ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Failure Analysis and Improvement of Hardfacing Layers on Spiral Blades

Failure Description and Operating Context

The study by Pan Hongliang and colleagues addresses a specific and costly problem in the production of synthetic rubber. The expansion dryer, a key piece of equipment in the production of polybutadiene rubber, uses a spiral blade that is hardfaced with a Stellite alloy to resist wear and corrosion. After only three months of service, the hardfacing layer on the spiral blade began to detach, causing significant downtime and production losses. The authors conducted a failure analysis to determine the root cause and to develop a solution.

The spiral blade is exposed to a corrosive and abrasive environment, with the rubber compound containing sulfur compounds and other aggressive chemicals. The blade is subjected to high shear forces as it conveys the rubber, and the surface temperature can be elevated due to the mechanical work and the process conditions. The failure mode was the detachment of the Stellite hardfacing layer, which suggests that the bond between the hardfacing and the base metal was compromised.

Root Cause Analysis

The authors performed a thorough failure analysis, including chemical analysis, metallographic examination, and mechanical testing. The results revealed that the root cause of the failure was not the hardfacing material itself, but the selection of the base metal. The spiral blade was made of ZG1Cr18Ni12Mo2Ti, an austenitic stainless steel with a relatively high carbon content. Under the service conditions, this steel is susceptible to intergranular corrosion, which occurs when chromium carbides precipitate at the grain boundaries, depleting the adjacent regions of chromium and making them vulnerable to corrosion.

The intergranular corrosion weakened the base metal at the fusion line, causing the hardfacing layer to lose its bond and detach. The following table summarizes the key findings:

Analysis Result
Base metal composition ZG1Cr18Ni12Mo2Ti, high carbon content
Failure mode Detachment of Stellite hardfacing
Root cause Intergranular corrosion of base metal
Corrosion mechanism Chromium carbide precipitation at grain boundaries
Service environment Sulfur compounds, elevated temperature

The high carbon content of the base metal is the key factor. When the steel is heated during the hardfacing process, the temperature in the HAZ reaches the sensitization range (450 to 850°C), which causes chromium carbides to precipitate at the grain boundaries. This depletes the chromium in the adjacent regions, making them susceptible to intergranular corrosion. The corrosive environment then attacks the sensitized grain boundaries, weakening the base metal and causing the hardfacing to detach.

Material Selection and Process Improvement

Based on the failure analysis, the authors recommended two changes. First, the base metal was changed from ZG1Cr18Ni12Mo2Ti to ZG0Cr17Ni4Cu4Nb, a martensitic precipitation-hardening stainless steel with a lower carbon content and better corrosion resistance. This steel is less susceptible to sensitization because the carbon content is lower, and the addition of niobium helps to stabilize the carbon, preventing the formation of chromium carbides.

Second, the hardfacing process was improved to minimize the heat input and to ensure a sound bond. The Stellite hardfacing was applied to the end of the spiral blade, and the process parameters were optimized to reduce the width of the HAZ and to prevent sensitization. The following table compares the two base metals:

Property ZG1Cr18Ni12Mo2Ti ZG0Cr17Ni4Cu4Nb
Carbon content High (0.12% max) Low (0.07% max)
Corrosion resistance Susceptible to intergranular corrosion Good, precipitation-hardening
Sensitization risk High Low
Hardfacing bond Failed after 3 months Intact after 1 year

The change to ZG0Cr17Ni4Cu4Nb also provides the advantage of higher strength and hardness, which improves the wear resistance of the blade. The precipitation-hardening treatment, which involves solution annealing and aging, can be applied to achieve the desired mechanical properties.

Field Validation and Long-Term Performance

The improved spiral blade was put into service and monitored for over a year. The results were excellent: the hardfacing layer remained intact, and the blade showed no signs of corrosion or wear. The service life of the spiral blade was significantly extended, resulting in reduced downtime and lower maintenance costs.

The success of this improvement demonstrates the importance of considering the entire system, not just the hardfacing material. The base metal must be compatible with both the service environment and the hardfacing process. The failure in this case was not a defect in the hardfacing, but a fundamental mismatch between the base metal and the service conditions. By selecting a more appropriate base metal and optimizing the hardfacing process, the problem was solved.

Conclusion

The study by Pan Hongliang and colleagues is a textbook example of failure analysis leading to a practical and effective solution. The root cause of the hardfacing detachment was identified as intergranular corrosion of the base metal, caused by the high carbon content of the original material. By changing the base metal to a low-carbon precipitation-hardening stainless steel and optimizing the hardfacing process, the service life of the spiral blade was extended from three months to over a year. This case highlights the importance of considering the compatibility between the base metal, the hardfacing material, and the service environment. For engineers involved in the design and maintenance of hardfaced components, this study serves as a reminder that the base metal is just as important as the hardfacing layer. The next step for the industry should be to develop a standard methodology for selecting base metals and hardfacing materials for corrosive and abrasive service conditions.