Repair and Reuse of Forging Dies by Hardfacing
Literature Overview and Practical Significance
This short paper by Li Wenbin and Guan Jun, published in Hot Working Technology in 2006, describes the process methods and corresponding process parameters for the repair and reuse of forging dies by hardfacing. It is a brief technical note, but it addresses a topic that is of enormous practical importance in the forging industry. Forging dies are expensive, and their premature failure due to wear, thermal fatigue, or mechanical fatigue is a major cost driver. The ability to repair and reuse a forging die can extend its service life significantly and reduce the cost per forging. I have seen many forging shops throw away dies that could have been repaired and reused, simply because they did not have a proper repair procedure. This paper provides a starting point for developing such a procedure.
Interpretation of Technical Points
The paper describes the general approach to forging die repair by hardfacing. The key steps are: cleaning the die surface, preparing the worn area by machining or grinding, preheating the die, depositing the hardfacing layer, and then machining the hardfaced surface to the required dimensions. The process parameters include the welding process, the electrode or filler material, the welding current and voltage, the welding speed, the preheat temperature, and the post-weld heat treatment.
The choice of hardfacing material is critical. For hot forging dies, the hardfacing material must have good hot hardness, good thermal fatigue resistance, and good resistance to oxidation and scaling. Common choices include cobalt-based alloys such as Stellite, nickel-based alloys such as Inconel, and iron-based alloys such as tool steels. Cobalt-based alloys have the best hot hardness and thermal fatigue resistance, but they are expensive. Nickel-based alloys are a good compromise between performance and cost. Iron-based alloys are the cheapest, but they have lower hot hardness and may not provide adequate service life.
The preheat temperature is another critical parameter. Forging dies are typically made from hot work tool steels such as H11, H13, or H21. These steels are air-hardening and are susceptible to cold cracking if welded without preheat. The preheat temperature should be in the range of 250 to 400 °C, depending on the die size and the hardfacing material. The interpass temperature should be maintained at the same level to prevent the HAZ from cooling too quickly and forming martensite.
The post-weld heat treatment is also important. After hardfacing, the die should be stress-relieved at a temperature below the tempering temperature of the base metal. For H13 steel, the stress relief temperature is typically 550 to 600 °C. The stress relief should be followed by slow cooling to prevent the formation of residual stress.
The following table summarizes the typical process parameters for forging die hardfacing that I would recommend based on my experience.
| Parameter | Recommended Range | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Die material | H11, H13, H21 | Hot work tool steels |
| Hardfacing material | Cobalt-based, nickel-based, or iron-based | Depends on the die service conditions |
| Welding process | SMAW, GTAW, or FCAW | SMAW is most common for field repair |
| Preheat temperature | 250 to 400 °C | Mandatory to prevent cold cracking |
| Interpass temperature | 300 to 400 °C | Must be controlled to avoid overtempering |
| Welding current | 100 to 200 A | Depends on the electrode diameter |
| Arc voltage | 20 to 28 V | Short arc to minimize dilution |
| Post-weld heat treatment | 550 to 600 °C for 2 hours | Stress relief and tempering |
| Deposited layer thickness | 3 to 10 mm | Depends on the wear depth |
| Machining allowance | 1 to 2 mm | For final machining to dimensions |
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
I have seen many forging die repair jobs fail because the die was not properly cleaned before hardfacing. The die surface must be free of oil, grease, scale, and cracks. If there are cracks, they must be ground out completely before hardfacing. If a crack is left in place, it will propagate through the hardfacing layer and cause premature failure. I have also seen failures due to inadequate preheat. In one case, a die was hardfaced without preheat, and the HAZ cracked immediately after welding. The die was scrapped, and the cost of the hardfacing was lost.
Another lesson I have learned is that the hardfacing layer should not be too thick. A thick hardfacing layer will have high residual stress and may crack during service. The maximum thickness should be about 10 mm. If the wear depth is greater than 10 mm, the die should be built up with a softer filler material first, and then the hardfacing layer should be applied on top. This reduces the residual stress and prevents cracking.
