ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Hydrogen Effects on Plasticity and Toughness of Stainless Steel Electroslag Hardfacing Layers

Core Content and Literature Significance

This paper by Liu Hang and colleagues from the Central Iron and Steel Research Institute addresses a critical issue in the fabrication of hydrogenation reactors. These vessels operate at high hydrogen partial pressures and elevated temperatures. The internal surface is often protected by a stainless steel hardfacing layer, which is applied using the electroslag welding process. The hardfacing layer must resist hydrogen attack, but the hydrogen itself can embrittle the layer.

The authors simulated the service conditions of a hydrogenation reactor by charging the hardfacing layer with hydrogen at 17.5 MPa and 450°C. The material was 00Cr20Ni10Nb, which is a niobium-stabilized stainless steel. This is a common choice for hydrogenation reactor overlays because the niobium stabilizes the carbon and prevents sensitization.

The results are clear: hydrogen charging reduces the fracture toughness and significantly degrades the plasticity and toughness of the hardfacing layer. In the face bend test, the hydrogen-charged specimens cracked at small angles, and the fracture surface showed a brittle quasi-cleavage morphology with numerous secondary cracks. The microcracks were distributed along the delta/gamma phase boundaries.

The most important finding is that the hydrogen embrittlement can be reversed. A de-hydrogenation treatment at 630°C for 4 hours eliminated the embrittlement and restored the plasticity and toughness. This is a practical solution for the shop floor.

Technical Points and Metallurgical Interpretation

The electroslag hardfacing layer has a duplex microstructure consisting of delta ferrite and austenite. The delta/gamma phase boundaries are the weak points. Hydrogen tends to accumulate at these interfaces, and when the material is stressed, the hydrogen promotes decohesion along the boundaries.

The mechanism is well known in the literature. Hydrogen reduces the cohesive strength of the metal lattice and promotes the formation of hydrides or the accumulation of hydrogen at stress concentrators. The delta/gamma phase boundaries are particularly susceptible because they are sites of high local stress and high hydrogen solubility.

The fracture morphology is typical of hydrogen embrittlement. The quasi-cleavage appearance with secondary cracks indicates that the fracture path follows the phase boundaries. The small-angle cracking in the face bend test is a clear sign that the material has lost its ductility.

The de-hydrogenation treatment at 630°C for 4 hours is effective because it allows the hydrogen to diffuse out of the material. The temperature is high enough to give the hydrogen sufficient mobility, but not so high that it causes other microstructural changes. The 4-hour time is sufficient for the hydrogen to escape from the hardfacing layer, which is relatively thin.

It is important to note that the de-hydrogenation treatment must be done before the component is put into service. If the hydrogen is already in the material and the component is stressed, the embrittlement can cause cracking. The treatment is a preventive measure, not a repair.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

This paper is directly relevant to the fabrication of hydrogenation reactors. In my experience, the hardfacing of these vessels is a critical operation. The electroslag process is used because it gives a high deposition rate and a low dilution, which is important for maintaining the corrosion resistance of the overlay.

The problem of hydrogen embrittlement in hardfacing layers is often underestimated. The hydrogen can come from several sources. The welding process itself can introduce hydrogen, especially if the consumables are not properly dried. The service environment, with high hydrogen partial pressure, can also introduce hydrogen over time.

The paper shows that the hydrogen embrittlement is reversible, but this is only true if the hydrogen has not caused any permanent damage. If the material has already cracked, the de-hydrogenation treatment will not heal the cracks. The treatment must be applied before the component is stressed.

There is a practical issue with the de-hydrogenation treatment. The temperature of 630°C is within the sensitization range for some stainless steels. For a niobium-stabilized steel like 00Cr20Ni10Nb, sensitization is less of a concern because the niobium ties up the carbon. But for other stainless steels, the treatment could cause chromium carbide precipitation, which would reduce the corrosion resistance.

The paper does not address the effect of the de-hydrogenation treatment on the mechanical properties of the substrate. In a hydrogenation reactor, the hardfacing is applied to a low-alloy steel substrate. A 630°C treatment could affect the properties of the substrate, especially if the substrate is in a quenched and tempered condition.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that the paper raises is the threshold hydrogen concentration for embrittlement. The authors charged the material with hydrogen at 17.5 MPa and 450°C, which is a severe condition. In practice, the hydrogen concentration in the hardfacing layer will depend on the operating conditions and the time in service. The paper does not provide a threshold, but it does show that the effect is significant at the conditions tested.

Another question is the effect of the delta ferrite content on the susceptibility to hydrogen embrittlement. The delta/gamma phase boundaries are the weak points, so a higher delta ferrite content might increase the susceptibility. However, delta ferrite is also beneficial for preventing hot cracking during welding. There is a trade-off between weldability and hydrogen resistance.

The de-hydrogenation treatment is a practical solution, but it adds time and cost to the fabrication process. In a large vessel, the treatment might require a separate furnace cycle. The question is whether the treatment is always necessary or only for certain service conditions.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a classic example of the importance of understanding the interaction between the service environment and the material. The hardfacing layer is designed to resist corrosion, but the hydrogen in the environment can embrittle it. The solution is not just to choose a better material, but to understand the entire service condition.

For the fabrication shop, the key takeaway is that hydrogen control is essential. The welding consumables must be dry, the process must be controlled to minimize hydrogen pickup, and the component must be de-hydrogenated before it is put into service. This is especially important for hydrogenation reactors, where the consequences of failure are severe.

The paper also highlights the importance of the face bend test as a quality control tool. This test is sensitive to hydrogen embrittlement and can detect the problem before the component is put into service. A standard bend test on a hydrogen-charged specimen can reveal the embrittlement, even if the tensile properties look acceptable.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper is from 1999, but the principles are still relevant. Hydrogen embrittlement of stainless steel overlays is still a concern in hydrogenation reactors and other high-pressure hydrogen service. The de-hydrogenation treatment is still used in practice, although the parameters may be adjusted based on the specific material and geometry.

One area where more work is needed is the effect of hydrogen on the long-term properties of the hardfacing layer. The paper looks at the short-term effect after charging. In service, the hydrogen concentration may reach a steady state, and the material may be exposed to hydrogen for years. The long-term effect may be different from the short-term effect.

Another area is the effect of the welding process on the hydrogen content of the hardfacing layer. The electroslag process has a different hydrogen behavior than other welding processes. The flux, the current, and the voltage all affect the hydrogen pickup. The paper does not address this directly, but it is an important factor in practice.

In summary, this paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the fabrication of hydrogenation reactors or other equipment for high-pressure hydrogen service. It provides a clear demonstration of the hydrogen embrittlement mechanism and offers a practical solution in the form of the de-hydrogenation treatment. The lessons learned here apply not just to electroslag hardfacing, but to any stainless steel overlay in hydrogen service. The key is to understand the interaction between the material, the welding process, and the service environment, and to control all three.