ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Numerical Simulation of the Temperature Field in Plunger Overlay Welding Using ANSYS

Overview and Context

This paper by Zhang Guozheng presents a finite element analysis of the temperature field during the overlay welding of a 45 steel plunger. The author uses ANSYS to perform a three-dimensional transient thermal analysis, and compares the temperature distributions obtained at different welding speeds. The goal is to provide a basis for optimizing the welding process and for subsequent structural fatigue analysis of the welded joint.

For anyone involved in the overlay welding of cylindrical components — whether plungers, hydraulic cylinders, or pipe ends — this paper is a useful demonstration of how numerical simulation can be used to understand the thermal history and to guide process development. The author's approach is straightforward and the results are presented clearly.

Technical Points and Interpretation

The paper uses a moving heat source model to simulate the welding arc. The heat input is applied to the surface of the plunger, and the model accounts for heat conduction within the material, convection to the surrounding air, and radiation from the hot surface. The material properties (thermal conductivity, specific heat, and density) are defined as functions of temperature, which is essential for an accurate simulation.

The key results are the temperature distributions at different welding speeds. The author compares three welding speeds and shows the effect on the peak temperature, the size of the heat-affected zone (HAZ), and the cooling rate.

Welding Speed (mm/s) Peak Temperature (°C) HAZ Width (mm) Cooling Rate (800–500 °C, °C/s) Practical Consequence
2.0 1,850 4.5 15 Slow cooling; risk of grain growth and soft HAZ.
4.0 1,720 3.2 35 Moderate cooling; acceptable for most applications.
6.0 1,600 2.4 60 Fast cooling; risk of martensite formation in the HAZ.

The results show that as the welding speed increases, the peak temperature decreases, the HAZ narrows, and the cooling rate increases. This is consistent with the physics of welding: a faster travel speed means less heat input per unit length, and the heat is dissipated more quickly.

The author also presents the temperature distribution at a specific time during the welding process, which shows the characteristic teardrop-shaped isotherms that are typical of a moving heat source. This is a useful visual representation of the thermal field.

Practical Insights and Lessons Learned

The value of this paper lies not in the specific results for the 45 steel plunger, but in the demonstration of the methodology. In my experience, numerical simulation of welding temperature fields is a powerful tool for process development, but it must be used with care. The accuracy of the simulation depends entirely on the accuracy of the material properties and the boundary conditions.

I have used similar simulations to optimize the overlay welding of pipe ends for CRA lined pipe. The challenge is to achieve a uniform temperature distribution across the weld, which is critical for controlling distortion and residual stress. The simulation allowed us to vary the welding sequence and the heat input to find a combination that minimized the temperature gradient.

One practical lesson from this paper is the importance of the cooling rate in determining the microstructure of the HAZ. In the case of 45 steel, which is a medium-carbon steel, a fast cooling rate can lead to the formation of martensite, which is hard and brittle and can cause cracking. The simulation shows that the welding speed must be carefully selected to avoid this.

Another lesson is the importance of the boundary conditions. The author uses a convection coefficient and an emissivity for radiation, but these values are not always well known. In practice, it is often necessary to calibrate the model against experimental measurements, such as thermocouple readings or infrared camera images. Without this calibration, the simulation results can be misleading.

I would also note that the simulation of the temperature field is only the first step. The next step is to use the temperature history to predict the residual stress and distortion, which requires a coupled thermal-mechanical analysis. This is more complex but is essential for predicting the final shape and the service performance of the component.

Conclusion and Reflection

This paper is a useful example of how finite element analysis can be applied to the overlay welding process. The author has demonstrated that ANSYS can be used to simulate the three-dimensional temperature field and to compare the effects of different welding speeds. The results are consistent with the expected physics and provide a basis for process optimization. For engineers involved in overlay welding, the key takeaway is that numerical simulation is a valuable tool, but it must be used with a clear understanding of its limitations. The material properties must be accurate, the boundary conditions must be realistic, and the model must be validated against experimental data. I would recommend that any simulation study be accompanied by a limited set of welding trials with thermocouple measurements to verify the model. This paper is a good starting point for anyone who wants to apply simulation to their own welding processes. The methodology is sound, and the results are presented in a clear and useful manner. The next step for the author would be to extend the model to predict residual stress and distortion, which would make the simulation even more valuable for practical applications.