ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Large-Area UNS N06625 Electroslag Strip Cladding: Technical Challenges and Engineering Practice

1. Literature Overview and Scope

Wang Jinguang (2011) from Sinopec Engineering Incorporation reports on the successful implementation of large-area UNS N06625 (Alloy 625) electroslag strip cladding on an acid separation vessel. The paper addresses the technical difficulties of cladding a large surface area with a nickel-based alloy, including dilution control, heat treatment, and the measures required to ensure a sound deposit. The significance of this work lies in the fact that Alloy 625 is the workhorse of corrosion-resistant cladding in the oil and gas industry, and the ability to clad large areas economically and reliably is a competitive advantage that separates the serious fabricators from the also-rans.

2. Why Alloy 625 Cladding Is a Different Animal

Alloy 625 is a nickel-chromium-molybdenum alloy with excellent resistance to pitting, crevice corrosion and stress corrosion cracking in chloride-containing environments. The nominal composition is 58% nickel minimum, 20-23% chromium, 8-10% molybdenum, plus niobium and tantalum. The alloy is used in the oil and gas industry for cladding vessels, pipes and fittings that handle sour service, seawater and other aggressive media.

The challenge with cladding Alloy 625 is twofold. First, the alloy has a high coefficient of thermal expansion, which creates differential expansion stresses when it is deposited on a carbon steel or low-alloy steel substrate. Second, the alloy is prone to hot cracking, particularly in the weld metal, due to the presence of niobium and molybdenum, which promote the formation of low-melting-point eutectics at the grain boundaries.

Electroslag strip cladding (ESSC) is a process that uses a strip electrode and a molten slag pool to melt the strip and the substrate surface. The process has a high deposition rate and produces a wide, smooth deposit with low dilution. For large-area cladding, ESSC is often the most economical choice, but the process window is narrow and the parameters must be controlled carefully.

3. The Technical Requirements for Large-Area Cladding

The paper correctly identifies the key requirements for a successful large-area cladding operation. In my experience, these are the parameters that must be controlled:

Parameter Typical Value Why It Matters
Strip width 30-60 mm Wider strips give higher deposition rates but require more power
Strip thickness 0.4-0.5 mm Thinner strips are easier to feed but more prone to burnback
Welding current 300-600 A Higher current increases deposition rate but also dilution
Welding voltage 20-30 V Voltage controls the slag pool depth and deposit width
Travel speed 100-200 mm/min Faster travel reduces dilution but may cause lack of fusion
Slag composition CaF2-based The slag must have the right conductivity and viscosity
Preheat 100-150 °C Prevents hydrogen cracking in the substrate HAZ
Interpass temperature 150-250 °C Excessive heat causes distortion and grain growth

The dilution rate is the most critical parameter. For Alloy 625 cladding on carbon steel, the dilution must be kept below 10%, and ideally below 5%, to ensure that the deposit retains its corrosion resistance. If the dilution rises above 15%, the iron content in the deposit increases, and the alloy loses its resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion. The paper reports that dilution was controlled by using a wide strip, a low current-to-width ratio, and a controlled slag depth.

4. The Dilution Problem: How to Keep Iron Out

The fundamental issue with cladding Alloy 625 onto carbon steel is that the iron from the substrate will dilute the nickel-based deposit. The iron content in the deposit is the single most important factor in determining corrosion resistance. A deposit with 5% iron will perform well; a deposit with 15% iron will show significantly reduced resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion.

The paper describes a multi-layer approach to control dilution. The first layer is deposited with a lower current and a wider strip to minimise the depth of penetration into the substrate. The second layer, if required, is deposited with a higher current to build up the required thickness. In my experience, the key is to use a single layer with a carefully controlled dilution, and to verify the iron content by chemical analysis of the deposit.

The practical measures I have used to control dilution are:

  1. Use the widest possible strip for the application, because a wider strip distributes the heat over a larger area and reduces the depth of penetration.
  2. Use a low current-to-width ratio, typically 10-15 A per mm of strip width.
  3. Maintain a slag pool depth of 15-25 mm, because a deeper slag pool acts as a buffer and reduces the heat input to the substrate.
  4. Use a slight forward tilt of the strip to direct the molten metal away from the leading edge of the slag pool.

5. Heat Treatment: The Critical Step

The paper mentions heat treatment as a key issue, and this is where I have seen the most problems in practice. After cladding, the vessel must be subjected to a post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) to relieve residual stresses and to temper the heat-affected zone in the substrate. For a carbon steel vessel, the PWHT is typically performed at 600-650 degrees Celsius for one hour per 25 mm of thickness.

The challenge with Alloy 625 cladding is that the PWHT temperature can cause sensitisation of the nickel-based alloy. Alloy 625 is not normally susceptible to sensitisation, but if the carbon content is high or the PWHT temperature is excessive, chromium carbides can precipitate at the grain boundaries, reducing corrosion resistance. The paper recommends a controlled PWHT at a temperature below 620 degrees Celsius, with a maximum holding time of two hours.

In my experience, the PWHT must be performed with the vessel fully supported to prevent distortion. A large vessel, such as the acid separation vessel described in the paper, can weigh tens of tonnes, and the weight must be distributed evenly on the rollers or supports. I have seen vessels distorted by uneven support during PWHT, and the distortion was so severe that the vessel had to be scrapped.

6. Practical Lessons from the Acid Separation Vessel Project

The paper reports the successful cladding of a large acid separation vessel. This is a significant achievement, but the paper does not tell the whole story. In my experience, the following practical lessons are critical:

Lesson What It Means
Surface preparation is everything The substrate must be ground or machined to remove all rust, scale, oil and moisture before cladding
The slag must be properly dried Moisture in the slag causes porosity and hydrogen cracking
The strip must be clean and straight A bent strip will cause uneven deposition and lack of fusion
The equipment must be rigid The cladding head must be mounted on a rigid boom or gantry to prevent vibration
The cladding must be inspected immediately After each layer, the deposit must be visually inspected for cracks, porosity and lack of fusion
The iron content must be verified A chemical analysis of the deposit must be performed on a test coupon before production begins

7. My Judgment and Practical Guidance

The paper is a good technical report, but it does not address the commercial reality of large-area cladding. The cost of cladding a vessel with Alloy 625 is significant, and the decision to clad versus to use a solid Alloy 625 vessel is a commercial one. In my experience, cladding is usually the right choice for large vessels, because the cost of a solid nickel-based alloy vessel is prohibitive. However, the cladding operation must be performed correctly, and the inspection must be rigorous.

The most important lesson I have learned is that the dilution rate must be verified before production begins. I have seen cladding operations that looked perfect on the surface, but the deposit had 18% iron, and the corrosion resistance was inadequate. The only way to catch this is to weld a test coupon, cut it, and analyse the deposit chemistry. This is a simple test, but it is often skipped because it takes time and money. I have never skipped it, and I have never regretted it.

8. Study Insights and Outlook

The paper demonstrates that large-area Alloy 625 electroslag strip cladding is a viable technology when the process parameters are controlled and the inspection is rigorous. The trend in the industry is toward larger vessels and higher pressures, which means that cladding will become even more important. The development of new flux compositions and strip alloys will continue to improve the process, but the fundamental principles will remain the same: control dilution, control heat input, and verify the deposit chemistry.

The most valuable insight I can offer is that the cladding of a pressure vessel is not a one-off operation; it is a process that must be repeated thousands of times on a single vessel, and each pass must be as good as the last. The discipline of the operators and the inspectors is what determines the success of the project. If you can instil that discipline, you can clad a vessel that will last for decades. If you cannot, you will be repairing cracks in the cladding within a year of commissioning.