Hardox400 Wear-Resistant Plate Surfacing Joint Hardness and Microstructure: HAZ Softening and Deposit Integrity
Introduction and Literature Context
This companion paper by the same research group at Beijing University of Technology, published in Welding journal in 2013, focuses specifically on the effect of the surfacing process on the hardness and microstructure of the Hardox400 base material. While the first paper (Topic 2) addressed alloy selection and deposit properties, this paper examines the interface between the deposit and the base material, with particular attention to the heat-affected zone (HAZ) and the potential for softening or cracking.
The paper uses CO2 gas shielded arc welding to deposit a single bead on Hardox400, then measures macro-hardness from the HAZ to the base material and observes the microstructure of the joint region. The key findings are that the hardness drop zone is limited to 5mm, the maximum hardness reduction occurs at 1-2mm from the fusion line and is 18-26% of the base material hardness, and no significant grain growth is observed in the fusion zone. The deposit consists of martensite as the wear-resistant skeleton with finely dispersed Fe2B as the hard phase, which matches the base material's martensitic structure.
Technical Interpretation and Metallurgical Analysis
HAZ Softening Mechanism
The softening of the HAZ in Hardox400 is a well-known phenomenon that occurs when the material is heated above its tempering temperature. Hardox400 is supplied in the quenched and tempered condition, with a tempering temperature typically in the range of 250-400°C. When the material is heated above this temperature during welding, the tempered martensite undergoes additional tempering, resulting in a reduction in hardness.
The paper reports that the maximum hardness reduction is 18-26% of the base material hardness, occurring at 1-2mm from the fusion line. This is consistent with the temperature distribution in the HAZ. The region closest to the fusion line experiences the highest peak temperature, which may exceed the austenitizing temperature, resulting in re-austenitization and subsequent transformation to fresh martensite on cooling. This fresh martensite may be harder than the original tempered martensite, but it is also more brittle. The region at 1-2mm from the fusion line experiences a peak temperature below the austenitizing temperature but above the tempering temperature, resulting in over-tempering and softening.
The limited extent of the softening zone (5mm) is a positive finding. In many high-strength steels, the HAZ softening zone can extend 10-20mm from the fusion line, particularly with high heat input welding processes. The limited softening in this case suggests that the welding parameters used were appropriate for minimizing heat input.
Microstructural Observations
The paper reports that no significant grain growth is observed in the fusion zone. This is important because grain growth in the HAZ can lead to reduced toughness and increased susceptibility to cracking. The absence of grain growth indicates that the peak temperature in the HAZ did not exceed the grain coarsening temperature, which is typically around 1100-1200°C for low-alloy steels.
The deposit microstructure consists of martensite as the wear-resistant skeleton with finely dispersed Fe2B as the hard phase. The martensite provides toughness and strength, while the Fe2B provides hardness and wear resistance. The paper notes that this structure is compatible with the base material's martensitic structure, which is important for ensuring good metallurgical bonding and preventing spalling.
Interface Integrity and Spalling Resistance
The paper's finding that the deposit does not spall is significant. Spalling is a common failure mode in hardfacing, where the deposit separates from the base material due to inadequate bonding or excessive residual stress. The good compatibility between the deposit's martensitic structure and the base material's martensitic structure promotes strong metallurgical bonding, reducing the risk of spalling.
The absence of cracking at the interface is also important. Cracking can occur due to hydrogen embrittlement, residual stress, or the formation of brittle phases at the interface. The paper's finding that no cracks are observed suggests that the welding parameters and alloy selection were appropriate for the application.
Engineering Practice and Practical Implications
HAZ Softening and Component Performance
The HAZ softening zone, even though limited to 5mm, can affect component performance. If the component is subjected to high bending loads, the softened zone may act as a stress concentration point, leading to premature failure. In practice, this means that the component must be designed with the HAZ softening zone in mind, or the component must be re-tempered after welding.
For Hardox400 components, re-tempering is not recommended because it would reduce the hardness of the entire component. Instead, the design should account for the HAZ softening zone, and the component should be inspected for cracks or deformation after surfacing.
Welding Parameter Optimization
The paper's findings on HAZ softening provide a basis for optimizing welding parameters. The key parameters that affect HAZ softening are:
- Heat input: Lower heat input reduces the extent and severity of HAZ softening.
- Preheat temperature: Higher preheat temperature increases heat input and may worsen HAZ softening.
- Interpass temperature: Higher interpass temperature increases heat input and may worsen HAZ softening.
- Welding technique: Short-circuit transfer or pulsed transfer modes reduce heat input compared to spray transfer.
In practice, the welding parameters should be selected to minimize heat input while maintaining adequate fusion. The paper's finding that the HAZ softening zone is limited to 5mm suggests that the parameters used were appropriate, but the specific parameters are not provided.
Quality Control and Inspection
For Hardox400 surfacing repairs, the following quality control measures are recommended:
- Pre-weld inspection: Verify that the base material is free from cracks, corrosion or other defects.
- Preheating: Verify that the preheat temperature is within the specified range.
- Interpass temperature control: Monitor the interpass temperature to prevent excessive heat buildup.
- Post-weld inspection: Perform magnetic particle or dye penetrant testing to detect surface cracks.
- Hardness testing: Measure the hardness of the deposit and the HAZ to verify that the properties are within the specified range.
- Metallographic examination: If required, perform metallographic examination of a cross-section to verify the microstructure and interface integrity.
The paper's finding that the HAZ softening zone is limited to 5mm provides a basis for defining acceptance criteria. If the HAZ softening zone exceeds 5mm or the hardness reduction exceeds 30%, the repair may be considered unacceptable.
Comparison with Alternative Base Materials
Hardox400 is one of several wear-resistant steels available, including Hardox450, Hardox500, and various other quenched and tempered steels. The HAZ softening behavior of these materials is similar, but the extent and severity of softening may vary depending on the alloy composition and tempering treatment.
For applications where HAZ softening is a concern, alternative materials such as austenitic manganese steel (Hadfield steel) may be considered. Austenitic manganese steel work-hardens under impact, providing excellent wear resistance without the HAZ softening problem. However, austenitic manganese steel has lower yield strength and is more difficult to machine.
Critical Assessment and Study Insights
Strengths of the Research
The paper's focus on the HAZ and interface integrity is a valuable contribution. Many hardfacing studies focus on the deposit properties but neglect the effect on the base material. This paper addresses this gap by providing quantitative data on HAZ softening and qualitative observations on interface integrity.
The use of macro-hardness testing across the HAZ is a practical and reliable method for assessing HAZ softening. The hardness profile provides a clear picture of the extent and severity of softening, which can be used to define acceptance criteria for the repair.
Limitations and Unanswered Questions
The paper does not provide data on the mechanical properties of the HAZ, such as impact toughness or tensile strength. The HAZ softening may affect the mechanical properties of the component, but the paper does not quantify this effect.
The paper does not address the effect of multi-pass welding on the HAZ. In practical applications, multiple passes are often required, and each pass reheats the HAZ, potentially causing additional softening or tempering. The paper's single-pass approach does not reflect this reality.
The paper does not provide specific welding parameters, which makes it difficult to reproduce the results. The paper should have included the welding current, voltage, travel speed, and shielding gas flow rate.
Comparison with Industry Practice
In my experience, the HAZ softening behavior of Hardox400 is well known, and the paper's findings are consistent with industry practice. The limited HAZ softening zone (5mm) is a positive result, but it depends on the welding parameters used. In practice, the HAZ softening zone can extend 10-15mm with high heat input processes such as submerged arc welding.
The paper's finding that the deposit does not spall is consistent with good practice. Spalling is most commonly caused by inadequate surface preparation, high residual stress, or the use of an incompatible filler material. The paper's approach, using a compatible filler material and appropriate welding parameters, minimizes the risk of spalling.
Conclusions and Practical Recommendations
The paper provides valuable data on the HAZ softening behavior of Hardox400 when surfaced with the Fe-B-C-Nb-Ni flux-cored wire. The HAZ softening zone is limited to 5mm, with a maximum hardness reduction of 18-26% occurring at 1-2mm from the fusion line. The deposit forms a good metallurgical bond with the base material, with no evidence of cracking or spalling.
For practical applications, the following recommendations are made:
- The welding parameters should be optimized to minimize heat input and HAZ softening.
- The HAZ softening zone should be considered in the design of the component, particularly for components subjected to high bending loads.
- The deposit and HAZ should be inspected for cracks and hardness variations after welding.
- The component should be tested in service to verify the performance of the repair.
The paper's findings are particularly relevant for the repair of Hardox400 components in the steel pipe and fitting industry, where the material is used in pipe handling equipment, conveyor systems and chutes. The ability to repair worn components without degrading the base material's performance is critical for cost-effective maintenance.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd