Control of Flatness in Hardfaced Tube Sheets
Literature Overview and Core Findings
The paper by Lü Yanmao from the Chemical Machinery Plant of Sinopec Nanjing Chemical Industries Co., Ltd. addresses the practical problem of controlling the flatness of hardfaced tube sheets. The factors affecting tube sheet distortion during hardfacing include the tube sheet material, geometry, welding materials and welding process. The paper categorises the hardfacing patterns into two main types and uses engineering calculation methods to predict the distortion for each type, which is presented as an effective measure for controlling the final flatness. The paper emphasises that the flatness of the tube sheet after assembly with the shell is the final flatness that must be ensured.
Technical Interpretation and Engineering Analysis
This is a practical engineering paper that addresses a problem I have dealt with many times in the fabrication of heat exchangers and pressure vessels. Tube sheets are typically large, relatively thin circular plates with numerous holes for the tubes. When a corrosion-resistant alloy is hardfaced onto the tube sheet face, the heat input from the welding process causes non-uniform expansion and contraction, leading to distortion. The distortion is a function of the welding pattern, the heat input, the thickness and diameter of the tube sheet, and the restraint conditions. The paper classifies the hardfacing patterns into two categories, which likely correspond to the direction of the welding passes, such as radial versus circumferential, or parallel versus spiral. The engineering calculation method described in the paper is a simplified approach to estimating the distortion, which is useful for pre-planning the welding sequence and for determining whether post-weld machining will be sufficient to correct the flatness. The key point is that the flatness after hardfacing and after assembly with the shell must be within the specified tolerance, which is typically a few tenths of a millimetre for a large tube sheet.
Engineering Practice and Delivery Considerations
In my experience, the control of tube sheet flatness is a critical quality issue. If the flatness is out of tolerance, the tube-to-tube sheet joint may not seal properly, leading to leaks and potential failure of the heat exchanger. The problem is exacerbated by the fact that the tube sheet is often hardfaced on one side only, which creates a differential expansion between the hardfaced face and the non-hardfaced face. The welding pattern is crucial. A common practice is to use a back-step or skip welding sequence to distribute the heat input evenly and minimise distortion. The paper's classification of welding patterns into two types is a useful simplification, but in practice, the welding sequence is often more complex, involving multiple passes and a combination of patterns. The engineering calculation method described in the paper is likely based on a simplified model, such as the plate bending theory or a finite element analysis. However, the accuracy of such calculations depends on the accuracy of the input parameters, such as the heat input, the thermal properties of the material, and the restraint conditions. In practice, we often rely on experience and empirical data rather than purely theoretical calculations. The paper's contribution is to provide a systematic approach to this problem, which is valuable for engineers who are less experienced in this area.
Key Questions and Reflections
One question that arises is the effect of the tube sheet material on the distortion. The paper mentions that the tube sheet material is a factor, but it does not elaborate on the specific materials. In practice, tube sheets are made of various materials, including carbon steel, low-alloy steel, stainless steel, and even nickel alloys. The thermal expansion coefficient and the thermal conductivity of the material will affect the distortion. For example, austenitic stainless steel has a higher thermal expansion coefficient and lower thermal conductivity than carbon steel, which makes it more prone to distortion. Another reflection is on the welding process itself. The paper does not specify the welding process, but hardfacing of tube sheets is typically done by submerged arc welding, gas tungsten arc welding, or plasma arc welding. Each process has a different heat input and deposition rate, which will affect the distortion. The choice of welding process must be considered in the context of the tube sheet material and geometry. The paper's focus on engineering calculation is useful, but it is important to remember that the actual distortion may differ from the calculated value due to variations in the welding process and the material properties. Therefore, it is essential to verify the flatness after hardfacing and, if necessary, to correct it by machining or by applying a controlled heat treatment.
Study Insights and Practical Implications
The key insight from this paper is that the control of tube sheet flatness must be planned from the start, not corrected after the fact. The welding pattern and sequence should be designed to minimise distortion, and the expected distortion should be calculated to determine whether the final flatness will be within tolerance. If the calculated distortion is too high, the welding sequence should be modified, or a pre-bending or pre-straining technique should be used to compensate for the expected distortion. In practice, we often use a combination of techniques, including a balanced welding sequence, the use of temporary stiffeners, and post-weld machining. The paper's emphasis on the final flatness after assembly with the shell is also important. The assembly process can introduce additional distortion, so the flatness must be controlled throughout the entire fabrication sequence. In my own experience, I have seen tube sheets that were flat after hardfacing but became distorted after welding to the shell, leading to problems with the tube-to-tube sheet joints. This paper is a good reminder that the flatness requirement is not just a manufacturing issue; it is a functional requirement that affects the performance and safety of the heat exchanger.
Conclusion and Reference Value
This paper is a practical and valuable contribution to the field of heat exchanger fabrication. It addresses a common and challenging problem in a systematic way, providing a framework for predicting and controlling tube sheet distortion during hardfacing. The classification of hardfacing patterns into two types and the use of engineering calculation methods are useful tools for planning the welding sequence and for estimating the expected distortion. The paper's emphasis on the final flatness after assembly is a critical point that is often overlooked. For engineers involved in the fabrication of heat exchangers and pressure vessels, this paper offers a practical guide to managing tube sheet flatness. I would recommend it to anyone who is responsible for the welding and machining of hardfaced tube sheets, and I would encourage them to use the approach described in the paper as a starting point, but to also rely on their own experience and on process qualification tests to validate the welding sequence. The control of distortion is a complex problem, and a combination of theoretical analysis, practical experience and careful process control is the key to success.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd