Development of Flexible Strip Surfacing Materials
Literature Overview and Core Technical Points
This paper by Song Dan et al. (2010) from Shenyang University of Technology and Shenyang Bolaiti Welding Materials Co., Ltd. addresses a niche but important problem: surfacing the internal surfaces of small-diameter pipes and tubes. Traditional surfacing methods — such as TIG welding with filler wire, plasma transferred arc (PTA), or laser cladding — are difficult or impossible to apply inside a small-diameter tube.
The solution is a flexible strip material made by mixing hard particles (Ni60 and WC powders) with an organic silicone adhesive, forming the mixture into a strip, and drying it. The strip can be bent and inserted into a tube, then welded using TIG. The paper analyzes the effect of different adhesives on strip formability and evaluates the weld microstructure and hardness.
Material Design and Process Analysis
The Flexible Strip Concept
The fundamental problem with internal surfacing of small-diameter pipes is access. A welding torch can be inserted into a tube, but feeding filler wire into the weld pool while maintaining a proper arc length is extremely difficult when the tube diameter is less than about 50mm. The flexible strip solves this by pre-placing the filler material on the surface to be welded.
The strip is made by mixing the hard particles (Ni60, WC) with an adhesive, forming the mixture into a strip with the desired dimensions, and drying it. The adhesive must provide enough green strength to hold the strip together during handling and insertion, but it must burn off cleanly during welding without leaving residue that causes porosity or slag inclusions.
| Component | Function | Typical Content |
|---|---|---|
| Ni60 powder | Matrix material, provides toughness and corrosion resistance | 50-70% |
| WC powder | Hard phase, provides wear resistance | 20-40% |
| Organic silicone adhesive | Binder, provides green strength | 5-10% |
Adhesive Selection
The paper evaluates different adhesives for their effect on strip formability. The key requirements are:
- Green strength: The strip must be strong enough to handle without breaking.
- Flexibility: The strip must be flexible enough to bend into a small-diameter tube.
- Clean burn-off: The adhesive must decompose completely during welding without leaving residue.
- No adverse effect on weld quality: The adhesive must not cause porosity, slag inclusions, or other defects.
| Adhesive Type | Formability | Burn-off Behavior | Weld Quality |
|---|---|---|---|
| Organic silicone | Good flexibility, moderate strength | Clean burn-off, minimal residue | Good |
| Other organic adhesives | Variable | May leave residue | Variable |
The organic silicone adhesive is identified as the best choice because it provides good flexibility and burns off cleanly. The flexibility is particularly important because the strip must be able to conform to the internal surface of the tube.
TIG Welding with Flexible Strip
The welding process uses TIG with the flexible strip pre-placed on the surface. The TIG arc melts the strip and the underlying substrate, creating a weld pool that mixes the hard particles with the substrate material. The result is a composite deposit with hard particles dispersed in a metallic matrix.
| Parameter | Typical Value | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Welding current | 80-150A | Controls heat input and dilution |
| Arc voltage | 10-15V | Affects arc characteristics |
| Travel speed | 50-150 mm/min | Controls deposition rate and heat input |
| Shielding gas | Argon, 10-15 L/min | Prevents oxidation |
Microstructure and Hardness
The paper reports the microstructure and hardness of the deposits. The Ni60 matrix provides a hard, corrosion-resistant matrix, while the WC particles provide additional wear resistance. The hardness of the deposit is typically in the range of HRC 55-65, depending on the dilution and the WC content.
The microstructure shows the WC particles partially dissolved in the matrix, with some re-precipitation of fine carbides. This is typical of WC-containing hardfacing deposits. The degree of dissolution depends on the heat input — higher heat input causes more dissolution, which reduces the wear resistance but improves the bond strength.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
Application to Small-Diameter Pipe Internal Surfacing
The primary application for this technology is the internal surfacing of small-diameter pipes and tubes used in abrasive service. Examples include:
- Pneumatic conveying pipes for cement, fly ash, and other abrasive materials.
- Slurry transport pipes for mining and mineral processing.
- Boiler tubes for coal-fired power plants, where erosion by fly ash is a concern.
In my experience, these pipes typically have internal diameters of 20-100mm, which makes conventional welding techniques impractical. The flexible strip approach allows the surfacing material to be placed precisely on the internal surface, then welded with a TIG torch that can be inserted into the tube.
The Formability Challenge
The formability of the strip is critical. If the strip is too stiff, it will not conform to the internal surface of the tube, leaving gaps that result in lack of fusion. If the strip is too soft, it will deform during handling and may not stay in place during welding.
The organic silicone adhesive provides the right balance. It gives the strip enough green strength to handle, but enough flexibility to bend into a small-diameter tube. The adhesive burns off cleanly during welding, leaving a dense, sound deposit.
Common Defects and Countermeasures
| Defect | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Porosity | Adhesive residue, gas entrapment | Use clean-burning adhesive, ensure proper drying |
| Lack of fusion | Strip not conforming to surface, low heat input | Improve strip formability, increase current |
| WC dissolution | Excessive heat input | Reduce current, increase travel speed |
| Cracking | High hardness, residual stress | Preheating, controlled cooling, post-weld treatment |
| Slag inclusions | Adhesive residue, oxide contamination | Use clean-burning adhesive, clean surface before welding |
The 5W2H Analysis
- What: Flexible strip surfacing material for small-diameter pipe internal surfaces.
- Why: Conventional welding methods cannot access small-diameter tubes.
- Where: Internal surfaces of pipes and tubes, 20-100mm diameter.
- When: During manufacture or repair of wear-resistant pipes.
- Who: Welding engineers and operators at pipe manufacturing and repair facilities.
- How: Pre-placed flexible strip, TIG welding, controlled heat input.
- **
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd