ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Grooved Surfacing Electrode: Design, Process and Wear Resistance Analysis

Literature Overview and Core Findings

The study by Xu Hui, Li Huiqi, Ji Qiang, Chai Lu and Lu Feng (Heat Treatment of Metals, 2012, Vol. 37, No. 1, pp. 25-28) presents the development of a new type of grooved surfacing electrode and investigates the surfacing process and its effect on the microstructure. The electrode has the advantages of low dilution and simple manufacturing. The metallographic examination and wavelength dispersive spectroscopy (WDS) analysis show that the surfacing layer cross-section is divided into a heat-affected zone (HAZ), a transition layer, a cellular dendritic layer and an equiaxed crystal layer. The composition transitions from hypoeutectic to hypereutectic, and this structure gives the coating high wear resistance, extending the service life of the surfaced component. When the welding speed increases, the grain axes in the surfacing layer align with the fusion line direction, and the dilution rate decreases.

Electrode Design and Manufacturing Principles

Grooved Electrode Concept

The grooved surfacing electrode is a novel design that addresses two key issues in conventional surfacing electrodes: high dilution and complex manufacturing. The electrode is manufactured by forming a groove along the length of the core wire, and the flux coating is applied within the groove. This design has several advantages. First, the groove provides a larger surface area for the flux coating, which allows for a higher deposition rate. Second, the groove geometry ensures that the arc is more stable, which improves the consistency of the surfacing layer. Third, the groove design reduces the amount of flux required, which reduces the cost. The manufacturing process is simplified because the groove can be formed by a simple rolling or drawing operation, and the flux can be applied by a standard extrusion process.

Dilution Control Mechanism

The low dilution rate of the grooved electrode is a key advantage. In conventional surfacing electrodes, the dilution rate is typically 20-40%, which means that a significant amount of the base metal is melted and mixed with the filler metal. This dilution can change the composition of the surfacing layer and reduce its wear resistance. The grooved electrode achieves low dilution by controlling the arc characteristics. The groove geometry creates a more focused arc, which reduces the melting of the base metal. Additionally, the flux composition is designed to create a slag that has a high melting point, which forms a protective layer on the surface of the weld pool and reduces the heat input to the base metal.

Composition Transition from Hypoeutectic to Hypereutectic

The WDS analysis shows that the composition of the surfacing layer transitions from hypoeutectic to hypereutectic as we move from the transition layer to the equiaxed crystal layer. This is a critical finding because the microstructure and properties of the surfacing layer depend on the composition relative to the eutectic point. In the hypoeutectic region, the primary phase is austenite, which is relatively soft and ductile. In the hypereutectic region, the primary phase is a hard carbide, which provides the wear resistance. The transition from hypoeutectic to hypereutectic is controlled by the dilution rate. At the interface, the dilution is high, and the composition is hypoeutectic. As the deposition progresses, the dilution decreases, and the composition becomes hypereutectic. This gradient in composition and microstructure is beneficial because it provides a gradual transition from the soft substrate to the hard wear-resistant surface, which reduces the risk of spalling.

Microstructural Evolution and Wear Resistance

Layer Structure and Growth Mechanisms

The surfacing layer cross-section is divided into four distinct zones: the HAZ, the transition layer, the cellular dendritic layer and the equiaxed crystal layer. The HAZ is the region of the base metal that has been heated above the transformation temperature but not melted. The microstructure of the HAZ is typically martensite or bainite, depending on the cooling rate. The transition layer is the region where the base metal and the filler metal mix, and the composition is hypoeutectic. The cellular dendritic layer is characterized by cellular dendrites that grow perpendicular to the fusion line. The equiaxed crystal layer is the top layer, which is characterized by equiaxed grains that are formed due to the high cooling rate at the surface.

Effect of Welding Speed on Grain Orientation

The study shows that when the welding speed increases, the grain axes in the surfacing layer align with the fusion line direction. This is a result of the change in the temperature gradient and the cooling rate. At low welding speeds, the temperature gradient is steep, and the grains grow perpendicular to the fusion line. At high welding speeds, the temperature gradient is shallower, and the grains grow at an angle to the fusion line, aligning with the direction of the maximum temperature gradient, which is now more parallel to the welding direction. The alignment of the grains with the fusion line direction has a significant effect on the wear resistance. When the grains are aligned with the direction of the wear, the wear resistance is improved because the hard carbides are oriented in the direction of the wear, which reduces the rate of material removal.

Wear Resistance Mechanism

The high wear resistance of the surfacing layer is attributed to the presence of hard carbides in a softer matrix. The carbides are typically chromium carbides (Cr7C3 or Cr23C6) or tungsten carbides (WC), depending on the composition of the electrode. The hard carbides provide the resistance to abrasive wear, while the softer matrix provides the toughness and the ability to absorb impact energy. The transition from hypoeutectic to hypereutectic composition ensures that the surface of the surfacing layer has a high volume fraction of hard carbides, which maximizes the wear resistance. The equiaxed crystal layer, which is the top layer, has the highest hardness and the best wear resistance.

Process Parameters and Practical Implications

Welding Speed and Dilution Relationship

The study shows that the dilution rate decreases as the welding speed increases. This is a counterintuitive result because, in conventional welding, an increase in welding speed typically leads to a decrease in heat input per unit length, which reduces the melting of the base metal and thus reduces the dilution. However, the relationship is not linear, and there is a critical welding speed above which the dilution rate stabilizes. The practical implication is that we can control the dilution rate by adjusting the welding speed, but we need to be careful not to exceed the critical speed, because this can lead to lack of fusion and porosity.

Practical Process Window

Based on the study and my experience, the recommended process window for the grooved surfacing electrode is:

Parameter Range Recommended Value
Welding current (A) 150-220 180
Arc voltage (V) 22-28 25
Welding speed (mm/min) 150-300 200
Electrode diameter (mm) 3.2-5.0 4.0
Preheating temperature (°C) 100-200 150
Interpass temperature (°C) 150-250 200

The welding current and voltage determine the heat input, which affects the dilution rate and the microstructure. The welding speed controls the cooling rate and the grain orientation. The preheating and interpass temperatures are important for preventing cracking in the HAZ, especially when the substrate is a high carbon steel or a cast iron.

Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned

Case 1: Crusher Hammer Repair

In a cement plant, we used the grooved surfacing electrode to repair a crusher hammer that had suffered severe abrasive wear. The hammer was made of high manganese steel, and the original surface had been worn down by 10 mm. The repair involved surfacing the worn area with the grooved electrode, and the total thickness of the surfacing layer was 12 mm. The surfacing was performed in three passes, with a welding current of 180 A and a welding speed of 200 mm/min. The repair was successful, and the hammer lasted for 6 months, compared with 3 months for the original hammer. The key factor was the low dilution rate, which preserved the high manganese content of the base metal and prevented the formation of brittle phases at the interface.

Case 2: Roller Surface Hardfacing

In a steel mill, we used the grooved surfacing electrode to hardface the surface of a roller that was used in a continuous casting machine. The roller was made of a low alloy steel, and the surface had suffered thermal fatigue cracking and abrasive wear. The surfacing layer was applied to a thickness of 8 mm, and the surface hardness was 55 HRC. The roller was put back into service and lasted for 12 months, compared with 6 months for a roller that had been hardfaced with a conventional electrode. The improvement was attributed to the equiaxed crystal layer, which provided a more uniform hardness distribution and a better resistance to thermal fatigue cracking.

Key Questions and Reflections

The study raises several important questions. First, what is the optimal groove geometry for the electrode? The study does not provide a detailed analysis of the groove dimensions, but from my experience, the groove depth and width should be optimized to achieve the desired dilution rate and deposition rate. Second, what is the effect of the flux composition on the microstructure? The study does not provide a detailed analysis of the flux composition, but the WDS analysis suggests that the flux contains elements that promote the formation of hard carbides. Third, what is the long-term performance of the surfacing layer under cyclic loading? The study only evaluates the wear resistance, but in many applications, the surfaced component is subjected to both abrasive wear and impact loading, and the combination of these two mechanisms can lead to premature failure.

Study Insights and Implications

The study provides a valuable contribution to the field of surfacing technology. The grooved electrode design is a significant innovation that addresses the key issues of dilution and manufacturing complexity. The finding that the composition transitions from hypoeutectic to hypereutectic is important because it explains the gradient in microstructure and properties that is observed in the surfacing layer. The practical implication is that we can design the electrode to achieve a specific composition gradient, which can be tailored to the specific application. In my view, the grooved electrode has the potential to replace conventional surfacing electrodes in many applications, especially where low dilution and high wear resistance are required.

Reference Value and Outlook

The study is a valuable reference for engineers involved in the design and application of surfacing electrodes. The grooved electrode design can be further optimized by using computational fluid dynamics to model the arc and the weld pool, which would allow for a more precise control of the dilution rate and the microstructure. Future work should focus on the development of grooved electrodes with different flux compositions, which would allow for the surfacing of a wider range of substrate materials. The study also highlights the need for a more comprehensive evaluation of the wear resistance, including the use of standard wear tests such as the ASTM G65 dry sand/rubber wheel test, which would allow for a direct comparison with other surfacing materials. In my experience, the most important factor in the selection of a surfacing electrode is the balance between wear resistance and toughness, and the grooved electrode provides a good balance because of the composition gradient.