Preheat Temperature Effects on Stellite 6 Hardfacing of 5CrNiMo Die Steel
The Role of Preheat in Hardfacing Die Steels
This 2020 study from China National Erzhong Group and Hunan University addresses a question that every hardfacing engineer has to answer at some point: what preheat temperature should I use? The specific case is the plasma arc welding (PAW) of Stellite 6 alloy onto a 5CrNiMo hot work die steel. This is a classic application — die steels are expensive, and hardfacing them with a cobalt-based alloy like Stellite 6 extends their service life significantly.
The authors, Zhang Peng and colleagues, systematically investigated the effect of preheat temperature on the microstructure and hardness of the Stellite 6 coating and the heat-affected zone (HAZ). This is exactly the kind of parametric study that the shop floor needs. Too often, preheat temperatures are selected based on habit or a general rule of thumb, without understanding the specific metallurgical consequences.
Microstructural Evolution with Preheat Temperature
The paper's findings are clear and directly applicable. The Stellite 6 coating consists of dendritic cobalt solid solution with a eutectic of Co-Cr and carbides in the interdendritic regions. This is the typical microstructure of a cobalt-based hardfacing alloy. The key finding is that increasing the preheat temperature slows the cooling rate, which allows the dendrites to grow larger. At a preheat temperature of 300°C, the carbide distribution is the most uniform, and the columnar grains are the smallest. This is the optimum preheat temperature for this application.
The effect on the HAZ is equally important. The base metal, 5CrNiMo, is a hot work die steel with a high hardenability. When the HAZ cools, it transforms to martensite, which is hard and brittle. The paper found that as the preheat temperature increases, the amount of needle-like martensite in the HAZ decreases, and the martensite becomes finer. This is because the slower cooling rate allows more time for carbon to diffuse and for the transformation to occur at a higher temperature, resulting in a less severe martensitic structure.
The hardness of the HAZ is directly related to the amount of martensite. The paper found that at a preheat temperature of 300°C, the HAZ hardness is the most uniform. This is critical because a non-uniform hardness distribution in the HAZ can lead to stress concentrations and cracking in service. A die steel that has a hard, brittle HAZ will fail by thermal fatigue or cracking during the first few thousand cycles.
Practical Recommendations for the Shop Floor
From my perspective, this paper provides a clear process window for hardfacing 5CrNiMo die steel with Stellite 6. A preheat temperature of 300°C is the sweet spot. Below this, you risk excessive martensite in the HAZ and cracking. Above this, you risk grain growth in the Stellite 6 coating and a loss of wear resistance.
The paper also highlights the importance of controlling the cooling rate after welding. Even with a preheat of 300°C, if the component is allowed to cool rapidly after welding, the HAZ will still transform to martensite. A post-weld heat treatment, such as tempering, may be necessary to relieve residual stresses and reduce the hardness of the HAZ. In my experience with die steel hardfacing, a post-weld temper at 500-600°C for several hours is often required to achieve the desired combination of hardness and toughness.
The use of plasma arc welding is also significant. PAW provides a high energy density and a stable arc, which allows for precise control of the heat input and dilution. This is particularly important for Stellite 6, which is sensitive to dilution with the base metal. If the dilution is too high, the cobalt-based alloy becomes enriched with iron, which reduces its hot hardness and wear resistance. The paper's results are a reminder that the process parameters, including preheat, must be optimized together to achieve the desired microstructure and properties.
For any engineer involved in the repair or hardfacing of die steels, this paper is a valuable reference that provides a clear, quantitative basis for selecting preheat temperatures. It is the kind of study that should be on the desk of every welding engineer who works with hot work tool steels.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd