Self-Shielded Surfacing Technology for Raw Material Vertical Mills
Core Technical Points and Process Overview
The paper by Yang Wei, Zhang Haiyan, and Ni Junjie from the Zhengzhou Research Institute of Mechanical Engineering addresses a topic that is close to my heart: the repair of large grinding components in cement plants. Vertical mills, or vertical roller mills, are the workhorses of the cement industry, and their grinding rollers and table liners suffer from severe abrasive wear. The authors describe a self-shielded surfacing technology that can be used for both offline and online repair, which is a significant advantage in an industry where downtime is extremely costly.
Self-shielded surfacing, also known as open-arc hardfacing, uses flux-cored wire that generates its own shielding atmosphere through the decomposition of the flux core. This eliminates the need for external shielding gas, which simplifies the equipment and makes the process more flexible for field repairs. The authors note that this technology is "convenient and flexible," and I can attest to that from my own experience. In a cement plant, you often have to repair a grinding roller in place, without the ability to set up a gas-shielded welding station. Self-shielded wire allows you to do this with a simple wire feeder and a power source, even in a dusty, confined space.
The key technical points from the paper include the selection of the welding consumable, the process parameters, and the resulting microstructure. Self-shielded hardfacing wires typically contain high levels of carbon, chromium, and other alloying elements to produce a hard, wear-resistant deposit. The microstructure of the deposit is usually a martensitic or carbide-rich structure, depending on the alloy composition. The authors likely discuss the importance of controlling the dilution rate, which is the percentage of base metal melted into the deposit. High dilution can reduce the hardness and wear resistance of the surfacing layer, so the process must be carefully controlled.
Practical Implications for Cement Plant Maintenance
From a practical standpoint, this paper highlights several critical factors that determine the success of a hardfacing repair. The first is the condition of the base metal. Grinding rollers are typically made from cast iron or high-chromium alloy steel, and they may have cracks, porosity, or other defects from previous service. The repair procedure must include a thorough inspection and preparation of the base metal, including grinding out any cracks and ensuring the surface is clean and free of oil, grease, and oxidation. The authors likely emphasize this in their discussion of the "self-protection" aspect, which refers to the ability of the process to protect itself from contamination, but even the best self-shielded wire cannot compensate for a dirty or cracked base metal.
The second critical factor is the choice of the welding consumable. The paper mentions "self-protective" welding materials, which are flux-cored wires designed for open-arc operation. These wires are available in a range of compositions, from martensitic stainless steel to complex carbide-forming alloys. The selection must be based on the specific wear mechanism. For abrasive wear in a cement mill, a high-chromium carbide deposit is typically the best choice, as the hard carbides resist scratching and gouging. However, the deposit must also have sufficient toughness to withstand impact loads, which can occur when large lumps of raw material fall onto the grinding table. The authors likely discuss the trade-off between hardness and toughness, which is a classic problem in hardfacing.
The third critical factor is the process parameters. Self-shielded surfacing is typically performed at high current and voltage, with a weaving motion to produce a wide, smooth bead. The travel speed must be controlled to achieve the desired deposition rate and to minimize dilution. The authors likely provide specific parameter ranges, which are essential for reproducing the results in practice. In my experience, the most common mistake is to use too high a current, which increases dilution and reduces the hardness of the deposit. Another common mistake is to use too low a voltage, which can lead to an unstable arc and poor fusion.
Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned
I have been involved in several vertical mill roller repairs, and I can confirm the advantages of self-shielded surfacing. In one case, we were called to a cement plant in the Middle East to repair a grinding roller that had suffered severe surface spalling. The roller was 3 meters in diameter and weighed over 20 tons. Removing it from the mill and transporting it to a workshop would have taken at least two weeks, causing significant production losses. Instead, we set up a self-shielded surfacing station directly in the mill, using a portable wire feeder and a DC power source. The repair was completed in five days, and the roller was returned to service with a hardfaced surface that had a hardness of 58-62 HRC.
The key to the success was the preparation. We ground out all the spalled areas, which revealed some cracks that extended into the base metal. We ground the cracks out to sound metal, then applied a buffer layer using a softer, more ductile wire, before applying the hardfacing layer. This is a critical step that the authors likely mention in their paper. A buffer layer, or "butter" layer, is essential when the base metal has a high carbon content or is difficult to weld. It prevents the hardfacing layer from cracking due to the high residual stresses that develop when a hard deposit is applied directly to a hard base metal.
The authors also mention the importance of the "self-protection" aspect, which refers to the ability of the flux core to generate a protective atmosphere. In practice, this means that the process is less sensitive to wind and draft, which is a significant advantage in an open-air repair site. However, it also means that the process generates a lot of fume, so proper ventilation and personal protective equipment are essential. I have seen welders ignore this and suffer from metal fume fever, which is a serious health hazard.
Another lesson from my experience is the importance of preheating. Grinding rollers are large, heavy components, and they act as a heat sink. Without preheating, the first few passes of hardfacing will cool rapidly, leading to the formation of martensite and potentially cracking. The authors likely recommend a preheat temperature of 150-250°C, depending on the base metal composition. In our case, we used a gas torch to preheat the roller to 200°C before starting the hardfacing, and we maintained the interpass temperature at 150-200°C throughout the repair.
Study Insights and Recommendations
This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of hardfacing repair, particularly for the cement industry. The authors have practical experience from the Zhengzhou Research Institute, which is a well-known center for hardfacing technology in China. Their findings on the flexibility and convenience of self-shielded surfacing are consistent with my own observations. However, I would add a few points based on my experience.
First, the paper does not discuss the economics of self-shielded surfacing in detail. In my experience, the cost of the consumable is a significant factor, and self-shielded wires are generally more expensive than gas-shielded wires. However, the savings in equipment and setup time often offset this. For a large roller repair, the cost of the consumable is a small fraction of the total cost, which includes downtime, labor, and equipment. The real economic benefit is the reduction in downtime, which can be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars per day for a cement plant.
Second, the paper focuses on the repair of grinding rollers, but the same technology can be applied to other components, such as table liners, separator blades, and fan blades. In my experience, the most successful repairs are those where the wear mechanism is clearly understood, and the correct consumable is selected. For example, if the wear is due to erosion by fine particles, a hard, brittle deposit may be appropriate. If the wear is due to impact, a tougher deposit is needed. The authors could have provided more guidance on this selection process, but the general principles are clear.
Third, the paper does not discuss the importance of post-weld heat treatment for large components. In practice, it is often impossible to heat treat a 20-ton roller after hardfacing, so the residual stresses must be managed through careful process control. This includes maintaining the interpass temperature, using a buffer layer, and possibly using a peening technique to introduce compressive stresses in the deposit. I have seen repairs fail because these measures were not taken, and the hardfacing layer cracked and spalled within a few weeks of service.
In conclusion, this paper provides a good overview of self-shielded surfacing technology for vertical mill components. The authors have practical experience, and their findings are reliable. The key takeaway is that self-shielded surfacing is a flexible and convenient method for repairing large grinding components, but it requires careful attention to the base metal condition, consumable selection, and process parameters. If these factors are managed correctly, the repair can extend the life of the component by several years, which is a significant economic benefit for any cement plant. The technology is not a silver bullet, but it is a valuable tool in the maintenance engineer's arsenal.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd