Quality Control of Hardfacing for Wear-Resistant Parts in Cement Equipment
Background: Why This Paper Still Matters
I have spent thirty years watching wear parts fail in cement plants, crushers, and mills, and I can tell you that the problem is rarely the design of the part. It is almost always the quality of the hardfacing that was applied to it. The paper by Zhang Liguo and Zhong Libin addresses a gap that I have seen on every site I have walked: suppliers know how to deposit hardfacing, but neither they nor the user's inspectors know how to control its quality in a systematic way. The authors make a simple but powerful argument: most users judge a wear part only by its final service life, which is a reactive measure, and they do not know how to implement quality control during the hardfacing process itself. This is a classic case of "inspect the result, not the process," and it leads to expensive failures that could have been prevented.
The paper's core contribution is to identify four specific control points that both the supplier and the user's supervisory team must verify during manufacture. These are not abstract laboratory measurements; they are practical, shop-floor checks that can be performed with standard equipment. Let me break them down as I would in a pre-production meeting with a fabricator.
The Four Control Points Explained
The authors argue that hardfacing quality must be assessed through four interrelated checks. I have reproduced them in the table below, along with my own commentary on how I would apply them in practice.
| Control Point | What It Measures | Why It Matters | Practical Assessment Method |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hardness range determination | The intended hardness of the deposited layer before production begins | Establishes the acceptance band for the entire batch, preventing "hard but brittle" or "soft but fast-wearing" deposits | Reference hardness blocks, calibrated portable hardness testers (Leeb or Rockwell) on a sample coupon |
| Working surface hardness inspection | Hardness at the actual service surface of the finished part | The surface is what contacts the abrasive material; a soft surface will fail prematurely even if the core is hard | Direct reading on the finished surface at multiple locations, typically 5 to 10 points per square meter |
| Overall working surface hardness assessment | Statistical distribution of hardness across the entire surface | Averages can hide local soft spots that become preferential wear paths and early failure | Map hardness readings on a grid; calculate mean, standard deviation, and identify any points below the minimum acceptable value |
| Crack distribution uniformity on the hardfacing surface | The pattern and density of surface cracks in the deposit | Hardfacing alloys are designed to crack in a controlled manner to relieve residual stress; uncontrolled cracking or crack-free surfaces can indicate wrong preheat, wrong alloy, or excessive dilution | Visual inspection with dye penetrant (PT) on a sample area; classify cracks as uniform, clustered, or absent |
The insight that I find most valuable in this paper is the emphasis on crack distribution uniformity. In my experience, many inspectors see any crack in a hardfacing deposit and immediately reject the part. This is a fundamental misunderstanding of the metallurgy. High-chromium cast iron and other hardfacing alloys are intentionally formulated to crack in a controlled, uniform pattern. The cracks relieve the high tensile residual stress that would otherwise cause spalling or delamination. The problem is not the presence of cracks but the lack of uniformity. If cracks are clustered in one area or absent entirely in another, the residual stress distribution is uneven, and the part will fail prematurely.
Shop Floor Reality: What Goes Wrong
I have seen the following failure modes on real cement equipment, and each one traces back to a gap in the four control points described above.
- Incorrect hardness range specification. A supplier once delivered a set of crusher hammers with a nominal hardness of 58 HRC, but the actual deposit varied from 45 to 62 HRC across the surface. The soft zones wore away within weeks, creating a scalloped surface that accelerated abrasive wear on the remaining hard zones. The user had specified only a single target value, not a range, so the supplier had no acceptance band to work against.
- Surface hardness testing at the wrong location. An inspector tested the hardness of a wear plate only at the edges, where the deposit had been ground flush. The center of the plate, which was the actual contact zone, was never tested. When the plate failed, we found the center hardness was 12 HRC lower than the edges. The inspection plan must specify the test grid, not just the number of readings.
- Crack pattern misinterpretation. A fabricator applied a hardfacing alloy that was designed to crack in a fine, uniform network. The actual deposit showed long, continuous cracks running the full length of the part. The fabricator argued that "cracks are normal in hardfacing." They are normal, but not in that pattern. The long cracks were caused by excessive heat input and insufficient preheat, and they propagated through the deposit into the base metal, causing catastrophic failure.
A Practical QC Protocol for Suppliers and Users
Based on the paper's framework and my own experience, I would recommend the following protocol for any cement equipment hardfacing procurement. This is the kind of document I would put in front of a fabricator before they weld a single bead.
| Stage | Action | Responsibility | Acceptance Criteria |
|---|---|---|---|
| Before production | Establish the target hardness range from the alloy datasheet or a qualification coupon | Supplier and user jointly | Hardness range must be agreed and documented before any production parts are hardfaced |
| First article inspection | Deposit a coupon with the same parameters as production; test hardness at 10 points and check crack pattern | User's inspector | Hardness within the agreed range; crack pattern uniform and consistent with the alloy type |
| During production | Random surface hardness checks at a minimum of 5 points per part; dye penetrant on 10% of parts | Supplier's QC and user's inspector | No reading below the minimum acceptable value; no clustered or absent cracks |
| Pre-dispatch | Full surface hardness map on 100% of critical parts; visual and PT inspection on all parts | User's inspector or third-party | All readings within the agreed range; crack distribution uniform across the entire surface |
I want to emphasize one point that the paper makes implicitly but that I have learned the hard way: the supplier and the user must agree on the acceptance criteria before production starts, not after the parts are delivered. In one project, we had a dispute over whether a hardness of 54 HRC was acceptable when the specification said "minimum 55 HRC." The supplier argued that the test method had a tolerance of ±2 HRC, so 54 was within tolerance. The user argued that the specification was absolute. We resolved it by requiring a second test at a different location, which read 56 HRC, but the delay cost us two weeks. If we had agreed on the test method and the tolerance band upfront, we would have avoided the dispute entirely.
Lessons and Reflections
The paper by Zhang and Zhong is short, but it addresses a problem that I have seen cause millions of dollars in lost production and equipment damage. The key takeaway for me is that hardfacing quality control is not a matter of "testing the final product." It is a process control problem. The four control points they identify hardness range, surface hardness, overall hardness distribution, and crack uniformity are all process outputs that reflect the quality of the welding procedure, the preheat and interpass temperature control, the alloy selection, and the operator's technique.
If I were to add one thing to their framework, it would be a fifth control point: dilution control. The hardness of a hardfacing deposit is directly influenced by the amount of base metal that melts into the first layer. If the dilution is too high, the deposit becomes lean in alloying elements and the hardness drops. If the dilution is too low, the deposit may not bond properly to the base metal. This is controlled by the welding parameters, particularly the travel speed and the current. I would add a requirement for a dilution check on the first article, typically by measuring the carbon or chromium content of the deposit at a known distance from the fusion line.
The bottom line is that hardfacing quality is a shared responsibility. The supplier must know how to control the process, and the user must know how to verify it. This paper provides a practical starting point for both sides, and I would recommend it to any engineer who is responsible for wear parts in cement, mining, or any other abrasive service. The cost of implementing this quality control is small compared to the cost of a premature failure, and the peace of mind it provides is worth every hour of inspection time.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd