Plasma Surfacing of Different Powders on F51 Duplex Stainless Steel: Microstructure and Hardness
Literature Overview and Core Significance
This 2023 study by He Tao and colleagues from Wuzhong Instrument Co., Ltd. and Dalian University of Technology investigates plasma surfacing of Co106F, Co112F, and Ni55 powders on F51 duplex stainless steel (UNS S31803). The work is directly relevant to the control valve industry, where duplex stainless steel components often require hardfacing to resist wear, corrosion, and galling on sealing surfaces. From my perspective in the pipe and fitting industry, this is the same class of problem we face when hardfacing valve seats, pipe flanges, and pump components in duplex stainless steel systems. The study examines the microstructure and hardness of the surfacing layers, with particular attention to element diffusion across the interface and the effect of different powder chemistries.
Key Technical Points and Process Parameters
The study uses plasma transferred arc (PTA) surfacing, which is a precision process that produces a low-dilution, high-quality deposit. The three powders are:
| Powder | Nominal Composition | Hardness Ratio to Base Metal | Microstructure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Co106F | Cobalt-based, Cr-W-C type | 1.5× | Dendritic |
| Co112F | Cobalt-based, higher W and C | 1.6× | Dendritic |
| Ni55 | Nickel-based, Ni-Cr-B-Si type | 1.62× | Dense, with columnar crystals at layer interface |
The base metal is F51 duplex stainless steel, which has a two-phase microstructure of ferrite and austenite. The key findings are:
- Co106F and Co112F deposits show similar dendritic microstructures with no significant morphological difference. The dendrites are typical of cobalt-based hardfacing alloys, with primary dendrites of cobalt solid solution and interdendritic carbides and Laves phases.
- Ni55 deposits show a more compact, dense microstructure. At the interface between the first and second surfacing layers, disordered columnar crystals appear, attributed to undercooling during the deposition of the second layer.
- The hardness ratios are 1.5×, 1.6×, and 1.62× for Co106F, Co112F, and Ni55 respectively. The surface hardness is lowest for Co106F and highest for Ni55.
Process Analysis and Metallurgical Considerations
The PTA process is a key factor in the quality of these deposits. Unlike conventional TIG or MIG surfacing, PTA uses a transferred arc that melts the powder and the substrate simultaneously, creating a strong metallurgical bond with minimal dilution. The dilution rate in PTA is typically 5–10%, compared to 20–30% for TIG and 30–50% for MIG. This low dilution is critical for maintaining the hardfacing alloy's properties, as excessive base metal mixing would dilute the carbide-forming elements and reduce hardness.
The dendritic microstructure of the cobalt-based alloys is a classic solidification structure. The primary dendrites form first, growing in the direction of the thermal gradient. The interdendritic regions are enriched with chromium, tungsten, and carbon, which precipitate as carbides and Laves phases during cooling. These hard phases provide the wear resistance, while the cobalt matrix provides toughness and galling resistance.
The Ni55 deposit's denser microstructure is attributed to the different solidification behavior of nickel-based alloys. Nickel has a face-centered cubic (FCC) crystal structure, which promotes a more equiaxed grain structure. The columnar crystals at the layer interface are a result of the second layer being deposited on the first layer, which acts as a substrate with a different thermal conductivity. The undercooling at the interface promotes directional solidification, creating the columnar structure.
The element diffusion analysis (line scanning) is critical for understanding the interface quality. The study shows that the diffusion zone is narrow, indicating a clean metallurgical bond with no significant intermetallic compound formation. This is essential for preventing cracking and delamination in service.
Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned
In the control valve industry, hardfacing on duplex stainless steel components is common for valve seats and stems. The valve seat must resist erosion from high-velocity fluid, corrosion from the process medium, and galling from repeated opening and closing. The choice of hardfacing alloy depends on the service conditions:
- Co106F: Used for moderate wear and corrosion resistance, with good toughness. Suitable for valves in general service.
- Co112F: Higher hardness and wear resistance, but lower toughness. Suitable for valves in abrasive service.
- Ni55: Highest hardness, good corrosion resistance, and excellent galling resistance. Suitable for valves in severe service where both wear and corrosion are present.
In my experience with pipe and fitting hardfacing, the choice between cobalt-based and nickel-based alloys is often a cost-performance trade-off. Cobalt-based alloys are more expensive but offer better high-temperature strength and galling resistance. Nickel-based alloys are less expensive and offer good corrosion resistance but may not perform as well at elevated temperatures.
The study's finding that Ni55 has the highest hardness is interesting because nickel-based alloys are typically not as hard as cobalt-based alloys. The high hardness of Ni55 is likely due to the presence of boron and silicon, which form hard borides and silicides in the microstructure. These hard phases, combined with the dense microstructure, contribute to the overall hardness.
Key Questions and Reflections
- Why is the microstructure of Ni55 more compact than the cobalt-based alloys? The answer lies in the solidification behavior. Nickel-based alloys have a narrower solidification range, which promotes a more equiaxed, fine-grained structure. Cobalt-based alloys have a wider solidification range, which promotes dendritic growth.
- What is the significance of the columnar crystals at the layer interface? This indicates that the second layer was deposited with a different thermal condition than the first layer. The first layer was deposited on the base metal, which acts as a heat sink. The second layer was deposited on the first layer, which is already at an elevated temperature, reducing the cooling rate and promoting columnar growth. This is not necessarily a defect, but it does indicate that the interface may have different properties than the bulk of the deposit.
- How does this translate to pipe and fitting applications? For pipe fittings in duplex stainless steel systems, hardfacing is often applied on sealing surfaces, such as flange faces and valve seats. The choice of powder depends on the service conditions. In offshore oil and gas, where duplex stainless steel is common, nickel-based hardfacing is often preferred because of its corrosion resistance and lower cost compared to cobalt-based alloys.
Study Insights and Implications for Practice
This study provides valuable data for engineers selecting hardfacing powders for duplex stainless steel components. The key takeaways are:
- Plasma surfacing produces high-quality deposits with low dilution. This is essential for maintaining the hardfacing alloy's properties and ensuring a strong metallurgical bond.
- The choice of powder significantly affects microstructure and hardness. Cobalt-based alloys produce dendritic structures with good toughness, while nickel-based alloys produce denser structures with higher hardness.
- The hardness ratio to base metal is a useful metric for selection. A ratio of 1.5–1.6× is typical for cobalt-based alloys, while nickel-based alloys can achieve 1.6× or higher.
- Element diffusion at the interface is minimal, indicating a clean bond. This is critical for preventing cracking and delamination in service.
Reference Value and Outlook
This study is a valuable reference for any engineer involved in hardfacing duplex stainless steel components. The data on microstructure, hardness, and element diffusion provides a solid foundation for powder selection and process optimization.
For the pipe and fitting industry, the next step would be to investigate the corrosion resistance and wear behavior of these deposits in actual service conditions. The study focuses on microstructure and hardness, but the real-world performance depends on the interaction between the hardfacing layer and the process medium.
The broader lesson is that hardfacing is a specialized field that requires careful consideration of the base material, the hardfacing alloy, the process, and the service conditions. This study demonstrates that plasma surfacing is a viable method for applying high-quality hardfacing on duplex stainless steel, and that the choice of powder has a significant impact on the resulting properties. In my experience, this is the kind of detailed, fundamental research that provides the data needed to make informed engineering decisions on the plant floor.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd