ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Microstructure and Microhardness of Hardfacing Metal on 45 Steel

Core Findings and Alloy Element Effects

The study by Zhang Youyi and colleagues examined the microstructure and microhardness of hardfacing layers deposited on 45 steel using two different electrodes: D237 and D207. The key conclusion is that the microstructure and hardness of the hardfacing metal are influenced by welding heat input, the alloy composition of the electrode, and the type, properties, and distribution of hard phases. Specifically, the alloying elements molybdenum (Mo) and vanadium (V) have a pronounced grain-refining effect on the hardfacing metal.

This is a practical finding because 45 steel is a common substrate for shafts, gears, and structural components that require surface repair or wear-resistant overlays. The choice of electrode determines not only the hardness but also the service performance of the repaired component. D237 is a Cr-Mo-V alloy electrode, while D207 is a Cr-Mn-Si alloy electrode. The difference in alloying philosophy leads to different microstructures and hardness levels.

Microstructure and Hardness Analysis

The paper reports that the hardfacing layer from D237 exhibits finer grains and higher hardness than that from D207 under the same welding conditions. This is attributed to the combined effect of Mo and V, which form fine carbides and nitrides that pin grain boundaries and promote heterogeneous nucleation during solidification. The microstructure of the D237 hardfacing metal is typically martensitic with dispersed carbides, while the D207 hardfacing metal tends to be more ferritic or bainitic with less pronounced hard phase precipitation.

Electrode Alloy System Typical Hardness (HRC) Microstructure Key Alloying Elements
D237 Cr-Mo-V 45–55 Martensite + fine carbides Mo, V promote grain refinement
D207 Cr-Mn-Si 35–45 Bainite/ferrite + carbides Mn, Si provide solid solution strengthening

The study also notes that welding heat input significantly affects the hardness. Higher heat input leads to a coarser microstructure and lower hardness due to slower cooling rates and increased grain growth. This is a critical parameter in practice, because it means that the welder must control travel speed and interpass temperature to achieve the desired hardness and microstructure.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

In our shop, we have used D237 and D207 electrodes for repair welding of shafts and gear teeth made from 45 steel. The practical lesson is that the electrode selection must match the service requirements. For components that require high wear resistance and moderate impact toughness, D237 is the better choice. For components that require more ductility and resistance to cracking, D207 may be more suitable.

One of the most common failures we have encountered is cracking in the hardfacing layer when the substrate is not properly preheated. 45 steel has a carbon content of approximately 0.45%, which places it in the medium-carbon range. This means that the heat-affected zone (HAZ) can become martensitic and susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking if the preheat is inadequate. The paper does not address this directly, but it is a critical practical consideration. We typically preheat 45 steel to 150–250 °C before hardfacing and maintain an interpass temperature of 200–300 °C.

Another practical issue is dilution. When hardfacing on 45 steel, the carbon from the substrate can dilute into the hardfacing layer, increasing its carbon content and hardness but also increasing its susceptibility to cracking. This is particularly important when using D207, which has a lower alloy content and is more sensitive to dilution.

Summary and Outlook

This study provides a useful comparison of two commonly used hardfacing electrodes and highlights the role of alloying elements in controlling microstructure and hardness. For the steel pipe and fitting industry, where hardfacing is used on shafts, valve stems, and other components, the choice of electrode must be based on the service conditions and the substrate material. The grain-refining effect of Mo and V is a valuable tool for improving the performance of hardfacing layers, but it must be balanced against the risk of cracking and the need for proper preheat and interpass control. Future work should focus on the effect of dilution on hardfacing properties and on the development of electrode specifications that are more forgiving of process variations.