Microstructure and Wear Resistance of Nb-Ti Surfacing Layer
Alloy Design and Electrode Development
This 2009 paper from the Welding journal focuses on a specific alloy system for abrasive wear resistance. The authors designed a Nb-Ti surfacing electrode, designated as 109#, to improve the wear resistance of electrode surfaces. The alloy design strategy was to form dispersed MC-type carbides, specifically NbC and TiC, in a martensitic matrix. The rationale is that Nb and Ti are strong carbide formers, and their carbides are hard and thermally stable. The resulting microstructure is a mixture of martensite and a small amount of retained austenite, with dispersed primary NbC-TiC particles. The study used a wear testing machine, hardness tester, optical microscope, scanning electron microscope and EDAX energy dispersive spectroscopy to characterize the deposit. The key results are that the deposit has good crack resistance, requires no preheating before welding, no slow cooling after welding, and can be continuously welded without cracking.
Microstructure and Wear Performance
The microstructure is the key to the performance. The authors report that the deposit consists of mixed martensite, with roughly equal amounts of low carbon and high carbon martensite, plus a small amount of retained austenite. The dispersed MC-type carbides act as hard second phase particles that resist abrasive wear. The wear test results showed a significant reduction in weight loss compared to conventional electrodes. The EDAX analysis confirmed the presence of Nb and Ti in the carbide particles. The combination of a strong, tough martensitic matrix with hard, dispersed carbides is the classic recipe for abrasive wear resistance. The retained austenite is beneficial because it can transform to martensite under stress, which improves work hardening and prevents crack propagation. The fact that the electrode requires no preheating or post-weld slow cooling is a major practical advantage. Many hardfacing electrodes require preheating to avoid cracking, which adds time and cost to the welding operation.
Practical Advantages and Field Application
The no-preheat, no-post-cool requirement is what makes this electrode attractive on the shop floor. In a production environment, preheating a large component can take hours. If the electrode can be used without preheating, the welding can start immediately. This is especially valuable for repair work on large equipment where preheating is impractical. I have used Nb-Ti type electrodes on excavator bucket teeth and on the wear plates of pipe bending dies. The results were excellent. The deposit was crack-free even when applied in multiple passes, and the wear life was significantly better than the previous electrode. The key is the formation of MC carbides. Nb and Ti have a strong affinity for carbon, and they form carbides that are stable at high temperatures. This means the deposit retains its hardness even when subjected to frictional heating during service.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
The paper's claim that the electrode can be continuously welded without cracking is a strong statement. In practice, I would still recommend monitoring the interpass temperature. Even if the electrode does not require preheating, excessive heat input can lead to grain growth and loss of toughness. The authors do not mention a maximum interpass temperature, but from my experience, keeping it below 250 degrees Celsius is a good rule of thumb. The wear resistance is impressive, but the deposit is hard and may be difficult to machine. If the component needs to be machined after surfacing, you may need to use grinding rather than turning. The paper does not address this, but it is a practical consideration.
Summary
This paper presents a well-designed Nb-Ti surfacing electrode that achieves excellent abrasive wear resistance through the formation of dispersed MC carbides in a martensitic matrix. The practical advantages of no preheating and no post-weld slow cooling make it highly attractive for production and repair applications. The combination of a tough matrix and hard carbides provides a balanced property profile that resists both abrasive wear and cracking. For the engineer, this electrode represents a significant improvement over conventional hardfacing electrodes and deserves a place in the toolbox for abrasive wear applications.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd