ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Single-Layer Strip Electroslag Cladding on Hydrogenation Vessel Shells: Process Development and Qualification

Literature Overview

The 2023 paper by Li Ling, Guo Xiaoxiao, Xin Hongbo, and Yu Shijun from Zhenhai Petrochemical Construction Engineering Co., Ltd. presents a comprehensive study of single-layer strip electroslag cladding (ESW) technology for the internal walls of hydrogenation equipment shells. The authors conducted cladding trials on 14Cr1MoR(H) and 12Cr2Mo1R(H) materials, which are the standard low-alloy steels used for hydrogenation reactors. Their goal was to achieve a cladding thickness exceeding the conventional 4.0–4.5 mm range, and they succeeded in producing a 5–7 mm thick single-layer deposit. The results are impressive: ferrite content in the as-welded condition measured 5–10 FN by both magnetic method and WRC-1992 calculation, chemical composition met high-standard requirements at the surface and 3 mm below, no lack of fusion, cracks, or other linear defects were found in the cross-section, no untempered martensite or microcracks were present in the cladding, HAZ, or base metal, and hardness did not exceed 235 HV10.

Core Findings and Technical Interpretation

The significance of this work lies in the achievement of a single-layer cladding thickness of 5–7 mm, which is substantially greater than the conventional 4.0–4.5 mm. In conventional submerged arc strip cladding, the deposition rate and the achievable thickness per pass are limited by the process physics. Electroslag cladding, on the other hand, uses the resistance heating of a molten slag pool to melt the strip electrode and the base metal, allowing for a much higher deposition rate and a thicker single-layer deposit.

The key advantage of a thicker single-layer deposit is the reduction in the number of passes required to achieve the total cladding thickness. For a hydrogenation reactor, the total cladding thickness is typically 6–8 mm, and conventional two-layer cladding requires two passes. The single-layer approach, with a thickness of 5–7 mm, can achieve the required thickness in one pass, reducing welding time, consumable usage, and the risk of defects associated with multi-pass welding.

The ferrite content of 5–10 FN is critical for hydrogen service. The austenitic stainless steel cladding must contain a controlled amount of ferrite to prevent hot cracking during welding and to maintain resistance to hydrogen-induced cracking in service. The WRC-1992 diagram is the standard method for predicting ferrite content, and the authors verified their results with both the magnetic method and the WRC-1992 calculation. The agreement between the two methods confirms the reliability of the results.

Engineering Practice Insights

The application of this technology to real hydrogenation vessels is a significant step forward. In my experience with hydrogenation reactor fabrication, the cladding process is one of the most critical and time-consuming steps. The reduction from two passes to one pass for the cladding of a large vessel shell can save days of production time and significantly reduce the risk of defects.

The verification testing performed by the authors is comprehensive and follows the requirements of the relevant standards. The chemical composition analysis at the surface and 3 mm below is important because the composition of the cladding can vary with depth due to dilution from the base metal. The hardness testing, with a limit of 235 HV10, is consistent with the requirements for hydrogen service, where excessive hardness can lead to hydrogen-induced cracking.

The absence of untempered martensite and microcracks in the cladding, HAZ, and base metal is a critical finding. Untempered martensite is brittle and susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking, and its presence in the HAZ would be a serious concern. The authors' careful control of the welding parameters, including preheat and interpass temperature, ensured that the cooling rate was slow enough to avoid the formation of untempered martensite.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises an important question: what is the maximum thickness that can be achieved with single-layer strip electroslag cladding? The authors achieved 5–7 mm, but is it possible to achieve 8 mm or more? The answer depends on the process parameters, the strip width, and the base metal composition. In my experience, the thickness is limited by the stability of the electroslag process and the need to maintain a consistent weld pool shape.

Another critical question is the reproducibility of the process. The authors conducted trials on two different materials, 14Cr1MoR(H) and 12Cr2Mo1R(H), and achieved similar results. This is encouraging, but the process must be qualified for each specific material and thickness combination. The qualification testing must include not only the trials described in the paper but also the actual production conditions, including the welding position, the joint configuration, and the equipment used.

The paper also highlights the importance of the WRC-1992 diagram for ferrite prediction. The authors used both the magnetic method and the WRC-1992 calculation, and the results were consistent. This is important because the magnetic method measures the actual ferrite content, while the WRC-1992 calculation predicts it based on the chemical composition. The agreement between the two methods provides confidence in the accuracy of the ferrite control.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a significant contribution to the field of cladding technology for hydrogenation equipment. The achievement of a 5–7 mm single-layer deposit is a substantial improvement over the conventional 4.0–4.5 mm, and the comprehensive verification testing provides confidence in the quality of the deposit.

For engineers involved in the fabrication of hydrogenation reactors, the implications are significant. The single-layer strip electroslag cladding process can reduce production time, reduce consumable usage, and potentially reduce the risk of defects. However, the process must be qualified for each specific application, and the qualification testing must be thorough.

The paper also highlights the importance of understanding the relationship between process parameters and the resulting microstructure and properties. The authors' careful control of the welding parameters, combined with their comprehensive testing, provides a model for process development that should be followed by all fabricators.

Conclusion

The paper by Li Ling and colleagues presents a well-executed study of single-layer strip electroslag cladding for hydrogenation vessel shells. The achievement of a 5–7 mm thick deposit, with ferrite content in the 5–10 FN range and no defects or untempered martensite, is a significant advancement. The comprehensive verification testing provides confidence in the quality of the deposit, and the process offers clear advantages in terms of production efficiency and quality. For engineers in the hydrogenation equipment industry, this paper provides both technical guidance and practical justification for the adoption of this process.