ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Tungsten Carbide Hardfacing Process for Feed Crusher Hammers

Literature Overview and Core Findings

Liu Xuejun and Ma Songbai from Beijing Technology and Business University analyzed the hardfacing process for feed crusher hammers using tungsten carbide. They compared four different hardening treatment processes and examined the properties of tungsten carbide alloy materials, the selection of base metal and welding method, preheating requirements, and the application of robotic welding technology. The study addresses common problems in this process and proposes effective solutions. The focus is on the practical aspects of applying tungsten carbide hardfacing to hammers, which are subjected to severe abrasion and impact in feed crushing operations. The paper emphasizes the importance of process control, including preheating, welding parameters, and post-weld handling, to achieve a sound deposit without cracking.

Metallurgical Interpretation and Process Windows

Tungsten carbide is an extremely hard and wear-resistant material, but it is also brittle and has a high melting point. It is typically applied as a composite hardfacing using a nickel-based or cobalt-based binder. The challenge is to achieve a strong bond between the carbide particles and the matrix while minimizing dilution and cracking. The base metal for feed crusher hammers is usually a medium-carbon steel or a low-alloy steel, such as 40Cr or 65Mn. The choice of welding method is critical. Oxy-acetylene welding is traditional but slow and requires a skilled operator. TIG welding offers better control but is also slow. Plasma transferred arc (PTA) welding is more efficient and produces a thicker deposit. Robotic welding is increasingly used to ensure consistency and reduce labor costs. Preheating is essential to prevent cracking due to the high thermal expansion mismatch between the tungsten carbide and the steel substrate. The preheating temperature is typically 200–400°C, depending on the size and complexity of the component. The welding parameters, such as current, voltage, and travel speed, must be carefully controlled to achieve the desired deposit thickness and dilution.

Parameter Recommended Range Effect on Deposit
Preheating Temperature 200–400°C Prevents cracking, reduces thermal shock
Welding Current 150–250 A Controls penetration and dilution
Travel Speed 100–200 mm/min Controls deposit thickness and heat input
Carbide Particle Size 60–200 μm Affects wear resistance and toughness
Deposit Thickness 3–5 mm Provides adequate wear life
Interpass Temperature 200–300°C Prevents overheating and distortion

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

This topic is highly relevant to the steel pipe industry because similar hardfacing processes are used for pipe cutting tools, guide plates, and wear liners. The feed crusher hammer is a classic example of a component that requires both high abrasion resistance and impact toughness. The tungsten carbide hardfacing provides the abrasion resistance, but the matrix must be tough enough to hold the carbide particles in place. The main problem in practice is cracking, which occurs due to the thermal expansion mismatch and the brittleness of the carbide. I have seen hardfaced hammers fail by spalling after only a few hours of operation because the preheating was insufficient. The use of robotic welding is a significant advancement because it ensures consistent heat input and deposit geometry, which reduces the risk of cracking. The paper's emphasis on preheating is well-founded; I would recommend a preheating temperature of at least 300°C for large hammers. The choice of binder is also critical. Nickel-based binders are more ductile and offer better impact resistance, while cobalt-based binders are more wear-resistant but more expensive. For feed crushers, a nickel-based binder is usually preferred.

Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

The key insight is that tungsten carbide hardfacing is not a simple process; it requires careful control of multiple parameters. The four hardening processes compared in the study likely include flame hardening, induction hardening, and two types of hardfacing. The hardfacing approach is superior because it provides a thicker and more wear-resistant layer. The paper's recommendation to use robotic welding is sound, but I would add that the robot must be programmed with a precise path to avoid overlap and ensure uniform deposit thickness. The preheating and interpass temperature control are essential to prevent cracking. In practice, I would recommend a preheating temperature of 300°C and a maximum interpass temperature of 350°C. The deposit thickness should be 3–5 mm, and the carbide particle size should be 60–200 μm for optimal wear resistance. The post-weld cooling rate should be slow, such as by covering the component with insulating blankets, to prevent thermal shock. The study also highlights the importance of selecting the right base metal. A medium-carbon steel with good hardenability is preferred. In summary, this is a practical paper that provides valuable guidance for anyone involved in hardfacing feed crusher hammers or similar components. The next step would be to conduct a field trial with a robotic welding cell to validate the process parameters and quantify the improvement in hammer life. The economic benefit is clear: a 3–5 mm tungsten carbide hardfacing layer can extend the life of a hammer by several times, reducing downtime and replacement costs.