The machining of the hardfaced surface is also critical. The hardfacing material is typically much harder than the base metal, and it may be difficult to machine. In many cases, the hardfaced surface must be ground rather than machined. The grinding process must be carefully controlled to avoid overheating the hardfacing layer and causing cracking. I have seen cases where the grinding wheel was too hard, and the heat generated during grinding caused the hardfacing layer to crack.
The paper does not provide detailed process parameters, but it does emphasize the importance of the process method. In my experience, the most important factor in forging die repair is the preparation of the die surface. If the surface is not properly prepared, the hardfacing will not bond properly, and the repair will fail.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises an important question: when is it economically justified to repair a forging die rather than replace it? The answer depends on the cost of the new die, the cost of the repair, and the expected remaining life of the repaired die. In general, if the repair cost is less than 30 percent of the cost of a new die, and the repaired die can achieve at least 50 percent of the life of a new die, then the repair is economically justified. I have seen many cases where a repaired die achieved 80 to 90 percent of the life of a new die, which is an excellent return on investment.
Another question is whether the hardfacing material should be the same as the base metal or different. In general, the hardfacing material should be different from the base metal, because it needs to have better wear resistance and thermal fatigue resistance. However, the hardfacing material must be compatible with the base metal in terms of thermal expansion and metallurgical compatibility. If the hardfacing material has a significantly different coefficient of thermal expansion, it may crack during thermal cycling.
The paper does not address the issue of die distortion during hardfacing. Hardfacing introduces heat into the die, which can cause distortion. The distortion can be minimized by using a balanced welding sequence, such as welding alternating sides of the die. The die should also be supported properly during welding to prevent sagging.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a useful reminder that forging dies can be repaired and reused, and that the repair process is not difficult if the correct procedures are followed. The key to success is proper surface preparation, adequate preheat, careful control of the welding parameters, and proper post-weld heat treatment. The paper provides a good overview of the process, but it lacks the detailed process parameters that are needed to implement the process in a production environment.
From a practical standpoint, I would recommend that any forging shop that repairs dies should have a written repair procedure that specifies the surface preparation method, the preheat temperature, the welding process and parameters, the hardfacing material, and the post-weld heat treatment. The procedure should be validated by a test coupon that is sectioned and examined metallurgically. The welding operator should be qualified for the procedure, and the welding parameters should be monitored and recorded for each die repair.
The paper also highlights the importance of the process method. In my experience, the most successful forging die repair procedures use a combination of hardfacing and heat treatment. The hardfacing provides the wear resistance, and the heat treatment provides the toughness and strength. The two must be carefully balanced to achieve the best service life.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper has practical value for any forging shop that wants to reduce die costs by repairing and reusing dies. The process method described is sound, and the concept of extending die life by hardfacing is well established. However, the paper would be more useful if it provided specific process parameters for different die materials and hardfacing materials. I would also like to see a comparison of the service life of repaired dies versus new dies, and a cost analysis of the repair process.
In the future, I would expect to see more work on the use of laser cladding and plasma transferred arc welding for forging die repair. These processes offer better control of the heat input and dilution, and they can produce a more uniform hardfacing layer with less distortion. However, they are more expensive and require specialized equipment. For many shops, manual arc welding will remain the most economical option, and the process method described in this paper will continue to be relevant.
In conclusion, this paper is a practical contribution to the field of forging die repair. It demonstrates that forging dies can be repaired and reused, and that the repair process can significantly extend the die life. The process method described is sound, and I would recommend it to any forging shop that wants to reduce die costs. The key to success is proper surface preparation, adequate preheat, careful control of the welding parameters, and proper post-weld heat treatment. I would encourage any engineer responsible for forging die maintenance to develop a written repair procedure based on the principles described in this paper.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd