ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Annealing Temperature Effects on NM360 Wear-Resistant Steel Hardfacing Layers

Literature Overview and Core Findings

Deng Hanzhong and Meng Xiangfeng from Liaoning Technical University investigated the effect of post-weld annealing temperature on the microstructure, hardness, impact toughness, and wear resistance of hardfacing layers deposited on NM360 wear-resistant steel using D507MoNb electrodes. The annealing temperatures were 200°C, 400°C, and 600°C. The results show that the as-welded microstructure is martensite plus carbides. After annealing at 200°C, 400°C, and 600°C, the microstructures become tempered martensite, tempered troostite, and tempered sorbite, respectively. As the annealing temperature increases, the hardness decreases, the impact toughness increases, and the wear resistance decreases. The best wear resistance is obtained after annealing at 200°C, with a relative wear resistance of 1.327 times that of the base metal. This is a classic example of the trade-off between hardness and toughness in hardfacing applications.

Metallurgical Interpretation and Process Windows

NM360 is a low-alloy high-strength steel with a nominal hardness of 360 HB, used in mining equipment, dump truck beds, and chutes. The D507MoNb electrode is a chromium-molybdenum-niobium alloyed electrode designed for wear resistance. The as-welded microstructure is untempered martensite, which is hard but brittle. The purpose of post-weld annealing is to temper the martensite and improve toughness. At 200°C, the tempering is minimal; the martensite is slightly softened, but the hardness remains high, and the carbides are still fine. This gives the best wear resistance because the hard carbides are retained in a relatively hard matrix. At 400°C, the martensite transforms to troostite, which is a fine aggregate of ferrite and cementite. The hardness drops, and the toughness improves, but the wear resistance decreases because the matrix is softer and can be more easily deformed. At 600°C, the microstructure is sorbite, which is a coarser aggregate. The hardness is significantly lower, and the wear resistance is the poorest. The relative wear resistance of 1.327 at 200°C is a significant improvement over the base metal.

Annealing Temperature Microstructure Hardness Impact Toughness Relative Wear Resistance
As-welded Martensite + Carbides High Low Not specified
200°C Tempered Martensite High Moderate 1.327
400°C Tempered Troostite Moderate Good Moderate
600°C Tempered Sorbite Low Excellent Low

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

This study has direct relevance to the repair of worn components in the steel pipe industry, such as guide rolls, conveyor idlers, and transfer tables. The choice of annealing temperature is critical because it determines the final properties of the hardfaced layer. In practice, many shops skip post-weld heat treatment entirely, relying on the as-welded microstructure. This is acceptable if the component is not subjected to impact, but it risks cracking. The 200°C annealing is a low-temperature stress relief that preserves hardness while slightly improving toughness. This is a good compromise for components that experience both abrasion and moderate impact. The 400°C and 600°C treatments are more suitable for components that require higher toughness, such as those subject to severe impact loading. I have seen hardfaced rolls fail by spalling because the deposit was too hard and the substrate was not preheated. The study's use of NM360 as a substrate is interesting because it is already a wear-resistant steel; the hardfacing is intended to extend its life further. The relative wear resistance of 1.327 is a modest improvement, but in a high-volume application, it can translate to significant cost savings.

Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

The key insight is that post-weld heat treatment is a powerful tool for tailoring the properties of hardfacing layers. The 200°C treatment is often overlooked because it seems too low to have any effect, but it effectively relieves residual stresses and tempers the martensite just enough to prevent cracking without sacrificing hardness. I would recommend that engineers specify a 200°C annealing for components that are primarily abrasion-resistant and a 400°C treatment for components that experience impact. The 600°C treatment is rarely used for hardfacing because it destroys the hardness. In practice, the annealing should be performed immediately after welding, before the component cools completely, to avoid hydrogen-induced cracking. The study also highlights the importance of matching the hardfacing alloy to the substrate. D507MoNb is a good choice for NM360 because the alloying elements provide hardenability and carbide formation. However, the dilution from the substrate must be considered; the first layer will have a different composition than the subsequent layers. In summary, this is a practical study that provides clear guidance on post-weld heat treatment of hardfaced wear-resistant steel components. The next step would be to conduct a field trial on a real component, such as a chute liner, to validate the laboratory results under actual service conditions. The economic benefit is clear: a 32.7% improvement in wear resistance can double the service life of a component, reducing downtime and maintenance costs.