Surfacing Process and Application of Large Segmented Trimming Dies
The Problem and the Proposed Route
This 2003 paper from Modern Manufacturing Engineering addresses a classic cost dilemma in press shop tooling. Large trimming dies for automotive and agricultural equipment are expensive to manufacture from solid tool steel, and when they wear out, replacement is a major capital expense. The authors propose using ordinary cast iron as the base material and building up the cutting edges with surfacing welding. This approach is described as simple, reliable and economically superior to traditional methods. The study was funded by the Machinery Industry Ministry education science fund and conducted jointly by East China Jiaotong University and the First Tractor Engineering Machinery Company. The key performance claim is that the surfacing cast iron inserts achieve a service life of approximately 25,000 pieces, which is comparable to tool steel inserts that have been through full heat treatment. Furthermore, the surfacing approach improves life by 30 to 50 percent compared to cold stamping dies repaired with D322 electrodes.
Process Details and Material Selection
The process starts with a cast iron base block. The cutting edge area is machined to accept a surfacing layer, and then the appropriate surfacing electrode is applied. The choice of electrode is critical. D322 is a common Cr-W-Mo-V type electrode used for hot work die repair, but the authors found that a more robust surfacing system, likely based on a higher alloy content, gives better performance. The cast iron base must be prepared properly. I have seen too many shops try to weld directly on cast iron without preheating, and the result is always the same: cracking in the heat affected zone. The paper does not dwell on preheat, but from my experience, cast iron needs a preheat of 200 to 300 degrees Celsius, and the welding must be done with low heat input and short bead lengths to minimize thermal stress. The surfacing layer must be thick enough to allow for re-sharpening, typically 3 to 5 mm of finished deposit.
Performance Comparison and Life Data
The performance data is the heart of this paper. The table below summarizes the key findings.
| Parameter | Cast Iron Base + Surfacing | Tool Steel Insert (Heat Treated) | D322 Repaired Die |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base material | Ordinary cast iron | Tool steel | Cast iron |
| Edge material | Surfacing deposit | Tool steel | D322 deposit |
| Service life (pieces) | ~25,000 | ~25,000 | ~17,000-19,000 |
| Relative life | 100% | 100% | 70-80% |
| Cost | Low | High | Medium |
| Repair ability | Excellent | Poor | Fair |
The 30 to 50 percent improvement over D322 repaired dies is significant. D322 is a reasonable electrode for cold work applications, but it lacks the carbide-forming elements needed for abrasive wear resistance in trimming operations. The surfacing system used in this study, likely with higher Cr and Mo content, forms more stable carbides and gives a tougher matrix. From a production planning perspective, the ability to repair a large die multiple times by re-surfacing is a major advantage. A solid tool steel insert, once worn, may be scrapped. A cast iron base with surfacing can be re-machined and re-surfaced repeatedly, spreading the initial cost over many more production cycles.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
I have applied this exact approach on trimming dies for large diameter pipe fittings. The key is not just the electrode selection, but the entire repair cycle. You must machine the worn surface back to sound metal, inspect for cracks with magnetic particle testing, preheat properly, apply the surfacing in a controlled pattern, and then stress relieve or temper to reduce residual stress. The paper mentions that the process is simple, but simple does not mean careless. The most common failure I see is insufficient removal of the worn layer. If you weld over a cracked or work-hardened surface, the new deposit will crack within days. The 25,000 piece life is achievable only if the base metal is sound and the preheat and interpass temperature are controlled.
Summary
This paper demonstrates a pragmatic and cost-effective route to manufacturing and repairing large trimming dies. The combination of a cast iron base with a properly selected surfacing alloy delivers a service life equivalent to solid tool steel at a fraction of the cost, and it offers the additional advantage of repeatable repair. The 30 to 50 percent improvement over D322 repaired dies is a clear signal that electrode selection matters more than many shops acknowledge. For the engineer responsible for tooling costs, this approach deserves serious consideration, but it demands disciplined execution of preheat, welding and post-weld treatment.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd