ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Tempering Temperature Effects on Microstructure and Wear Resistance of Fe-Based Multi-Alloy Hardfacing Layers

Literature Overview and Core Findings

The paper by Li Xiaojuan and Guo Zhimin from Hebei Vocational College of Building Materials investigates the influence of tempering temperature on the microstructure and wear resistance of an iron-based multi-alloy hardfacing layer. The work is straightforward in design but touches on a question that has cost many plants real money: what happens to a hardfaced component after it goes through post-weld heat treatment or when it sees service temperatures above 400°C. The authors report three key findings. First, the hardfacing layer exhibits secondary hardening after tempering. Second, hardness remains relatively stable below 400°C but drops significantly once tempering exceeds 600°C. Third, tempering at 560°C for 2 hours yields excellent wear resistance, with a good correspondence between microstructure and wear performance.

I have seen this behaviour in the field more times than I can count, and it is worth unpacking what it means for the shop floor rather than just reading the numbers off a chart.

Interpretation of Technical Points

Secondary Hardening and Its Metallurgical Origin

Secondary hardening in an iron-based multi-alloy hardfacing layer is not a coincidence; it is a deliberate metallurgical design feature. When the hardfacing alloy contains strong carbide-forming elements such as molybdenum, vanadium, tungsten, or chromium, tempering in the range of 500 to 600°C promotes the precipitation of fine, coherent alloy carbides from the supersaturated martensite matrix. These carbides, typically of the M2C or MC type, are small enough to resist coarsening and hard enough to compensate for the softening of the tempered martensite itself. The net effect is a hardness peak or at least a plateau in the tempering curve.

What matters practically is that this behaviour is not universal. The exact tempering temperature for peak secondary hardening depends on the alloy system. In this study, 560°C appears to be the sweet spot, but I have seen other iron-based systems peak at 520°C or even 600°C. If you are qualifying a hardfacing procedure for a component that will see elevated service temperature, you must know where your alloy peaks, because running at the wrong side of the curve means either under-tempering (residual stress, cracking risk) or over-tempering (softening, rapid wear).

The 400°C Threshold and the 600°C Drop-Off

The finding that hardness is relatively unchanged below 400°C is important for a different reason. Many hardfaced components are not tempered at all; they are used in the as-welded condition or see only low-temperature stress relief. The data suggest that if your service temperature stays below 400°C, you have a wide safety margin. However, the sharp hardness drop above 600°C is a red flag. This is the temperature range where the fine secondary carbides begin to coarsen rapidly, and the martensite matrix over-tempers into a soft ferrite-carbide aggregate. The result is a dramatic loss of hardness and, consequently, wear resistance.

I recall a case involving a large dredge pump casing that was hardfaced with a high-chromium iron alloy. The client specified a post-weld heat treatment at 650°C to relieve welding residual stress before machining. The hardfacing went from 58 HRC to 34 HRC in a single heat treatment cycle. The component was scrapped. The lesson is simple: never specify a PWHT temperature without checking the hardfacing alloy's tempering response first.

Microstructure-Wear Resistance Correspondence

The authors note a good correspondence between microstructure and wear resistance. In practice, this means that the wear resistance is not merely a function of bulk hardness; it is governed by the type, size, and distribution of hard phases within a relatively tough matrix. At 560°C tempering, the microstructure likely consists of tempered martensite with a dense dispersion of fine alloy carbides, which provides an optimal combination of hardness and toughness. Under abrasive wear conditions, the hard carbides resist cutting and ploughing, while the matrix holds them in place and prevents pull-out.

If the tempering temperature is too low, the matrix is brittle and carbides are not fully precipitated, leading to chipping and spalling. If too high, the carbides coarsen and the matrix softens, allowing deep abrasive grooves and rapid material loss. This is why a single hardness measurement is never sufficient for qualifying a hardfacing layer for wear service; you need to look at the microstructure.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Process Window Definition for Hardfacing Operations

For a production environment, the practical takeaway from this study is the need to define a process window for tempering, not just a single temperature. Based on the data, a reasonable window for this alloy system would be 540 to 580°C, with a hold time of 1.5 to 2.5 hours. Outside this window, you risk either insufficient secondary hardening or over-tempering. The following table summarizes the recommended parameters based on the study findings and my own field experience:

Tempering Temperature Hold Time Expected Hardness Trend Microstructural State Recommended Use
Below 400°C 1-2 h Stable, near as-welded Untempered or lightly tempered martensite Low-temperature service, stress relief only
500-580°C 1.5-2.5 h Peak or near-peak (secondary hardening) Tempered martensite with fine alloy carbides Wear-resistant applications, optimal combination
Above 600°C Any Significant drop Over-tempered martensite, coarsened carbides Not recommended for wear service

Common Defects and Countermeasures

When tempering hardfaced components in the shop, I have observed several recurring problems. The first is uneven hardness across the layer, which usually results from inconsistent furnace temperature uniformity or from stacking components too densely. The second is temper embrittlement, which can occur if the alloy contains phosphorus or tin and is tempered in the range of 350 to 500°C. The third is distortion, particularly on thin-walled or asymmetric components, because the hardfacing layer and the base metal have different coefficients of thermal expansion.

The countermeasures are straightforward but are often ignored in the rush to meet delivery dates. Ensure the furnace is calibrated and surveyed to at least ±10°C across the working zone. Use thermocouples attached to the actual component, not just the furnace atmosphere. Avoid tempering in the 350-500°C range if the alloy is susceptible to temper embrittlement; either go below 300°C or jump to above 550°C. For distortion control, support the component properly, use slow heating and cooling rates, and consider a stress-relief cycle before final machining.

Case Study: Hardfaced Roll for a Steel Mill

I once dealt with a claim involving a pair of hardfaced rolls used in a continuous casting machine. The rolls were hardfaced with an iron-based alloy similar to the one in this study, then tempered at 560°C for 2 hours. The rolls performed well for six months, far exceeding the previous life of three months. However, the second batch of rolls, produced with the same procedure, failed after only two weeks. The difference was traced to the tempering furnace. The first batch had been tempered in a small, well-calibrated batch furnace. The second batch had been tempered in a large car-bottom furnace that had not been surveyed for two years. The temperature variation across the load was over 80°C, meaning some rolls saw 520°C and others saw 600°C. The rolls that saw 600°C were severely over-tempered and wore out rapidly. The cost of the claim was far greater than the cost of a furnace survey.

Key Questions and Reflections

The study raises a question that is often overlooked in hardfacing qualification: what is the actual service temperature of the component, and does the hardfacing alloy's tempering response match it? Too often, a hardfacing alloy is selected solely on as-welded hardness, with no consideration of the tempering curve. If the component sees 500°C in service, an alloy that peaks at 560°C may be acceptable, but an alloy that peaks at 400°C will be severely over-tempered. Conversely, if the component sees only ambient temperature, the secondary hardening effect is irrelevant, and you might as well use a simpler, cheaper alloy.

Another question concerns the test methodology. The study uses a single tempering time of 2 hours. In production, tempering times can vary from 30 minutes for small components to 8 hours or more for large, heavy-section parts. The tempering parameter, which combines time and temperature, is the more useful metric. If the study had used the Hollomon-Jaffe parameter, the results would be more directly transferable to production conditions. This is a gap in the literature that I would like to see addressed.

Study Insights and Implications

The practical value of this study lies in its clear demonstration that tempering temperature is not a secondary consideration for hardfaced components; it is a primary process parameter that determines whether the component will perform or fail. The finding of secondary hardening at 560°C is particularly valuable because it provides a window where both hardness and toughness can be optimized. This is exactly the kind of data that should be incorporated into welding procedure specifications for hardfacing, alongside the more commonly specified preheat and interpass temperatures.

For the shop floor, the key insight is that you cannot treat a hardfaced component like a simple carbon steel part. The hardfacing alloy has its own heat treatment response, and it may be completely different from the base metal. If you specify a PWHT for the base metal, you must verify that it does not damage the hardfacing layer. If you do not specify a PWHT, you must accept the residual stress and the risk of cracking. There is no free lunch in hardfacing, and this study helps quantify one side of that trade-off.

Concluding Summary

Tempering is not an optional step in hardfacing; it is a critical process control point that determines the final microstructure, hardness, and wear resistance of the layer. This study provides valuable data showing that an iron-based multi-alloy hardfacing layer exhibits secondary hardening, with optimal wear resistance at 560°C for 2 hours, and that hardness degrades significantly above 600°C. The practical implication is that hardfacing procedure specifications must include a defined tempering window, and that any post-weld heat treatment must be validated against the hardfacing alloy's tempering response. In my experience, many hardfacing failures are not due to poor welding but to incorrect heat treatment. The solution is not more complex alloys; it is more rigorous process control and a better understanding of the metallurgy behind the numbers. This paper is a useful reminder that the simplest questions, like what temperature to temper at, can have the most expensive consequences when ignored.