ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Failure Analysis and Improvement of Hardfacing Layer on Screw Blades

Literature Overview and Study Context

This 2004 paper from Mechanical Engineering Materials is a classic failure analysis case study. The authors, Pan Hongliang, Tang Jianhua, Huang Wuxing, and Qian Tianshun, from East China University of Science and Technology and Gaoqiao Chemical Plant, investigated the cause of Stellite hardfacing layer spalling on the screw blades of an expansion dryer used in cis-polybutadiene rubber production. The hardfacing layer failed after only three months of service.

The expansion dryer is a critical piece of equipment in rubber production, and the screw blades are subjected to a combination of abrasion, corrosion, and mechanical stress. The hardfacing layer is applied to provide wear and corrosion resistance, but its failure means the base material is exposed and the component must be replaced or repaired.

Core Technical Findings and Interpretation

The failure analysis revealed that the root cause was not the hardfacing alloy itself, but the selection of the base material. The screw blade was made of ZG1Cr18Ni12Mo2Ti, an austenitic stainless steel casting with a relatively high carbon content. Under the service conditions in the expansion dryer, this material experienced intergranular corrosion, which weakened the substrate beneath the hardfacing layer and caused the hardfacing to spall.

The mechanism is classic sensitization. The high carbon content of ZG1Cr18Ni12Mo2Ti allows chromium carbide precipitation at grain boundaries when the material is exposed to temperatures in the sensitization range, typically 450-850°C. The chromium-depleted zones at the grain boundaries become susceptible to intergranular corrosion in the corrosive process environment. As the corrosion proceeds along the grain boundaries, the substrate loses its integrity, and the hardfacing layer, which is still sound, loses its support and spalls off.

The corrective action was twofold. First, the screw blade material was changed from ZG1Cr18Ni12Mo2Ti to ZG0Cr17Ni4Cu4Nb, a precipitation-hardening stainless steel with lower carbon content and better corrosion resistance. Second, the Stellite hardfacing was applied at the end of the screw blade, where the wear and corrosion were most severe. After the change, the component operated for more than one year without failure, significantly extending the service life.

Parameter Original Design Improved Design
Base Material ZG1Cr18Ni12Mo2Ti ZG0Cr17Ni4Cu4Nb
Carbon Content Higher (sensitization risk) Lower (reduced sensitization risk)
Hardfacing Stellite alloy Stellite alloy at blade end
Service Life 3 months >12 months

Engineering Practice Implications

This case is a textbook example of why failure analysis must consider the entire system, not just the failed component. The hardfacing layer was not the problem; the substrate was. If the engineers had simply re-applied the same hardfacing on the same base material, the failure would have recurred.

The choice of ZG0Cr17Ni4Cu4Nb is interesting because it is a martensitic precipitation-hardening stainless steel, not an austenitic stainless steel. It has higher strength and better corrosion resistance than the original material, and its lower carbon content reduces the risk of sensitization. However, it also has different welding characteristics, and the hardfacing procedure had to be adjusted to accommodate the different base material.

The decision to apply Stellite hardfacing only at the end of the screw blade is a practical one. The end of the blade experiences the most severe wear and corrosion, so concentrating the hardfacing there provides the most benefit for the least cost. This is a good example of value engineering: apply the expensive material only where it is needed.

Study Insights and Reflections

This failure analysis highlights a lesson I have learned repeatedly in my career: the most common cause of hardfacing failure is not the hardfacing alloy, but the substrate or the interface. If the substrate is not suitable for the service environment, no hardfacing alloy will save it.

The case also demonstrates the importance of considering the service environment in material selection. ZG1Cr18Ni12Mo2Ti is a common stainless steel that works well in many applications, but it is not suitable for this particular service because of the sensitization risk. The engineers had to look beyond the standard material selection and choose a material that was specifically suited to the corrosive environment.

For the welding engineer, the lesson is to always ask what the substrate is and what the service conditions are before specifying a hardfacing alloy. A hardfacing procedure that is perfect for one application may be completely inadequate for another, even if the hardfacing alloy is the same.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a valuable case study for engineers involved in hardfacing of process equipment. It demonstrates a systematic approach to failure analysis, identifies the root cause, and implements a corrective action that significantly extends service life. The key takeaway is that material selection for the substrate is just as important as the hardfacing alloy, and the service environment must be considered in both.

For future work, it would be interesting to see a more detailed analysis of the corrosion mechanism, including the specific corrosive species in the rubber production process and the temperature profile in the dryer. This would help in selecting even more resistant materials and in optimizing the hardfacing procedure.