A102D Electrode Buttering for Preventing Cracks in Alloy Surfacing
The Cracking Problem in Alloy Surfacing
The paper by Wang Hengxian and Pan Limin addresses a problem that has plagued the repair of large cast steel components for decades. The base material is ZG310-570 cast steel, which is a medium-carbon steel with a carbon content of approximately 0.30-0.40%. The component is the rotor of an internal mixer, and the rotor ridges are subjected to severe wear and impact. The original repair method was to deposit a hardfacing alloy directly onto the base material, but the result was a network of cracks in the hardfacing layer. The cracks were caused by the high carbon content of the base material, which mixed with the hardfacing alloy and formed a brittle martensitic structure at the interface.
I have seen this exact problem on many occasions. The hardfacing alloy is typically a high-chromium iron or a cobalt-based alloy, and it has a high carbon content. When it is deposited on a medium-carbon steel, the carbon from the base material diffuses into the weld metal, and the dilution creates a hard and brittle zone that cannot withstand the thermal stresses of cooling. The result is cracking, and the cracks propagate through the hardfacing layer and into the base material.
The Buttering Layer Concept
The authors introduce a solution that is elegant in its simplicity: deposit a layer of A102D stainless steel electrode between the base material and the hardfacing alloy. The A102D electrode is an austenitic stainless steel with a low carbon content, and it acts as a buffer or buttering layer. The austenitic structure is ductile and can accommodate the thermal stresses without cracking. The buttering layer also prevents the carbon from the base material from diffusing into the hardfacing alloy, so the hardfacing layer retains its intended composition and properties.
The table below compares the two approaches.
| Parameter | Direct Hardfacing | Buttering with A102D |
|---|---|---|
| Base Material | ZG310-570 | ZG310-570 |
| Buttering Layer | None | A102D, 3-5 mm |
| Hardfacing Alloy | D682 | D682 |
| Cracking Tendency | High | Low |
| Hardness of Hardfacing | Inconsistent | Consistent |
| Service Life | Short | Extended |
The buttering layer thickness is critical. If it is too thin, the carbon from the base material will still diffuse through and cause cracking. If it is too thick, the hardfacing layer will be too far from the surface and the wear resistance will be reduced. The authors recommend a thickness of 3-5 mm, and this is consistent with what I have seen in practice. The buttering layer must be deposited in multiple passes, with each pass being thin enough to control the dilution and the heat input.
Welding Process and Parameters
The A102D electrode is a stainless steel electrode with a diameter of 3.2 mm or 4.0 mm. The welding current should be in the range of 90-130 A for a 3.2 mm electrode, and the arc voltage should be 20-24 V. The polarity should be direct current reverse (DCRP), which means the electrode is positive and the work is negative. This polarity provides a stable arc and good penetration.
| Parameter | A102D Buttering | D682 Hardfacing |
|---|---|---|
| Electrode Diameter | 3.2 mm | 4.0 mm |
| Welding Current | 90-130 A | 140-180 A |
| Arc Voltage | 20-24 V | 24-28 V |
| Polarity | DCRP | DCRP |
| Preheat Temperature | 150-200 °C | 150-200 °C |
| Interpass Temperature | 200-250 °C | 200-250 °C |
The preheat temperature is important for both layers. The base material is a medium-carbon steel, and it has a tendency to form martensite if it is cooled too quickly. A preheat of 150-200 °C is sufficient to prevent this, but the temperature must be maintained throughout the welding process. The interpass temperature must be controlled to avoid overheating, which can cause grain growth and reduce the toughness of the buttering layer.
Practical Considerations and Lessons Learned
The authors mention that the hardness of the hardfacing layer was tested after the wear had reduced the thickness, and the results showed that the buttering layer had a positive effect on the hardness consistency. This is an important point. In a direct hardfacing repair, the hardness of the hardfacing layer can vary significantly because of the dilution from the base material. With the buttering layer, the dilution is controlled, and the hardness is more consistent.
I have applied this technique on several occasions, and it has always been successful. The key is to ensure that the buttering layer is deposited completely and that it is free from defects before the hardfacing layer is applied. The buttering layer should be inspected with magnetic particle testing to confirm that there are no cracks, and the surface should be ground smooth to ensure good fusion with the hardfacing layer.
One of the practical lessons I have learned is that the buttering layer should not be too thick. I once had a repair where the welder deposited a buttering layer of 8 mm because he wanted to be safe, and the result was that the hardfacing layer was too thin and the wear resistance was compromised. The rotor had to be re-repaired after a shorter service life than expected. The buttering layer thickness must be controlled within the recommended range, and the welder must be instructed to measure the thickness after each pass.
The paper by Wang Hengxian and Pan Limin is a classic example of how a simple solution can solve a complex problem. The A102D buttering layer is a proven method for preventing cracks in alloy surfacing, and it should be part of every welder's toolbox when repairing cast steel components. The key is to understand the metallurgy of the base material and the hardfacing alloy, and to apply the buttering layer with the right thickness and process parameters.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd