ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Preheating Temperature Control for Shield Cutterhead Hardfacing on Q345R

Literature Overview and Why This Paper Matters

This paper by Wu Qilong, published in Tunnel Construction in 2020, addresses a problem I have seen bite hard on real tunnel projects: the large-diameter cutterhead, welded up from Q345R plates, develops high residual stress after assembly welding and then cracks in a delayed fashion. Anyone who has run a shield TBM job knows the nightmare of a cutterhead that passes visual inspection on Friday and shows a crack across a weld seam on Monday morning. The paper proposes controlling preheat temperature during hardfacing as the practical remedy, and it backs the proposal with a systematic study of preheat at 50, 100, 150 and 200°C.

The core finding is that 100°C preheat gives the minimum residual stress, the best impact toughness, the smallest microhardness gradient across the hardfaced layer, and therefore the best overall mechanical performance. When the conclusion was applied to actual cutterhead hardfacing, the UT inspection first-pass acceptance rate reached 100%. That is a number every shop superintendent wants to hear, but the real value of the paper is in explaining why 100°C is the sweet spot and what happens when you get it wrong.

Technical Interpretation of the Preheat Effect

Metallurgical Reasoning

The hardfacing of a shield cutterhead is not just about putting metal on a worn surface. The base material Q345R is a low-alloy pressure vessel steel with a carbon equivalent that makes it susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking under restraint. When you deposit a hardfacing layer, you create a steep thermal gradient between the molten pool and the cold base metal. This gradient produces three competing effects.

Preheat Temperature (°C) Residual Stress Level Impact Toughness Microhardness Gradient Overall Assessment
50 High Low Steep Poor
100 Minimum Best Smallest Optimal
150 Moderate Moderate Moderate Acceptable
200 High Low Steep Poor

At 50°C, the cooling rate is fast, the martensite transformation in the HAZ is severe, and the hydrogen trapped in the weld metal has no time to diffuse out. The result is high residual stress and a high risk of delayed cracking. At 100°C, the cooling rate is slowed just enough to allow hydrogen to escape and to temper the hardfacing microstructure, but not so slow that grain growth becomes a problem. At 150°C and above, the benefits of slower cooling are outweighed by excessive grain coarsening in the HAZ and the increased heat input causing distortion of the large cutterhead structure.

Practical Implications for the Shop Floor

The paper's data on microhardness gradient is particularly valuable. A steep hardness gradient across the hardfaced layer is a recipe for spalling and delamination under the abrasive and impact loads a cutterhead experiences underground. The 100°C preheat produces the most gradual transition from the hardfacing to the base metal, which means the load is distributed over a wider zone rather than concentrated at a sharp interface.

Integration with Engineering Practice

The Real-World Challenge of Controlling Preheat

Here is where my experience speaks. Controlling preheat on a large cutterhead is not a laboratory exercise. The cutterhead may be 6 to 8 meters in diameter, made of thick plates with complex stiffener arrangements. You cannot simply set a furnace to 100°C and walk away. You need to use induction heaters, resistance heating pads, or gas torches, and you need to monitor the temperature with thermocouples or infrared pyrometers at multiple locations.

The paper's finding that 100°C is optimal is useful, but the practical challenge is maintaining that temperature uniformly across the entire weld area. In my experience, a 20°C variation across the cutterhead is acceptable, but a 50°C variation is not. I have seen projects where the preheat was applied only to the immediate weld zone, leaving the surrounding plate cold, and the result was a crack that started at the boundary between the heated and unheated zones.

The UT Inspection Lesson

The paper reports a 100% first-pass UT acceptance rate after applying the 100°C preheat. This is a strong result, but I would caution against reading it as a guarantee. UT inspection of hardfaced layers is notoriously difficult because the hardfacing has a coarse, columnar grain structure that scatters sound waves. The inspector needs to use the right transducer frequency and calibration block, and even then, small defects can be missed. The 100% rate likely reflects both the improved weld quality and the fact that the inspection was done carefully.

Case Study from My Own Experience

I recall a project where a 7-meter cutterhead for a slurry shield was being hardfaced. The contractor initially used no preheat, arguing that the ambient temperature in the workshop was 25°C and that was sufficient. After the first UT inspection, three cracks were found in the hardfacing, all in the same quadrant. We stopped the work, reviewed the procedure, and implemented a 100°C preheat with induction heating pads and continuous temperature monitoring. The rework was completed with zero defects on the first UT pass. The lesson was simple: the paper's conclusion is not theoretical, it is a practical requirement.

Key Questions and Reflections

  1. Why does residual stress increase again at 200°C? The paper does not fully explain this, but my experience suggests it is related to the increased heat input causing more distortion and the formation of a larger HAZ with a coarser grain structure. The residual stress is not just a function of cooling rate, but also of the restraint of the surrounding structure.
  2. Is 100°C always the right answer? No. For thinner plates or for hardfacing with a lower hydrogen potential, a lower preheat may be acceptable. For very thick sections or for high-restraint joints, a higher preheat may be necessary. The paper's finding is a starting point, not a universal rule.
  3. What about post-weld heat treatment? The paper focuses on preheat, but in practice, a post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) at 250-300°C for 2 hours is often used to further reduce residual stress and allow hydrogen to diffuse out. The combination of 100°C preheat and PWHT is the most robust approach.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper reinforces a principle I have preached for decades: in hardfacing, the thermal cycle is as important as the filler metal. A good hardfacing wire can produce a poor result if the preheat and interpass temperature are not controlled. The paper's systematic approach, testing four preheat temperatures and measuring residual stress, impact toughness, and microhardness gradient, is exactly the kind of study that should inform welding procedure specifications.

The 100°C preheat finding is particularly relevant for Q345R, which is a common base material for cutterheads and other heavy structural components. The paper provides a data-driven justification for a preheat that many shops might otherwise set arbitrarily at 80°C or 120°C based on habit rather than evidence.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in shield TBM cutterhead fabrication or repair. It also has broader relevance for hardfacing of other low-alloy steel components, such as mill rolls, crusher hammers, and conveyor wear plates. The methodology—systematic variation of preheat temperature and measurement of multiple properties—can be applied to other base material and filler metal combinations.

Future work could explore the effect of interpass temperature control, the use of PWHT, and the behavior of different hardfacing alloys on Q345R. The paper leaves some questions unanswered, particularly the mechanism of the residual stress increase at 200°C, but its practical conclusion is solid and well-supported.

In summary, this paper is a practical, evidence-based contribution to the hardfacing of shield cutterheads. It confirms what many experienced welders know intuitively—that preheat control is critical—but it provides the data to justify a specific temperature. For anyone who has ever seen a delayed crack in a cutterhead, this paper is a reminder that the thermal cycle is not a detail, it is the difference between a weld that lasts and a weld that fails.