ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of External Longitudinal Magnetic Field Current on Microstructure and Wear Resistance of Plasma Arc Surfaced Ceramic-Reinforced Iron-Based Alloys

Literature Overview and Context

This paper by Zong Lin and Liu Zhengjun from Shenyang University of Chemical Technology and Shenyang University of Technology investigates the effect of an external longitudinal magnetic field on the microstructure and wear resistance of plasma arc surfaced ceramic-reinforced iron-based alloys on 20G carbon steel. The work is a sophisticated example of process-structure-property optimization, where the magnetic field is used as an active control parameter during the surfacing process to influence grain refinement and carbide distribution.

The application of magnetic fields during arc welding and surfacing is a well-established research area, but its practical implementation in industrial hardfacing remains relatively limited. This paper provides valuable data on the optimal magnetic field current and the underlying mechanisms, which is directly relevant to anyone seeking to improve the performance of hardfaced components in the steel pipe and fitting industry.

Experimental Setup and Findings

The experimental approach involved applying a longitudinal magnetic field during plasma arc surfacing of a ceramic-reinforced iron-based alloy onto 20G carbon steel. The magnetic field current was varied systematically, and the resulting microstructure, hardness, and wear resistance of the surfacing layer were evaluated.

Magnetic Field Current (A) Microstructure Hardness Wear Resistance
0 (baseline) Coarse grains, less uniform carbide distribution Lower Lower
2.0 Fine grains, hexagonal M7C3 carbides, uniform distribution Highest Best
>2.0 Grain coarsening, electromagnetic damping dominates Decreasing Decreasing

The results show a clear optimum at a magnetic field current of 2.0 A. At this level, the surfacing layer exhibits the finest grain size, the highest and most uniform distribution of hexagonal M7C3 ceramic hard phases, and the best combination of hardness and wear resistance. Beyond 2.0 A, the performance deteriorates due to electromagnetic damping effects.

Mechanism Analysis and Interpretation

The beneficial effect of the magnetic field at low currents is attributed to electromagnetic stirring of the molten pool. The Lorentz force generated by the interaction between the welding current and the external magnetic field induces convection in the molten pool, which promotes grain refinement by breaking up growing dendrites and distributing them more uniformly. This results in a finer, more homogeneous microstructure with a more even distribution of hard carbide phases.

The mechanism for the decline at higher currents is electromagnetic damping. When the magnetic field current exceeds a certain threshold, the Lorentz force becomes strong enough to suppress natural convection in the molten pool. This reduces the stirring effect, leading to a coarser grain structure and a less uniform distribution of carbides. The transition from beneficial stirring to detrimental damping occurs at approximately 2.0 A in this experimental setup.

Mechanism Effect at Low Current Effect at High Current
Lorentz force Promotes convection, grain refinement Suppresses convection, electromagnetic damping
Molten pool stirring Enhanced, uniform carbide distribution Reduced, coarser grains
Resulting properties Higher hardness, better wear resistance Lower hardness, reduced wear resistance

Practical Engineering Insights and Lessons

The application of a magnetic field during plasma arc surfacing is a technique that can deliver significant improvements in deposit quality, but it requires careful process control. The optimal magnetic field current is not a universal value; it depends on the welding current, the geometry of the workpiece, the composition of the surfacing alloy, and the specific plasma torch configuration. A magnetic field current that is optimal for one set of conditions may be detrimental for another.

In the steel pipe industry, plasma arc surfacing is used for applications such as hardfacing of valve seats, pump components, and other wear-resistant surfaces. The ability to refine the grain structure and improve carbide distribution through magnetic field control offers a route to enhanced performance without changing the alloy composition. This is particularly valuable when the alloy selection is constrained by other requirements, such as corrosion resistance or weldability.

However, the practical implementation of magnetic field-assisted surfacing in a production environment is not trivial. The magnetic field must be generated by coils positioned around the workpiece, which adds complexity to the welding station. The field must be uniform and consistent, which requires careful coil design and positioning. The interaction between the magnetic field and the welding arc can also affect arc stability, requiring adjustments to the welding parameters.

From a quality control perspective, the use of a magnetic field adds another variable to the process. If the magnetic field current is not controlled accurately, the resulting deposit quality may be inconsistent. This requires robust process monitoring and control systems, which may not be available in all production environments.

Concluding Summary

The application of an external longitudinal magnetic field during plasma arc surfacing of ceramic-reinforced iron-based alloys on 20G carbon steel produces a clear optimum in microstructure and properties at a magnetic field current of 2.0 A. At this level, electromagnetic stirring promotes grain refinement and uniform distribution of hexagonal M7C3 carbides, resulting in the highest hardness and best wear resistance. Beyond 2.0 A, electromagnetic damping dominates, leading to grain coarsening and reduced performance. The technique offers a viable route to improving hardfacing quality without changing alloy composition, but it requires careful process control and robust equipment design. For the steel pipe and fitting industry, magnetic field-assisted plasma arc surfacing represents a promising approach for enhancing the performance of wear-resistant components, provided the practical challenges of implementation are addressed.