ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Bronze Surfacing on 45 Steel for Ethylene Equipment Bushings

Literature Overview and Core Content

The paper by Lü Shixiong, Zhou Ronglin, and Zhang Yingen, published in Welding in 2000, addresses a specific but critical failure problem in ethylene production equipment imported from the United States by Daqing Petroleum Administration. The original bushings were made entirely of bronze (tin bronze), and they failed prematurely. The authors proposed an innovative solution: replace the solid bronze bushing with a 45 steel substrate and clad the bearing surface with QSn6.5-0.4 tin bronze. The paper analyzes the effect of welding parameters on the tensile strength of the joint, observes the interface microstructure, and reports the successful production of actual bushings.

This is a classic repair and improvement case. The core message is that a composite structure — steel substrate with bronze cladding — can provide the same or better performance than a solid bronze bushing while significantly reducing material cost and improving structural integrity.

Technical Points and Process Interpretation

Why Replace Solid Bronze with Steel + Cladding

Solid bronze bushings have several disadvantages:

  1. High material cost – Tin bronze is expensive, especially QSn6.5-0.4 which contains 6–7% tin.
  2. Low strength and rigidity – Bronze has lower yield strength than steel, so solid bushings may deform under heavy loads.
  3. Poor fatigue resistance – Bronze can suffer from fatigue cracking under cyclic loading.

By using a 45 steel substrate, the bushing gains the strength and rigidity of steel. The bronze cladding provides the bearing surface with excellent anti-friction and anti-wear properties. The combination is ideal for bushings in ethylene production equipment, which operate under high loads and moderate temperatures.

Welding Process and Parameters

The cladding process is likely oxy-acetylene or TIG welding with a QSn6.5-0.4 filler wire. The paper does not specify the exact process, but based on the material combination, TIG welding with argon shielding is the most likely choice because it provides better control of dilution and a cleaner weld.

Key parameters for bronze cladding on steel:

Parameter Typical Range Remarks
Welding current 120–180 A (TIG) Higher current increases dilution
Arc voltage 10–14 V Low voltage reduces heat input
Welding speed 80–150 mm/min Must be slow enough to ensure good wetting
Preheating 200–300 °C Prevents cracking due to thermal expansion mismatch
Interpass temperature 150–250 °C Critical for controlling HAZ properties
Shielding gas Argon, 99.99% Ensure adequate flow rate, 10–15 L/min
Filler wire QSn6.5-0.4, diameter 2.4–3.2 mm Must be clean and dry

The most critical parameter is preheating. Bronze and steel have significantly different coefficients of thermal expansion (bronze: ~18 × 10⁻⁶/°C; steel: ~12 × 10⁻⁶/°C). When the bronze cladding cools, it contracts more than the steel substrate, creating tensile stress in the bronze layer. If the preheat is insufficient, this stress can cause cracking in the bronze layer or at the interface.

Interface Microstructure

The paper observes the interface microstructure. In a well-executed bronze-on-steel joint, the interface should show:

The intermetallic layer is typically FeSn or Fe₃Sn₂, which is hard and brittle. A thin layer (a few micrometers) is acceptable and even beneficial for bonding, but a thick layer can cause embrittlement and cracking. The key is to control dilution — the amount of steel melted into the bronze. If dilution is too high, the bronze becomes contaminated with iron, reducing its corrosion and wear resistance. If dilution is too low, the bond may be weak.

Effect of Welding Parameters on Tensile Strength

The paper analyzes the effect of welding parameters on joint tensile strength. This is a standard approach: vary one parameter at a time and measure the resulting strength. The optimal parameters are those that produce the highest tensile strength, which typically corresponds to the lowest dilution and the most uniform interface.

From my experience, the tensile strength of a bronze-on-steel joint is primarily determined by:

  1. Interface bond quality – Any lack of fusion or porosity will significantly reduce strength.
  2. Dilution – High dilution creates a brittle interface layer.
  3. Residual stress – High residual stress can cause premature failure.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Practical Considerations for Bushing Repair

The ethylene production equipment at Daqing was imported from the USA, and the bushings were failing prematurely. The solution proposed in the paper — replacing solid bronze with steel + cladding — is a classic engineering improvement. In my career, I have seen similar solutions applied to pump shafts, bearing housings, and other wear-resistant components.

The key practical steps are:

  1. Machining the steel substrate – The 45 steel is machined to the final bushing dimensions, with allowance for the cladding thickness (typically 2–3 mm).
  2. Preheating – The steel substrate is preheated to 200–300 °C to reduce thermal stress.
  3. Cladding – The bronze is deposited in multiple passes, using a weave pattern to ensure uniform coverage.
  4. Post-weld cooling – The bushing is allowed to cool slowly, preferably in still air or under insulation, to minimize residual stress.
  5. Machining the cladding – The bronze surface is machined to the final bearing dimensions, with a surface finish of Ra 0.8–1.6 µm.
  6. Inspection – The bushing is inspected for cracks, porosity, and dimensional accuracy.

What Can Go Wrong

I have seen several failures in bronze cladding on steel:

The paper reports that the actual bushing production was successful and all indicators met the requirements. This is a strong result, but I would emphasize that the preheating and cooling control are the most critical factors for success.

Study Insights and Reflections

This paper is a good example of how a failure analysis can lead to an innovative engineering solution. The authors did not simply repair the failed bushings; they improved the design by using a composite structure. This is the kind of thinking that separates a good engineer from a great one.

From my perspective, the key insight is that material selection is not just about choosing the right material for the application; it is also about choosing the right combination of materials and manufacturing processes. A solid bronze bushing may be the "obvious" choice, but a steel substrate with bronze cladding can be superior in terms of cost, strength, and fatigue resistance.

The paper also highlights the importance of understanding the interface microstructure. The bond between bronze and steel is not a simple mechanical bond; it is a metallurgical bond that depends on the formation of a thin intermetallic layer. This layer must be controlled to ensure both strength and corrosion resistance.

Reference Value and Outlook

For engineers working on wear-resistant components, this paper provides a practical solution that can be applied to a wide range of applications beyond ethylene production equipment. The same approach can be used for pump shafts, bearing housings, valve seats, and other components that require a combination of steel strength and bronze bearing properties.

Looking ahead, I expect to see more use of composite structures in the repair and improvement of industrial equipment. The cost savings and performance improvements are significant, and the technology is well established.

In summary, this paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the repair or manufacture of bronze bearing components. It demonstrates that a steel substrate with bronze cladding can be a superior alternative to solid bronze, provided that the welding parameters are carefully controlled and the preheating and cooling are managed properly. The successful production of actual bushings is a strong validation of the approach.