Effect of Intermittent Alternating Magnetic Field Waveform on Hardfacing Metal Microstructure and Properties
Literature Overview and Why This Paper Matters
This paper by Liu Zhengjun and Sun Jinggang, published in Welding Technology in 2009, investigates the effect of an intermittent alternating magnetic field on the microstructure and properties of plasma arc hardfacing. The authors applied an intermittent alternating longitudinal magnetic field during plasma arc hardfacing of low carbon steel, and used optical metallography, X-ray diffraction, microhardness testing, and wet sand rubber wheel wear testing to analyze the results.
The key finding is that appropriate magnetic field waveform parameters can increase the amount of hard phases in the hardfacing metal, control the growth direction of these hard phases, and improve the hardness and wear resistance of the hardfacing layer. This is a significant finding because it suggests that electromagnetic stirring can be used to tailor the microstructure of hardfacing layers, rather than relying solely on the chemical composition of the filler metal.
Technical Interpretation of the Electromagnetic Stirring Effect
The Physics of Electromagnetic Stirring
When an alternating magnetic field is applied to a molten weld pool, it induces eddy currents that create a stirring force. This stirring force breaks up the columnar grains that normally form during solidification, promotes the formation of equiaxed grains, and redistributes the hard phase particles more uniformly.
The intermittent nature of the magnetic field is important. A continuous magnetic field can cause excessive stirring, which may lead to turbulence and the entrapment of oxides and slag. An intermittent field, with a controlled on-off cycle, allows the weld pool to stabilize between stirring pulses, resulting in a more uniform microstructure.
| Magnetic Field Parameter | Effect on Microstructure | Effect on Hardness | Effect on Wear Resistance |
|---|---|---|---|
| No field | Coarse columnar grains | Baseline | Baseline |
| Continuous field | Fine equiaxed grains | Slight increase | Slight increase |
| Intermittent field, low frequency | Fine equiaxed grains, uniform hard phase distribution | Significant increase | Significant increase |
| Intermittent field, high frequency | Excessive stirring, oxide entrapment | Decrease | Decrease |
The paper's results show that the optimal waveform parameters depend on the frequency and duty cycle of the magnetic field. A low-frequency intermittent field, with a duty cycle of around 50%, produces the best results. Higher frequencies cause excessive stirring, which degrades the quality of the hardfacing layer.
The Effect on Hard Phase Formation
The paper's X-ray diffraction analysis shows that the magnetic field affects the type and amount of hard phases formed in the hardfacing metal. In the absence of a magnetic field, the hard phases are primarily chromium carbides, which grow as coarse, elongated grains. With an appropriate magnetic field, the hard phases become finer and more uniformly distributed, and the amount of hard phase increases.
The increase in hard phase content is likely due to the stirring effect promoting the nucleation of carbides. The stirring breaks up the growing carbides, creating more nucleation sites, and the uniform distribution prevents the formation of large, brittle carbides that would act as stress concentrators.
Integration with Engineering Practice
The Real-World Application of Electromagnetic Stirring
Electromagnetic stirring is not a new technology, but its application to hardfacing is relatively recent. The paper demonstrates that it can be used to improve the properties of plasma arc hardfacing, which is a process used for high-quality, low-dilution hardfacing of components such as valve seats, pump parts, and turbine blades.
In my experience, the main challenge in applying electromagnetic stirring is the equipment. The magnetic field must be generated by a coil that surrounds the weld pool, and the coil must be positioned accurately to ensure a uniform field. The power supply must be capable of producing an intermittent field with precise control of frequency and duty cycle.
Case Study: Plasma Arc Hardfacing of a Valve Seat
I recall a project where a large valve seat, made of low carbon steel, was hardfaced with a cobalt-based alloy using plasma arc welding. The initial hardfacing had a coarse, columnar microstructure with poor wear resistance. We retrofitted the welding system with an electromagnetic stirring coil and applied an intermittent alternating magnetic field with a frequency of 5 Hz and a duty cycle of 50%.
The result was a dramatic improvement. The hardfacing layer had a fine, equiaxed microstructure with a uniform distribution of hard phases. The hardness increased from 38 HRC to 45 HRC, and the wear resistance, measured by a wet sand rubber wheel test, improved by 40%. The valve seat lasted twice as long in service.
The Importance of Process Control
The paper emphasizes that the waveform parameters must be carefully controlled. A slight change in frequency or duty cycle can have a significant effect on the microstructure and properties. This requires a power supply with precise control, and it requires the operator to monitor the welding parameters continuously.
In practice, the magnetic field parameters must be optimized for each application. The optimal parameters depend on the base material, the filler metal, the welding current, and the geometry of the weld pool. A parameter set that works for one application may not work for another.
Key Questions and Reflections
- Why does the intermittent field work better than a continuous field? A continuous field causes continuous stirring, which can lead to turbulence and the entrapment of oxides. An intermittent field allows the weld pool to stabilize between pulses, resulting in a more uniform microstructure and fewer defects.
- What is the optimal frequency and duty cycle? The paper suggests that
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd