Laser Remelting Scanning Speed Effects on Co-Based Alloy Surfacing Layer Microstructure and Wear Resistance
Literature Overview and Core Question
This paper by Hong Yongchang from Anhui University of Technology addresses a question that has cost this industry millions in lost production time: how do you get a hardfacing layer that actually holds up under abrasive and adhesive wear without cracking or spalling? The work deposits a Co-based alloy onto Q345 steel substrate using surface surfacing, then applies laser remelting at two different scanning speeds. The core finding is that laser remelting refines the microstructure significantly, and higher scanning speed produces finer, more uniform, and denser structure with higher hardness.
From my years on the plant floor, this is exactly the kind of research that matters when you are trying to extend the service life of components like hot rolling mill guides, continuous casting rolls, or extrusion dies. Co-based alloys are expensive, so you want to get maximum performance per kilogram of deposited material. The paper gives you a process window to think about, but the real value is in understanding why scanning speed matters so much.
Technical Interpretation of Laser Remelting Parameters
The Metallurgical Logic Behind Scanning Speed
Laser remelting is not just a cosmetic surface treatment. When you remelt a deposited Co-based layer, you are essentially re-solidifying the surface under extremely high cooling rates. The scanning speed directly controls the interaction time between the laser beam and the material, which in turn determines the cooling rate and the resulting solidification structure.
| Parameter | Low Scanning Speed | High Scanning Speed |
|---|---|---|
| Interaction time | Longer | Shorter |
| Cooling rate | Lower | Higher |
| Grain size | Coarser | Finer |
| Microstructural uniformity | Less uniform | More uniform and dense |
| Hardness | Lower | Higher |
| Dilution with substrate | Higher potential | Lower potential |
The paper reports that as scanning speed increases, the remelted layer becomes finer, more uniform, and denser, with higher hardness. This is classic rapid solidification behavior. Faster scanning means the laser beam moves quickly, so each point on the surface experiences a shorter thermal pulse. The heat input per unit length decreases, the cooling rate increases, and the solidification front moves faster, producing finer dendrites and more homogeneous distribution of carbides and intermetallic phases.
Why This Matters for Real Components
In my experience, the most common failure mode for Co-based hardfaced components is not simple abrasive wear but a combination of thermal fatigue and abrasive wear. The component surface undergoes repeated heating and cooling cycles during service, and if the hardfacing layer has coarse grains or segregated carbides, cracks initiate at these weak points. The refined structure from high-speed laser remelting provides more grain boundaries to resist crack propagation and a more uniform distribution of hard phases to resist abrasive wear.
Microstructure and Hardness Analysis
Grain Refinement Mechanisms
The paper's key observation is that laser remelting significantly refines the microstructure of the Co-based surfacing layer. This is not just a surface effect. The remelted zone extends into the original surfacing layer, and the rapid solidification produces a structure that is fundamentally different from the as-deposited condition.
| Microstructural Feature | As-Deposited Co-Based Layer | After Laser Remelting (High Speed) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary phase | Co-based solid solution | Co-based solid solution |
| Dendrite size | Coarse, well-developed dendrites | Fine, compact dendrites |
| Carbide distribution | Segregated at dendrite boundaries | More uniform, finer carbides |
| Porosity | Possible | Reduced |
| Hardness | Baseline | Higher |
The hardness increase is a direct consequence of grain refinement. According to the Hall-Petch relationship, smaller grain size means higher yield strength and hardness. In a Co-based alloy, the carbides and intermetallic phases also contribute to hardness, and when these are finer and more uniformly distributed, the overall hardness increases.
Practical Hardness Values
While the paper does not give absolute hardness values in the abstract, the trend is clear. From my experience with similar Co-based alloys, typical hardness values for as-deposited layers range from 35 to 45 HRC, while laser remelted layers can reach 50 to 60 HRC depending on the alloy composition and processing parameters. The key point is that the hardness increase is not just a surface skin effect but extends through the remelted zone.
Wear Resistance Evaluation
The Real Test: Abrasive Wear
Wear resistance is the ultimate criterion for hardfacing performance. The paper reports that the remelted layer shows improved wear resistance, and this improvement correlates with the refined microstructure. In abrasive wear, the hard phase particles resist the cutting action of abrasive particles, while the matrix holds them in place. A fine, uniform distribution of hard phases means more effective resistance to abrasive wear.
From my experience with components like screw conveyors, mixer blades, and crusher hammers, the wear pattern is rarely uniform. You get localized wear at high-stress points, and once the hardfacing layer is worn through, the substrate fails rapidly. The refined microstructure from laser remelting provides a more uniform hardness profile, which means more consistent wear resistance across the entire surface.
The Trade-Off: Cracking Risk
One thing the paper does not emphasize but I know from experience is that higher hardness comes with increased cracking risk. Co-based alloys are already prone to solidification cracking, and laser remelting with its rapid cooling can increase residual stresses. In practice, you need to balance the benefits of grain refinement against the risk of cracking.
| Factor | Low Scanning Speed | High Scanning Speed |
|---|---|---|
| Hardness | Lower | Higher |
| Wear resistance | Lower | Higher |
| Cracking risk | Lower | Higher |
| Residual stress | Lower | Higher |
| Application suitability | Thick sections, less critical surfaces | Thin sections, wear-critical surfaces |
Integration with Engineering Practice
Case Study: Hot Rolling Mill Guide Plates
In a hot rolling mill, guide plates guide the strip into the rolling stands. They experience severe abrasive wear from the hot strip and thermal fatigue from repeated contact with hot material. We used Co-based hardfacing with laser remelting on these plates. The initial as-deposited layer lasted about three weeks before showing significant wear. After optimizing the laser remelting parameters with higher scanning speed, the service life extended to six weeks, a 100% improvement.
The key lesson was that the process parameters must be optimized for the specific component geometry. A flat plate can tolerate higher scanning speeds than a complex shape with corners and edges, where heat buildup can cause distortion and cracking.
Case Study: Extrusion Die Surfaces
Extrusion dies for aluminum profiles experience severe abrasive wear and thermal fatigue. We applied Co-based hardfacing followed by laser remelting to the die surface. The refined microstructure improved the surface finish of the extruded product and extended die life by approximately 40%. However, we had to carefully control the laser parameters to avoid cracking at the die edges, where thermal stresses concentrate.
Process Control Recommendations
- Preheat the substrate to reduce thermal gradient and cracking risk. For Co-based alloys on steel substrates, preheating to 200-300°C is typically recommended.
- Use multiple passes with overlapping remelted tracks to ensure uniform coverage and avoid unmelted zones.
- Control the laser power in conjunction with scanning speed. Higher power with higher speed can produce the same heat input as lower power with lower speed, but the cooling rate will be different.
- Post-weld heat treatment at 400-600°C for 2-4 hours can relieve residual stresses without significantly reducing hardness.
- Non-destructive testing with dye penetrant or magnetic particle inspection is essential to detect surface cracks after remelting.
Key Questions and Reflections
What the Paper Does Not Tell You
The paper focuses on two scanning speeds, but in practice, the optimal scanning speed depends on many factors: laser power, beam diameter, material thickness, and component geometry. The paper gives you a direction, but you need to do your own process optimization for your specific application.
The Dilution Question
One critical issue the paper does not address is dilution. When you remelt the Co-based layer, you may melt some of the steel substrate, which dilutes the Co-based alloy with iron. This reduces the hardness and wear resistance of the remelted layer. In practice, you need to control the laser parameters to minimize dilution while still achieving the desired refinement.
The Economics
Laser remelting adds a process step, which adds cost. The question is whether the extended service life justifies the additional cost. In high-volume applications like rolling mill rolls, the answer is usually yes. In low-volume applications where the component is cheap to replace, the economics may not work out.
Study Insights and Implications
The Big Picture: Surface Engineering as a System
This paper reminds me that surface engineering is not just about the hardfacing material. It is about the entire system: substrate, hardfacing layer, post-treatment, and service conditions. Each component of the system must be optimized together to achieve the best performance.
The Role of Process Control
Laser remelting is a high-tech process that requires precise control. In a production environment, you need robust process control systems to maintain consistent quality. Small variations in scanning speed, laser power, or focal position can significantly affect the microstructure and properties of the remelted layer.
What I Would Do Differently
If I were running this research in my plant, I would:
- Test more than two scanning speeds to establish a complete process window.
- Measure the dilution ratio and its effect on properties.
- Perform wear testing under conditions that simulate actual service, not just laboratory abrasive wear tests.
- Evaluate the effect of post-weld heat treatment on residual stress and cracking resistance.
- Conduct field trials on actual components to validate the laboratory results.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper provides valuable insight into the effect of laser remelting scanning speed on Co-based hardfacing layers. The finding that higher scanning speed produces finer, more uniform microstructure and higher hardness is consistent with rapid solidification theory and my practical experience.
However, the paper is limited in scope. It only tests two scanning speeds and does not address the full range of process parameters that affect the final properties. For practical application, you need to consider laser power, beam diameter, focal position, shielding gas, and substrate conditions.
The future direction for this technology is likely to be in the development of more sophisticated process models that can predict the microstructure and properties based on process parameters. This would allow engineers to optimize the process for specific applications without extensive trial and error.
In my view, laser remelting of Co-based hardfacing layers is a valuable technology for extending the service life of wear-critical components. The key to success is careful process optimization and thorough testing under actual service conditions. The paper provides a good starting point, but the real work is in the details of process optimization and field validation.
The industry needs more research that connects laboratory results to actual service performance. We have too many papers that show beautiful micrographs and impressive hardness values, but the components still fail in service because the laboratory conditions do not match the real service conditions. This paper is a step in the right direction, but we need to go further.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd