Automatic Surfacing of Duplex Stainless Steel 2205 on Tube Sheets: Process Qualification and Production Experience
1. Literature Overview and Why Duplex Is Different
This paper from Welding Technology (2010, Vol. 39, No. 2) describes the development of a surfacing process for duplex stainless steel 2205 on large-diameter 16Mn forged tube sheets. The authors used a two-layer approach: a transition layer of D309MoL deposited by submerged arc welding (SAW) with strip cladding, followed by a corrosion-resistant layer of ER2209 deposited by MIG welding. The process was qualified through mechanical testing and corrosion testing.
Duplex stainless steel is a special animal. It has a two-phase microstructure of approximately 50% ferrite and 50% austenite. This structure gives it excellent corrosion resistance and high strength, but it also makes it sensitive to welding thermal cycles. If the ferrite-austenite balance is disturbed, the material can become susceptible to sigma phase precipitation, 475°C embrittlement, or nitrogen loss. The welding process must be carefully controlled to maintain the correct phase balance.
2. The Two-Layer Approach: Why It Is Necessary
The authors used a transition layer of D309MoL before depositing the ER2209 layer. This is a standard practice in cladding of carbon steel with stainless steel. The transition layer serves two purposes:
- It provides a metallurgical bond between the carbon steel substrate and the stainless steel overlay. Without it, the carbon from the substrate would migrate into the stainless steel, causing chromium carbide precipitation and loss of corrosion resistance.
- It accommodates the difference in thermal expansion between the carbon steel and the stainless steel. The transition layer has a coefficient of thermal expansion that is intermediate between the two, reducing the thermal stress at the interface.
The D309MoL wire is a 23Cr-13Ni-2Mo alloy, which is designed to provide a fully austenitic or austenitic-ferritic structure with good resistance to dilution from the carbon steel substrate. The "L" designation indicates low carbon content, which is important for preventing sensitization.
3. Qualification Testing and Results
The authors performed a comprehensive qualification program, including mechanical testing and corrosion testing. The key results are summarized below:
| Test | Requirement | Result | Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength | Per standard | Met | Satisfactory |
| Impact toughness | Per standard | Met | Satisfactory |
| Bend test | No cracks | No cracks | Satisfactory |
| Intergranular corrosion | Per standard | Passed | Satisfactory |
| Ferrite content | 30-70% | Within range | Satisfactory |
| Hardness | Per standard | Met | Satisfactory |
The fact that the process met all requirements is a testament to the careful selection of welding parameters and the two-layer approach. The ferrite content is particularly important. For duplex stainless steel, the ferrite content should be in the range of 30-70% to ensure the correct balance of corrosion resistance and mechanical properties. If the ferrite content is too low, the material becomes susceptible to stress corrosion cracking. If it is too high, the toughness decreases.
4. Production Implementation Considerations
For a production environment, the key challenges in duplex stainless steel surfacing are:
- Heat input control: The heat input must be within a specific range to maintain the correct ferrite-austenite balance. Too low a heat input results in excessive ferrite; too high a heat input results in excessive austenite and possible sigma phase precipitation.
- Interpass temperature control: The interpass temperature must be limited to prevent excessive grain growth and sigma phase precipitation. A maximum interpass temperature of 150°C is commonly specified.
- Shielding gas: The shielding gas must be appropriate for duplex stainless steel. A gas mixture with nitrogen is often used to compensate for nitrogen loss during welding.
- Cleaning between passes: The surface must be clean and free of contamination between passes. Iron contamination can cause localized corrosion.
The authors used SAW with strip cladding for the transition layer and MIG for the corrosion-resistant layer. This combination is common in tube sheet cladding because SAW provides high deposition rates and good penetration, while MIG provides better control of the weld bead shape and composition.
5. Critical Assessment and Study Insights
This paper is a good example of process qualification for a demanding application. The authors have demonstrated that duplex stainless steel 2205 can be successfully surfaced on carbon steel using a two-layer approach. However, I would note the following:
- The paper does not report the actual welding parameters used. This makes it difficult to replicate the process without additional testing.
- The corrosion testing appears to be limited to intergranular corrosion. For duplex stainless steel, pitting corrosion and stress corrosion cracking are also important considerations.
- The paper does not discuss the effect of post-weld heat treatment. In some applications, the tube sheet may need to be stress-relieved, which could affect the microstructure of the duplex layer.
6. Reference Value and Outlook
This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in cladding of carbon steel components with duplex stainless steel. The two-layer approach is well-established, and the qualification results confirm its viability.
For the practicing engineer, the key takeaway is that duplex stainless steel surfacing requires careful attention to the phase balance. The ferrite content must be measured and controlled, and the welding parameters must be selected to maintain the correct balance. The two-layer approach with a transition layer is essential for achieving a sound metallurgical bond and preventing carbon migration.
My advice: if you are planning to surface a component with duplex stainless steel, start with the approach described in this paper. Use a transition layer of D309MoL and a corrosion-resistant layer of ER2209. Qualify the process with the same tests described in the paper, and add pitting corrosion testing if the application requires it. And remember: the ferrite content is the single most important parameter to monitor.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd