ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Alloying Elements on Water Plasma Arc Hardfaced Iron-Based Layers

Paper Overview and Metallurgical Context

The paper by Li Da and colleagues from Southwest Jiaotong University tackles a question that I have asked myself many times on the shop floor: how do I get the right combination of hardness and toughness in a hardfacing layer without burning through the budget? The authors used an orthogonal experimental design to study the effects of chromium, molybdenum, silicon, and carbon additions on the microstructure, hardness, and wear resistance of iron-based hardfacing layers deposited by water plasma arc welding on Q345 steel. The water plasma arc is an interesting process because it uses a water-stabilized plasma column, which provides a higher energy density than conventional plasma arc welding and allows for efficient powder feeding. This is not a process I have seen used widely in the steel pipe industry, but the metallurgical principles are directly applicable to any hardfacing application.

The key finding is that the hardfacing layer contains a large amount of M7C3 primary carbides embedded in a eutectic matrix, and the maximum hardness reached 56.8 HRC. The authors identified chromium and carbon as the elements with the greatest influence on wear resistance. This is consistent with my experience in high-chromium cast iron hardfacing alloys, where the M7C3 carbides provide the primary wear resistance and the matrix provides the toughness to hold them in place.

Element-by-Element Analysis

Let me break down the role of each element as the paper presents it, and then add my own commentary based on what I have seen in production hardfacing.

Element Primary Role in the Hardfacing Layer Effect on Microstructure Practical Observation
Chromium (Cr) Promotes the formation of M7C3 primary carbides Increases the volume fraction of hard carbides; raises the hardness and wear resistance Too much chromium can cause excessive carbide coarsening and embrittlement; typical range is 15-25%
Molybdenum (Mo) Strengthens the matrix and improves high-temperature hardness Refines the eutectic structure; increases the hardness of the matrix Molybdenum is expensive; the benefit must be weighed against the cost increase
Silicon (Si) Deoxidizer and improves the fluidity of the weld pool Promotes the formation of a finer eutectic structure Too much silicon can cause the formation of brittle silicides, which reduce toughness
Carbon (C) Determines the amount and type of carbides formed Increases the volume fraction of M7C3 carbides; increases hardness but reduces toughness The carbon content must be balanced against the chromium content to achieve the desired carbide-to-matrix ratio

The orthogonal experimental design is a smart approach for this kind of study. It allows the authors to evaluate the effect of each element with a relatively small number of experiments, which is exactly what you want when you are trying to develop a new alloy composition without spending a fortune on trial and error. I have used similar approaches in my own work to optimize welding parameters for line pipe, and I can confirm that the method is sound.

Process Window and Practical Implications

The authors used a water plasma flame machine to deposit the powder onto Q345 steel plates. This process is interesting because it combines the high energy density of a plasma arc with the ability to feed alloy powder directly into the arc. The result is a deposit with low dilution and high deposition efficiency, which is exactly what you want for hardfacing applications.

From a practical standpoint, there are three key process parameters that I would focus on if I were running this process in production:

  1. Plasma gas flow rate. This controls the energy density of the arc and the amount of powder that is melted. Too low a flow rate and the powder does not fully melt, leading to porosity and lack of fusion. Too high a flow rate and the arc becomes unstable, causing spatter and an uneven deposit.
  2. Powder feed rate. This controls the deposition rate and the thickness of the layer. The feed rate must be matched to the travel speed to achieve a consistent layer thickness. If the feed rate is too high, the powder does not fully melt and the deposit contains unmelted particles.
  3. Travel speed. This controls the heat input per unit length and the cooling rate of the deposit. A faster travel speed produces a finer microstructure and higher hardness, but it also increases the risk of lack of fusion. A slower travel speed produces a coarser microstructure and lower hardness, but it improves the bond quality.

The paper reports a maximum hardness of 56.8 HRC, which is in the range I would expect for a high-chromium iron-based hardfacing alloy. For cement equipment, I would typically look for a hardness in the range of 55 to 60 HRC for the deposit, with a minimum of 50 HRC at the interface to ensure good bonding.

Comparison with Conventional Hardfacing Processes

The water plasma arc process offers several advantages over conventional hardfacing methods, but it also has some limitations that I want to highlight.

Process Advantages Limitations Typical Hardness Range
Water plasma arc powder hardfacing Low dilution, high deposition efficiency, fine microstructure, good control of alloy composition Requires specialized equipment; not widely available; higher capital cost 50-60 HRC
Conventional plasma transferred arc (PTA) hardfacing Well-established process, good control of dilution, widely available Higher dilution than water plasma arc; coarser microstructure 45-58 HRC
Submerged arc hardfacing High deposition rate, good penetration, low cost High dilution; limited to flat positions; coarser microstructure 35-50 HRC
Flux-cored arc hardfacing Versatile, can be used in all positions, good for field repairs Higher dilution; requires shielding gas or self-shielded wire 40-58 HRC

The main advantage of the water plasma arc process is the combination of low dilution and high hardness. In conventional PTA hardfacing, the dilution is typically 5-10%, which means that the first layer of the deposit is contaminated with base metal. This reduces the hardness of the first layer and can cause cracking if the base metal has a different coefficient of thermal expansion. The water plasma arc process can achieve dilution as low as 2-3%, which means that even the first layer has the full hardness of the alloy.

Reflections on the Paper and Its Relevance

This paper is a useful contribution to the hardfacing literature because it provides a systematic study of the effect of alloying elements on the properties of a water plasma arc hardfaced iron-based layer. The authors clearly demonstrate that chromium and carbon are the dominant elements controlling wear resistance, which is consistent with the well-established metallurgy of high-chromium cast iron alloys.

From my perspective as a production engineer, the most valuable takeaway is the confirmation that the water plasma arc process can produce hardfacing layers with hardness and wear resistance comparable to or better than conventional processes. This opens up the possibility of using water plasma arc hardfacing for applications where conventional processes are not suitable, such as thin-walled components or parts that require a very low dilution.

However, I would caution against adopting this process without a thorough qualification program. The water plasma arc process is sensitive to variations in powder feed rate and plasma gas flow rate, and it requires a high level of operator skill. I have seen too many projects where a new process was adopted based on promising laboratory results, only to fail in production because the operators did not have the training to control the process consistently. If you are considering this process, I would recommend starting with a small pilot program, qualifying the process on representative parts, and training the operators thoroughly before committing to full production.

The orthogonal experimental design used in this paper is a good example of how to develop a new alloy composition efficiently. I would recommend this approach to any engineer who is tasked with developing a new hardfacing alloy, because it allows you to identify the key variables and their interactions with a minimum number of experiments. The cost of the experiments is small compared to the cost of a failed production run.