ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effects of Preheating Temperature and Welding Current on the Microstructure and Properties of Surfacing Layers on 4Cr5Mo2V Steel

Literature Overview and Practical Context

This study from China University of Mining and Technology, Zhejiang Qingshan Steel, Jiangsu University of Science and Technology, and Shenzhen Institute of Metrology and Innovation examines the effects of preheating temperature and welding current on the microstructure and properties of surfacing layers deposited on 4Cr5Mo2V die steel. The authors used both experimental testing and numerical simulation of the temperature field to understand the mechanisms behind the observed changes in microstructure and properties.

The key findings are particularly relevant to anyone involved in die repair and hardfacing operations. Without preheating, a welding current of 70 A produced a molten pool with a width of 7.0 mm and a depth of 1.5 mm, and the resulting grains were 10.9 μm long and 4.0 μm wide. Increasing the welding current caused the peak temperature of the molten pool to rise significantly, which increased the pool size, grain size, and heat-affected zone (HAZ) width, thereby degrading the properties of the surfacing layer. Preheating reduced the cooling rate of the surfacing layer, which gradually decreased the average hardness. After preheating at 450°C, the average hardness of the surfacing layer decreased by 4.9%, while the base metal retained its original hardness, resulting in a surfacing layer with a good combination of strength and toughness.

Technical Interpretation of Temperature Field Effects

The Role of Welding Current in Determining Pool Geometry and Grain Size

The study clearly demonstrates that welding current is the primary factor controlling the size of the molten pool and the resulting grain structure. Higher welding current increases the heat input to the weld, which increases the peak temperature of the molten pool. This higher peak temperature increases the pool width and depth, and also increases the size of the grains that form during solidification. Larger grains generally result in lower strength and toughness, which is why the properties of the surfacing layer degrade with increasing welding current.

The numerical simulation of the temperature field confirmed these observations. The peak temperature of the molten pool increased significantly with increasing welding current, and this was directly correlated with the observed changes in pool geometry and grain size. This demonstrates the value of numerical simulation in understanding the relationship between welding parameters and microstructure.

The Role of Preheating Temperature in Controlling Cooling Rate and Hardness

Preheating the base metal before welding reduces the temperature gradient between the weld and the base metal, which reduces the cooling rate of the weld and the HAZ. A slower cooling rate allows more time for diffusion and grain growth, which typically results in a softer deposit. The study found that preheating at 450°C reduced the average hardness of the surfacing layer by 4.9%, while the base metal retained its original hardness.

The key insight here is that preheating can be used to achieve a better combination of strength and toughness in the surfacing layer. By reducing the cooling rate, preheating promotes the formation of a more balanced microstructure that is less likely to crack or fail prematurely in service. This is particularly important for die steels, which are subject to both thermal and mechanical loading.

The Importance of Achieving a Strong-Toughness Match

The study emphasizes that the goal of preheating is to achieve a strong-toughness match in the surfacing layer. A surfacing layer that is too hard may be brittle and prone to cracking, while a surfacing layer that is too soft may not provide adequate wear resistance. By controlling the preheating temperature, it is possible to achieve a surfacing layer with the optimal balance of strength and toughness for the specific application.

Engineering Practice Implications for Die Repair and Hardfacing

Application to Die Steel Repair

In the steel pipe industry, die steels are used for forming and shaping operations, such as in the production of pipe fittings and flanges. These dies are subject to wear, thermal fatigue, and mechanical loading, and they often require repair through hardfacing. The findings from this study have direct relevance to the repair of 4Cr5Mo2V and similar die steels.

Preheating Recommendations

Based on my experience with die repair and hardfacing, I would recommend the following preheating guidelines:

Preheating Temperature Application Expected Effect
No preheating Small, simple repairs Higher hardness, higher cracking risk
200-300°C Medium-sized repairs Moderate hardness, moderate cracking risk
350-450°C Large, complex repairs Lower hardness, lower cracking risk
Above 450°C Very large, highly restrained repairs Lowest hardness, lowest cracking risk

Welding Current Optimisation

The study's finding that increasing welding current degrades the properties of the surfacing layer has direct implications for welding parameter selection. For die repair, the welding current should be set as low as possible while still achieving adequate fusion and deposition rate. Higher welding currents may increase productivity, but they also increase the risk of grain growth and property degradation.

Numerical Simulation as a Tool for Process Optimisation

The use of numerical simulation in this study demonstrates the value of this approach for process optimisation. By simulating the temperature field, it is possible to predict the effects of welding parameters on the microstructure and properties of the surfacing layer without extensive trial and error. This is particularly valuable for applications where the cost of experimentation is high, such as in the repair of large or complex dies.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that this study raises is the relationship between preheating temperature and the risk of hydrogen-induced cracking. Preheating is often used to reduce the risk of hydrogen-induced cracking by allowing hydrogen to diffuse out of the weld before it can cause cracking. However, preheating also reduces the cooling rate, which may increase the risk of other types of cracking, such as solidification cracking or reheat cracking. The optimal preheating temperature must balance these competing effects.

Another point worth reflecting on is the interaction between preheating temperature and the number of passes in a multi-pass weld. In multi-pass welding, the interpass temperature is effectively the preheating temperature for subsequent passes. The study examined single-pass welding, but in practice, die repair often involves multiple passes. The interpass temperature must be carefully controlled to avoid excessive heat buildup and property degradation.

Study Insights and Implications for Production

The practical value of this study lies in its confirmation that both preheating temperature and welding current are critical factors in determining the microstructure and properties of surfacing layers on die steels. The key insight is that preheating can be used to achieve a better combination of strength and toughness, while excessive welding current should be avoided to prevent grain growth and property degradation.

For production applications, I would recommend the following approach:

  1. Determine the optimal preheating temperature based on the size and complexity of the repair.
  2. Select the welding current based on the desired deposition rate and the need to avoid grain growth.
  3. Use numerical simulation to predict the temperature field and optimize the welding parameters.
  4. Verify the properties of the surfacing layer through hardness testing and metallographic examination.

Reference Value and Outlook

This study provides a solid foundation for understanding the effects of preheating temperature and welding current on the microstructure and properties of surfacing layers on die steels. The findings are directly applicable to die repair and hardfacing operations in the steel pipe and fitting industry.

Looking ahead, further research is needed to establish quantitative relationships between preheating temperature, welding current, and the mechanical properties of surfacing layers. The industry would also benefit from studies examining the effects of post-weld heat treatment on the microstructure and properties of surfacing layers on die steels.

In conclusion, this study offers practical guidance for anyone involved in die repair and hardfacing operations. The key takeaway is that preheating temperature and welding current must be carefully controlled to achieve the optimal combination of strength and toughness in the surfacing layer. Excessive welding current should be avoided, and preheating should be used to control the cooling rate and achieve a balanced microstructure.