ni phase grows dendritically and the hard phases (CrB, Cr2B, Ni3B, and various carbides) precipitate in the inter-dendritic regions. The XRD results show that FeNix and boride phases reach maximum crystallinity at 200 mm/min. This is not merely a matter of phase quantity—it is about phase distribution and morphology. At the optimum speed, the grain structure is refined, meaning more grain boundaries and a more uniform distribution of hard phases. The hardness profile across the coating thickness is also more consistent, which matters enormously in service where a soft spot can initiate premature wear or spalling.

Engineering Practice Insights

In my experience with PTA surfacing of Ni60 on 304 stainless steel for chemical processing equipment, the dilution rate is the single most important parameter to control. A dilution rate above 8% will typically reduce the coating's hardness by 10–15% and significantly degrade its corrosion resistance, because the iron content rises and the chromium-nickel balance shifts. The 4.5% dilution achieved at 200 mm/min is excellent—well within the acceptable range for most critical service. However, I would caution that this optimum is specific to the substrate, powder, and torch configuration used in the study. Changing the substrate to carbon steel or changing the powder to Ni60A with different boron and silicon content will shift the optimum. The practical approach is to run a design of experiments (DOE) on your own equipment, measuring dilution and hardness for each parameter combination, and then lock in the process window.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that the paper leaves partially unanswered is the effect of surfacing speed on residual stress and distortion. Faster speeds generally reduce heat input per unit length, which lowers residual stress but can also increase the risk of lack of fusion. The authors note the coating quality at 200 mm/min is "best" from a macro perspective, but they do not quantify residual stresses. From a practical standpoint, this matters for thin-walled components where distortion can cause dimensional problems. I would recommend that any engineer applying these findings also verify distortion and residual stress levels on the actual component geometry, not just on test coupons.

Another practical consideration is the effect of multiple passes. The study uses single-layer, single-pass deposits. In real applications, we often need multiple passes to build up thickness or to cover larger areas. The heat input from subsequent passes will temper the previous layers, potentially reducing hardness. The 200 mm/min optimum may need adjustment when stacking passes, and the interpass temperature becomes a critical variable. My rule of thumb is to keep interpass temperature below 150°C for Ni60 to avoid over-tempering.

Study Insights and Implications

The key takeaway from this work is that surfacing speed is not just a productivity parameter—it is a metallurgical control parameter. The authors demonstrate convincingly that speed affects phase crystallinity, grain size, and hardness through its influence on dilution and cooling rate. For the plant engineer, this means that the "fastest possible" surfacing speed is rarely the best. The optimum is the speed that gives you the dilution rate and microstructure you need for the service condition, and that optimum must be established experimentally for each combination of substrate, powder, and equipment.

I would also note that the authors' choice of 304 stainless steel as the substrate is significant. 304 has a relatively high thermal conductivity compared to carbon steel, which affects the cooling rate and thus the microstructure. On a carbon steel substrate, the same parameters would produce a different dilution rate and different grain structure. This reinforces the point that process parameters are substrate-specific, and what works on 304 may not work on 16Mn or Q235.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a solid contribution to the practical literature on PTA surfacing. It provides a clear example of how a single process parameter—surfacing speed—can be optimised to achieve a specific microstructural outcome. For engineers working on hardfacing of valve seats, pump impellers, or other components subject to abrasive and corrosive wear, the methodology is directly transferable. The finding that 200 mm/min is the optimum for this specific system is useful as a starting point, but the real value lies in the demonstration that dilution rate and crystallinity are the controlling factors, not just hardness measurements.

Looking ahead, I would like to see more work on the effect of surfacing speed on the interface between the coating and the substrate, particularly the fusion zone where dilution occurs. The authors mention the dilution rate but do not characterise the fusion zone in detail. In my experience, the fusion zone is where failures often initiate—either through lack of fusion, excessive dilution, or the formation of brittle intermetallic compounds. A follow-up study using EDS line scans across the fusion zone at different surfacing speeds would be valuable.

In conclusion, this study reinforces the fundamental principle that surfacing parameters must be selected based on the desired microstructure and properties, not just on deposition rate. The 200 mm/min optimum found here is a useful data point, but the methodology is the real takeaway. Set up your own trials, measure dilution and hardness, and you will find your own optimum—and when you do, your components will last longer, and your customers will notice.