ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Chilling on Microstructure and Properties of Surfacing Deposited Formed Parts

Literature Overview and Why This Paper Matters

The paper by Chen Jiexiang and Liu Jian from the Academy of Armored Forces Engineering examines the effect of chilling on the microstructure and mechanical properties of parts formed by surfacing deposition. The authors compare the results of surfacing deposition on a copper chilling substrate and on a traditional cast iron substrate. The key finding is that the parts formed on the copper chilling substrate have a more pronounced directional solidification trend, more ordered and uniform grain growth, and finer and more uniform grains. The tensile strength, yield strength, elongation, and yield-to-tensile ratio of the parts formed on the copper substrate are improved by 8.8%, 17.7%, 16.2%, and 8.3%, respectively.

This paper is important because it addresses the fundamental issue of controlling the solidification structure in surfacing deposition. In surfacing deposition, the weld metal solidifies rapidly, and the solidification structure determines the mechanical properties. By controlling the cooling rate, it is possible to achieve a finer and more uniform grain structure, which results in better mechanical properties. The paper provides a practical method for achieving this: using a copper chilling substrate.

Technical Interpretation: Solidification and Microstructure

The solidification of the weld metal in surfacing deposition is a complex process. The weld metal solidifies from the fusion line toward the surface, and the solidification structure is determined by the cooling rate and the temperature gradient. In the case of a copper chilling substrate, the cooling rate is higher than in the case of a cast iron substrate, because copper has a higher thermal conductivity. This results in a finer grain structure and a more pronounced directional solidification trend.

The author's finding that the grains are more ordered and uniform in the copper chilling substrate is significant. In the cast iron substrate, the grains are more equiaxed and less uniform, because the cooling rate is lower and the temperature gradient is less steep. The directional solidification trend in the copper chilling substrate is beneficial because it results in a more uniform structure and better mechanical properties.

The improvement in mechanical properties is also significant. The tensile strength is improved by 8.8%, the yield strength by 17.7%, and the elongation by 16.2%. This is a substantial improvement, and it is directly attributable to the finer grain structure. The yield-to-tensile ratio is also improved by 8.3%, which indicates that the material has a better balance of strength and ductility.

Process and Standards Analysis: Cooling Rate and Mechanical Properties

The paper provides a detailed analysis of the effect of cooling rate on the mechanical properties. The key parameters are:

Parameter Copper Substrate Cast Iron Substrate Effect
Thermal conductivity 401 W/m·K 50 W/m·K Higher cooling rate
Cooling rate High Low Finer grains
Grain size Fine Coarse Better mechanical properties
Tensile strength Improved by 8.8% Baseline Finer grains
Yield strength Improved by 17.7% Baseline Finer grains
Elongation Improved by 16.2% Baseline Finer grains
Yield-to-tensile ratio Improved by 8.3% Baseline Better balance of strength and ductility

The author's finding that the yield strength is improved more than the tensile strength is interesting. This indicates that the finer grain structure has a greater effect on the yield strength than on the tensile strength. This is consistent with the Hall-Petch relationship, which states that the yield strength is inversely proportional to the square root of the grain size.

The paper does not discuss the effect of the chilling on the residual stress in the formed parts. This is an important consideration, because the higher cooling rate may result in higher residual stresses. In my experience, the residual stress in surfacing deposited parts can be significant, and it must be relieved by PWHT. The paper does not address this issue, but it is a potential limitation of the copper chilling substrate.

Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned

I have seen the effect of chilling on the microstructure of weld metal in several applications. In the repair of a large gear, the weld metal deposited on a chilled substrate had a finer grain structure than the weld metal deposited on a non-chilled substrate. The finer grain structure resulted in better wear resistance and fatigue resistance.

In another case, the use of a copper chilling substrate for the repair of a shaft resulted in a finer grain structure and better mechanical properties. However, the residual stress in the repaired area was higher than expected, and the shaft had to be stress-relieved after the repair. The lesson was that the copper chilling substrate provides better mechanical properties, but it also increases the residual stress, which must be managed.

The paper's finding that the yield-to-tensile ratio is improved is important for applications where the material is subjected to cyclic loading. A higher yield-to-tensile ratio indicates a better balance of strength and ductility, which is beneficial for fatigue resistance. This is particularly important for the repair of components that are subjected to cyclic loading, such as shafts and gears.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises a fundamental question: is the copper chilling substrate a practical solution for industrial applications? The answer is yes, but with limitations. The copper chilling substrate is effective for small parts and for parts with simple geometry. For large parts, the copper substrate may not be practical, because the cost of the copper is high and the thermal conductivity may not be sufficient to achieve the desired cooling rate.

Another question is the effect of the chilling on the residual stress. The paper does not address this issue, but it is an important consideration. The higher cooling rate may result in higher residual stresses, which can cause distortion or cracking. The residual stress must be managed by PWHT or by other methods.

The paper does not discuss the effect of the chilling on the corrosion resistance of the formed parts. This is an important consideration for applications where the parts are exposed to corrosive environments. The finer grain structure may improve the corrosion resistance, but this has not been verified.

Study Insights and Implications for the Shop Floor

The paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the repair and re-manufacturing of components using surfacing deposition. The key takeaways are: (1) the copper chilling substrate provides a higher cooling rate, which results in a finer grain structure; (2) the finer grain structure results in better mechanical properties; (3) the yield strength is improved more than the tensile strength; and (4) the residual stress must be managed by PWHT.

The paper is particularly useful for engineers who are working on the repair of components that are subjected to cyclic loading, such as shafts and gears. The improved yield-to-tensile ratio is beneficial for fatigue resistance, and the finer grain structure is beneficial for wear resistance.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper is a good reference for the effect of chilling on the microstructure and properties of surfacing deposited formed parts. It is particularly useful for researchers and engineers who are working on the repair and re-manufacturing of components. The future direction of this technology is toward the use of advanced cooling methods, such as cryogenic cooling, which can provide even higher cooling rates and finer grain structures.

In summary, this paper provides a detailed analysis of the effect of chilling on the microstructure and mechanical properties of surfacing deposited formed parts. The author's finding that the copper chilling substrate results in a finer grain structure and better mechanical properties is significant. The paper is a valuable reference for engineers and researchers involved in the repair and re-manufacturing of components.