ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Detailed Considerations for Hardfacing Repair of Grinding Equipment Components in the Cement Industry

Core Technical Points and Process Overview

The paper by Huang Zhiquan, Yang Wei, and Li Junwei from the Zhengzhou Research Institute of Mechanical Engineering is a practical guide to the details of hardfacing repair for cement industry grinding equipment. The authors emphasize three key points: understanding the base metal properties and defects, the critical role of the buffer layer, and the importance of welding consumable characteristics such as arc stability, porosity resistance, slag distribution, detachability, and spatter rate. These are exactly the details that separate a successful repair from a failed one, and I have seen all of them cause problems in the field.

The first point, understanding the base metal, is fundamental. Grinding rollers and table liners are typically made from high-chromium cast iron or high-chromium alloy steel, which are difficult to weld due to their high carbon content and tendency to form hard, brittle phases in the HAZ. The authors stress that the repair procedure must start with a thorough inspection of the base metal, including non-destructive testing to detect cracks, porosity, and other defects. In my experience, this is the most commonly overlooked step. Many repair shops simply grind out the worn surface and start hardfacing, without checking for cracks that may extend deep into the base metal. These cracks will propagate under service loads and cause the hardfacing layer to spall, leading to a repeat repair and additional downtime.

The second point, the buffer layer, is crucial for preventing cracking. The buffer layer, also known as a "butter" layer, is a soft, ductile deposit that is applied directly to the base metal before the hardfacing layer. It serves as a transition between the base metal and the hard, brittle hardfacing layer, absorbing the residual stresses that develop during cooling. The authors emphasize that the buffer layer must be carefully selected, and the wire must be chosen based on the base metal composition. In my experience, a nickel-based or austenitic stainless steel wire is often used for this purpose, as it has good ductility and can accommodate the thermal expansion mismatch between the base metal and the hardfacing layer. Without a buffer layer, the hardfacing layer will crack, especially on large components where the residual stresses are high.

The third point, the characteristics of the welding consumable, is often underestimated. The authors list arc stability, porosity resistance, slag distribution, detachability, and spatter rate as key technical indicators. These are not just quality issues; they directly affect the productivity and cost of the repair. For example, poor arc stability leads to an uneven deposit and increased dilution, which reduces the hardness and wear resistance. Porosity in the deposit creates stress raisers that can initiate cracks. Poor slag detachability increases the cleaning time between passes, which reduces productivity and can lead to slag inclusions in the deposit. High spatter rate wastes material and increases the risk of contamination. In my experience, the choice of consumable is often based on price, but the cheapest wire is rarely the most economical in the long run. A high-quality wire that produces a smooth, dense deposit will reduce the repair time and extend the service life, which more than compensates for the higher initial cost.

Practical Implications for Cement Plant Maintenance

The authors' emphasis on the "details" of hardfacing repair is well-placed. In the cement industry, the cost of downtime is enormous, and a repair that fails prematurely is a double loss: the cost of the repair itself, plus the cost of the additional downtime. The key to a successful repair is to follow a systematic procedure that addresses all the critical factors.

First, the base metal must be properly prepared. This includes grinding out all cracks and defects, and ensuring the surface is clean and free of oil, grease, and oxidation. The authors likely recommend a magnetic particle or dye penetrant inspection to detect surface cracks, and ultrasonic testing to detect subsurface defects. In my experience, the most common defect in used grinding rollers is a network of thermal fatigue cracks, which are caused by the cyclic heating and cooling of the surface during service. These cracks can be shallow, but they often extend deep into the base metal. If they are not completely removed, they will propagate under the hardfacing layer and cause spalling.

Second, the buffer layer must be applied correctly. The authors emphasize that the buffer layer plays a "connecting" role between the base metal and the hardfacing layer. The buffer layer must be thick enough to provide adequate stress relief, typically 3-5 mm, but not so thick that it reduces the effective thickness of the hardfacing layer. The buffer layer should be applied at a lower current and a slower travel speed to minimize dilution and ensure good fusion with the base metal. In my experience, the most common mistake is to apply the buffer layer too thin, which allows the hardfacing layer to crack. Another common mistake is to use the same wire for the buffer layer as for the hardfacing layer, which defeats the purpose of the buffer layer.

Third, the hardfacing layer must be applied with the correct process parameters. The authors likely provide specific ranges for current, voltage, travel speed, and weaving pattern. These parameters must be adjusted based on the size and shape of the component, the position of the weld, and the type of consumable. In my experience, the most common mistake is to use too high a current, which increases dilution and reduces the hardness of the deposit. Another common mistake is to use too low a voltage, which leads to an unstable arc and poor fusion. The interpass temperature must also be controlled, typically in the range of 150-250°C, to prevent the formation of martensite in the HAZ.

Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned

I have been involved in numerous hardfacing repairs of cement grinding equipment, and I can share a few lessons from my experience. In one case, we were asked to repair a table liner from a vertical mill that had suffered from severe abrasive wear. The liner was made from high-chromium cast iron, and it had a network of cracks on the surface. The repair shop that had previously attempted the repair had simply ground the surface and applied a hardfacing layer without a buffer layer. The hardfacing layer cracked and spalled within a month of service.

We took over the repair and implemented a proper procedure. First, we ground out all the cracks to sound metal, which required removing about 10 mm of material in some areas. We then applied a nickel-based buffer layer, 4 mm thick, using a GTAW process to ensure good fusion with the cast iron base metal. After the buffer layer, we applied a high-chromium carbide hardfacing layer, 8 mm thick, using a self-shielded flux-cored wire. The interpass temperature was maintained at 200°C, and we used a weaving pattern to produce a smooth, uniform deposit. The repair took three days, and the liner was returned to service. It lasted for 18 months, which was a significant improvement over the previous repair.

The key lesson from this case is the importance of the buffer layer. Without it, the hardfacing layer will crack, regardless of the quality of the hardfacing wire. The buffer layer provides a ductile transition that absorbs the residual stresses and prevents crack propagation. This is a fundamental principle of hardfacing repair, and the authors are correct to emphasize it.

Another lesson from my experience is the importance of consumable selection. In one case, we used a low-cost hardfacing wire that had poor arc stability and high spatter. The deposit was uneven, and we had to spend a lot of time cleaning the slag between passes. The final deposit had some porosity, which we detected by ultrasonic testing. We had to grind out the porous areas and re-weld them, which added two days to the repair. The cost of the additional time and labor was far greater than the savings from the low-cost wire. This experience taught me that the consumable is a small fraction of the total repair cost, and it is always worth paying for a high-quality product.

Study Insights and Recommendations

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in hardfacing repair of cement grinding equipment. The authors have practical experience from the Zhengzhou Research Institute, and their emphasis on the "details" is well-founded. The three key points they identify — base metal preparation, buffer layer selection, and consumable characteristics — are exactly the factors that determine the success or failure of a repair.

However, I would add a few points based on my own experience. First, the authors do not discuss the importance of preheating and interpass temperature control in detail. For large components, preheating is essential to prevent the formation of martensite in the HAZ, which can lead to cold cracking. The interpass temperature must be maintained within a specific range to ensure consistent deposit properties. In my experience, a preheat temperature of 150-250°C is typical for high-chromium cast iron, and the interpass temperature should be maintained at 150-200°C.

Second, the authors do not discuss the importance of post-weld heat treatment for large components. In practice, it is often impossible to heat treat a large roller or table liner after hardfacing, so the residual stresses must be managed through process control. This includes using a buffer layer, maintaining the interpass temperature, and possibly using a peening technique to introduce compressive stresses in the deposit. I have seen repairs fail because these measures were not taken.

Third, the authors do not discuss the importance of non-destructive testing after the repair. In my experience, a magnetic particle inspection or ultrasonic testing should be performed after the hardfacing is complete to detect any cracks or lack of fusion. This is essential for ensuring the quality of the repair and preventing premature failure.

In conclusion, this paper provides a practical guide to the details of hardfacing repair for cement grinding equipment. The authors' emphasis on base metal preparation, buffer layer selection, and consumable characteristics is well-placed, and their findings are consistent with my own experience. The key takeaway is that a successful hardfacing repair requires attention to detail at every step of the process. Skipping any of these details can lead to a premature failure, which is a costly mistake for any cement plant. The paper is a valuable reference for maintenance engineers and repair shop personnel, and I would recommend it to anyone involved in this type of work.