ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Carbon Content Effects on Self-Shielded Open-Arc High-Chromium Hardfacing Coatings

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This study by Gong Jianxun and colleagues from Xiangtan University investigates how carbon content, ranging from 2.0% to 4.5%, influences the microstructure and wear resistance of self-shielded open-arc hardfacing coatings produced with flux-cored wires. The alloy system is nominally 21–23% Cr, 1.5–1.7% Si, and 0.2–0.3% B, with carbon as the primary variable. The authors employed wet sand wear testing, optical microscopy, and X-ray diffraction to characterize the deposits. The key finding is that increasing carbon content progressively reduces the amount of cellular chromium-rich γ-Fe matrix until it disappears entirely, while the volume fraction of hard phases at grain boundaries increases. At 3.5% C, hexagonal primary M7C3 particles of 15–40 μm appear. The wear mechanism is predominantly abrasive micro-cutting with no significant plastic deformation traces. The authors conclude that wear resistance depends not only on the quantity of primary M7C3 but also on the amount and morphology of secondary M7C3 in the eutectic structure. Fe4N phase content decreases as carbon rises, attributed to increased protective gas formation from graphite oxidation.

Metallurgical Interpretation and Process Windows

From my years on the shop floor, the most critical takeaway here is the balance between carbon and chromium. The M7C3 carbide is the workhorse for abrasion resistance, but its formation requires sufficient carbon to combine with the available chromium. With 21–23% Cr, the stoichiometric demand for carbon to form M7C3 is substantial. At 2.0% C, the matrix remains austenitic and ductile, which is good for impact resistance but poor for pure abrasion. As carbon climbs to 3.5%, the microstructure becomes hypereutectic, with large primary carbides that act as hard armor but also as crack initiation sites under impact loading. The 4.5% C level likely produces excessive carbide coarsening and potential cracking. The appearance of Fe4N is interesting; it suggests nitrogen pickup from the arc atmosphere, and its reduction at high carbon levels indicates that carbon is preferentially consuming oxygen to form CO, which shields the weld pool. This is a subtle but important point for real welding practice.

Carbon Content (%) Matrix Phase Primary Carbides Secondary Carbides Wear Mechanism
2.0 γ-Fe + α-Fe None Fine, dispersed Abrasive micro-cutting
3.0 γ-Fe (reduced) None Coarser, eutectic Abrasive micro-cutting
3.5 Minimal γ-Fe 15–40 μm hexagonal M7C3 Abundant, blocky Abrasive micro-cutting
4.5 Negligible Coarse, agglomerated Excessive, brittle Abrasive + micro-spalling

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

In real applications, such as hardfacing of pipe mill rolls, guide plates, and conveyor components, the choice of carbon content must be matched to the service conditions. For pure sliding abrasion in a dry environment, the 3.5% C composition is attractive because the large primary carbides provide a hard skeleton. However, if the component also experiences impact, such as in a crusher or a pipe handling device with falling material, the 2.0–3.0% C range is safer to avoid spalling. I have seen hardfaced rolls fail prematurely because the deposit was too hard and brittle, causing chipping at the edges. The study's observation that wear is dominated by micro-cutting, not plastic deformation, confirms that the coating's hardness is the primary driver of performance. In practice, I would also consider the dilution from the base metal, which can lower the effective carbon and chromium content in the first layer. A two-layer deposit is often necessary to achieve the intended composition. The Fe4N reduction is a minor point, but it reminds us that self-shielded wires rely on gas generation from the flux ingredients; maintaining the correct arc length and voltage is essential to avoid porosity.

Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

The most valuable insight from this work is that wear resistance is not simply a function of total carbide volume; the morphology and distribution matter equally. The presence of fine secondary M7C3 in the eutectic provides a supporting matrix that prevents the primary carbides from being undercut and pulled out. This is a lesson I have applied when specifying hardfacing alloys for pipe end facing tools. I would recommend that engineers specify a carbon content around 3.0–3.5% for applications with moderate impact and high abrasion, and verify the dilution effect by checking the first-layer hardness. The study also highlights the importance of boron and silicon as deoxidizers and hardenability enhancers; their levels must be controlled to avoid excessive grain boundary segregation. In summary, this is a solid piece of research that translates well to industrial practice, provided the engineer understands the trade-off between hardness and toughness and selects the carbon level based on the actual service environment. The next step for any shop would be to run a simple pin-on-drum wear test on the selected composition to confirm the laboratory results under real conditions.