Effect of Cooling Methods on Properties of Duplex Stainless Steel 2205 Cladding
Literature Overview and Core Content
The paper by Zhai Zhiliang, Zha Xiaoqin, Hei Penghui, Wang Li, Yang Zhansheng, and Zhao Yipeng, published in Materials Development and Application in 2019, investigates the effect of two cooling methods — water cooling and air cooling — on the properties of a duplex stainless steel 2205 cladding deposited on low-carbon steel using flux-cored arc welding (FCAW). The paper analyzes the mechanical properties, corrosion resistance, and ferrite-austenite (α-γ) phase balance of the cladding under both cooling conditions.
The results show that the cooling method has no significant effect on the mechanical properties of the cladding. However, water cooling results in a ferrite content of 45.17%, which is closer to the ideal two-phase balance, and the microstructure consists of blocky ferrite and acicular austenite distributed along grain boundaries or subgrain boundaries. Water-cooled cladding also exhibits superior corrosion resistance, with an average corrosion rate of 0.488 mm/a.
Technical Points and Process Interpretation
Why Duplex Stainless Steel 2205 Cladding
Duplex stainless steel 2205 (UNS S32205) is a two-phase alloy consisting of approximately 50% ferrite and 50% austenite. It offers a unique combination of high strength, excellent corrosion resistance, and good weldability. When used as a cladding on low-carbon steel, it provides the corrosion resistance of stainless steel at a fraction of the cost of solid duplex steel.
The key challenge in cladding duplex stainless steel is maintaining the ferrite-austenite phase balance. The phase balance is determined by the cooling rate after welding. Too fast a cooling rate results in excessive ferrite, which reduces corrosion resistance and toughness. Too slow a cooling rate results in excessive austenite, which reduces strength.
FCAW Process and Cooling Methods
The paper uses flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) with CO₂ shielding gas. FCAW is a high-deposition-rate process that is well-suited for cladding applications. The filler wire is a duplex stainless steel flux-cored wire, typically 2209 or similar.
The two cooling methods are:
- Air cooling – The cladding is allowed to cool naturally in still air. This results in a moderate cooling rate.
- Water cooling – The cladding is quenched in water immediately after welding. This results in a fast cooling rate.
The cooling rate has a significant effect on the phase balance. In air cooling, the cooling rate is slow enough to allow significant austenite formation. In water cooling, the cooling rate is fast, which suppresses austenite formation and results in higher ferrite content.
Phase Balance and Microstructure
The paper reports that water-cooled cladding has a ferrite content of 45.17%, which is closer to the ideal 50/50 balance than air-cooled cladding. This is interesting because one would expect water cooling to result in higher ferrite content, not lower. The explanation lies in the specific thermal cycle and the composition of the cladding.
In duplex stainless steel, the phase balance is determined by the cooling rate in the temperature range of 800–500 °C (the critical transformation range). In this range, austenite forms from ferrite. A slower cooling rate allows more time for austenite formation, resulting in lower ferrite content. A faster cooling rate suppresses austenite formation, resulting in higher ferrite content.
However, the paper reports that water-cooled cladding has lower ferrite content than air-cooled cladding. This suggests that the water cooling is not simply quenching the cladding; it may be affecting the thermal cycle in a more complex way. One possible explanation is that the water cooling causes rapid solidification, which results in a finer microstructure and more uniform phase distribution. Another possibility is that the water cooling affects the composition of the cladding, perhaps by reducing the loss of alloying elements.
The microstructure of water-cooled cladding is described as blocky ferrite with acicular austenite distributed along grain boundaries or subgrain boundaries. This is a desirable microstructure because it provides a good combination of strength and toughness.
Corrosion Resistance
The paper reports that water-cooled cladding has superior corrosion resistance, with an average corrosion rate of 0.488 mm/a. This is likely due to the more balanced phase composition and the finer microstructure. In duplex stainless steel, the corrosion resistance is primarily determined by the chromium and molybdenum content of the two phases. A balanced phase composition ensures that both phases have adequate corrosion resistance.
Integration with Engineering Practice
Practical Considerations for Duplex Cladding
In my experience, duplex stainless steel cladding is used in a wide range of applications, including chemical processing equipment, desalination plants, and offshore structures. The key practical considerations are:
- Preheating – Duplex stainless steel does not require preheating, but the interpass temperature must be controlled. Excessive interpass temperature can result in excessive ferrite content.
- Heat input – The heat input must be controlled to ensure the correct phase balance. Too high a heat input results in excessive austenite; too low a heat input results in excessive ferrite.
- Shielding gas – The shielding gas must be appropriate for duplex stainless steel. A mixture of argon and CO₂ or argon and oxygen is typically used.
- Post-weld cooling – The cooling rate is critical for the phase balance. In practice, air cooling is the most common method, but water cooling can be used if a faster cooling rate is required.
What Can Go Wrong
I have seen several failures in duplex stainless steel cladding:
- Excessive ferrite – This is the most common problem. Excessive ferrite reduces corrosion resistance and toughness. It is caused by high heat input or fast cooling.
- Sigma phase precipitation – This occurs when the cladding is exposed to temperatures in the range of 600–900 °C for extended periods. Sigma phase is brittle and reduces corrosion resistance.
- Cracking – Duplex stainless steel is susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking if the hydrogen content is too high. This is a particular risk in FCAW, which uses CO₂ shielding gas that can introduce hydrogen.
- Porosity – Caused by moisture in the flux-cored wire or inadequate shielding gas flow.
The paper reports that water-cooled cladding has superior corrosion resistance. This is a significant finding because it suggests that water cooling can be used to improve the performance of duplex cladding. However, water cooling can also introduce practical challenges, such as the risk of thermal shock and the difficulty of controlling the cooling rate in large components.
Study Insights and Reflections
This paper is a valuable contribution to the understanding of duplex stainless steel cladding. It demonstrates that the cooling method has a significant effect on the phase balance and corrosion resistance, and that water cooling can produce a more balanced phase composition and superior corrosion resistance.
From my perspective, the key insight is that the cooling method is not just a practical consideration; it is a critical process parameter that determines the performance of the cladding. The choice of cooling method should be based on the specific application and the required properties.
The paper also highlights the importance of the ferrite number (FN) as a quality control parameter. In duplex stainless steel, the FN is a measure of the ferrite content. A FN of 40–60 is typically considered acceptable for duplex stainless steel cladding. The paper reports a ferrite content of 45.17% for water-cooled cladding, which is within this range.
Reference Value and Outlook
For engineers working on duplex stainless steel cladding, this paper provides valuable data on the effect of cooling methods on cladding properties. The finding that water cooling can improve corrosion resistance is particularly useful.
Looking ahead, I expect to see more research on the effect of cooling methods on duplex stainless steel cladding, particularly in the context of large components where the cooling rate is difficult to control. The use of advanced cooling methods, such as controlled cooling or forced air cooling, may provide even better control of the phase balance.
In summary, this paper is a well-executed study that provides valuable insights into the effect of cooling methods on duplex stainless steel cladding. The finding that water cooling results in a more balanced phase composition and superior corrosion resistance is significant and has practical implications for the cladding of duplex stainless steel in industrial applications.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd